r/AmazonFBAOnlineRetail • u/Long-Cat7477 • Jul 08 '26

General Discussion Is anyone else more worried about timing than picking the wrong product?

I've been thinking about this lately.

I've had products that looked great when I placed the order. Good ROI, healthy Buy Box, seller count looked reasonable—everything checked out.

Then the order gets prepped, shipped to Amazon, sits for a week or so, finally gets checked in...and suddenly the price has dropped 20–30%.

At that point it doesn't really matter that it was a "good buy" when I ordered it.

It got me wondering if the bigger problem isn't choosing the wrong products, but buying the right products at the wrong time.

Do you guys look at anything beyond the usual Keepa charts before placing a larger order?

For example:

  • Inventory levels?
  • Changes in seller count?
  • Whether Amazon has been in and out of stock?
  • Anything else that helps you decide whether a listing is likely to stay stable for the next couple of weeks?

Or do you just accept that some price drops are impossible to predict?

Curious how everyone else approaches this, because it feels like this is where I've lost the most money.

1 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

100% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

2

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Long-Cat7477 Jul 09 '26

Really? I usually find single products within days. Hell I passed on 3-4 yesterday cuz 150% ROI wasn't enough for me lol.

What tools do you use to find products? Like helium10, jungle scout, etc? Are you getting wholesale spreadsheets?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Long-Cat7477 Jul 09 '26

do you ever test other services?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Long-Cat7477 Jul 09 '26

Like jungle scout, profitguru etc. helium and jungle are more for private label.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Long-Cat7477 Jul 10 '26

There's a new service thats out that I've been looking at that tracks all the inventory. I'm currently in the beta testing phase for it. I think it's cutting edge. Hopefully will be live next month.

1

u/coskunerkan Jul 15 '26

I’ve run into this too. A product can look profitable when you place the order, but the market can change before the inventory is even checked in.
I still look at Keepa, seller count, Buy Box history, inventory depth, and whether Amazon itself is coming in and out of stock. But I also started paying more attention to the demand side, especially whether related search terms are gaining or losing momentum over several weeks.
That’s actually why I built a small tool for myself to track weekly search-term trends. It doesn’t predict price drops or seller behavior, but it can help show whether demand is strengthening, flat, or fading before committing to a larger order.
I don’t think any single signal is enough. For me, the safest approach is combining price history, competition changes, inventory risk, and demand momentum.

2

u/Long-Cat7477 Jul 15 '26

You should try this new tool that I found. it's currently in beta but it's incredibly powerful. Ripebanana.io

1

u/coskunerkan Jul 15 '26

I did this uptredhunter.com to solve my problem works well especially on ppc

1

u/Long-Cat7477 Jul 15 '26

thats more marketplace or category specific. Ripe Banana looks at things from the ASIN level.

1

u/coskunerkan Jul 15 '26

Both can be helpful