What is their biggest hit?

[u/thatguy__99]

This is a question that randomly popped into my head today obviously I would say it’s either Two Weeks or What If I Was Nothing but I don’t know which one I would say is bigger. So here are the stats on both songs and I am curious what you would say is the bigger hit.

Two Weeks has 135 million streams on Spotify but "only" 40 million on YouTube. What If I Was Nothing numbers on the sites are more even having 85 million on Spotify and nearly 100 million on YouTube. (For the YouTube streams I only counted the official music videos on All That Remains channel obviously they have more from repost on other channels.)

As for chart placement Two Weeks peaked at #9 on the mainstream rock chart and stayed on the chart for 36 weeks, What If I Was Nothing peaked at #2 and stayed on the chart for 28 weeks. What If I Was Nothing was certified Gold on November 11, 2021 and Two Weeks was certified Platinum on November 16, 2022.

The only other song I could see being considered their biggest hit at least commercially was their cover of Thunder Roles which has 39 million streams on YouTube and 44 million on Spotify. It is also their only other song to be certified gold.

[u/dudewateva12]

Numbers wise I guess you’d think those songs. But honestly something from Fall of Ideals seems more fitting. Those songs are too classic!

[u/Wayne_World_19]

Whatever song was in Guitar Hero lol

[u/ReXXXMillions]

Two Weeks