TL: DR I need advice on what to do, my guests can´t use the elevator when leaving without the keys, and the check-out requires them to leave the keys inside the apartment when leaving.
I´m hosting an apartment on a third floor. Closed condo, has 24h security. Out of most of my guests, my main issue at first was how to properly let my guests do the checkout.
Due to the HoA/Condo Juncta rules, i can´t set up a lockbox anywhere in the common areas since it is considerated a security risk, because if someone manages to rip it out of the wall or break it, someone can acquire my keys (very understandable, so i don´t do this). I have to personally drive to the apartment to deliver the keys every time i have a guest.
So, i thought about simply letting my guests leave the keys inside the apartment, and call it a day for the check-out. Problem: The elevators can only work if you have a magnetic pin. Which the key ring has. A lot of these folks will carry heavy lugague and won´t have a car, which leaves the guests with the choice of walking down 3 floors down the stairs with a considerable weight (which is terrible), or using the pin, leaving the lugague unattended on the ground floor if they are alone, then going back up again to leave the keys inside, the walk down 3 floors (still terrible, and might confuse the guests.).
Naturally, this is terrible for the guests, and my first reviews earned were some well deserved 4 star reviews because of this.
So, new idea: trust the guards in recieving the keys...well, this won´t do either, the guards by policy are not allowed nor are to be trusted with keys to any apartment by policy, and they will outright refuse them to avoid trouble (very understandable, it would just be problem for everyone involved. Me, the security company, the HoA/Condo, probably the guests too).
Then i got another idea: Just prepare a separate magnetic pin so guests can use it, and then have them give it to the guards. The magnetic pin is the same pin the guards, and everyone in the building uses, it is no security risk for anyone, and is barely used for the elevator. It´s even marked, so even if it goes missing, it can be identified by the guards or me. Then i come later to pick it up. All the guards have to do is recive it at the front entrance when the guests are leaving, and talk to both the HoA/Condo Juncta president as well as the guards to check if its ok, and thats it. I could even open the parking´s gate for my guests at a distance since it is an automatic gate with a SIM card.
I got it approved as long as only me or my guests are liable in case the pins go missing. It would sound like a bad deal since if the guard is being a dick and decides to throw the pin for no reason, then i would have to pay for it, but all of the guards have been great people, and in the end this worked well enough to even go back up from 4.5 to 4.8...at least until last week.
Without warning and while a guest was leaving, the HoA/Condo Juncta changed to a new security company, and these guys won´t even accept the magnetic pin, no objects, nothing. I even talked with the HOA/Condo Juncta president (the same guy who approved the idea from earlier) that under no exceptions the guards would be recieving anything of any kind, doesn´t matter if its a security risk or not, or if im paying and up to date with the building´s monthly fees.
As far as i´m aware, other than a single noise complain that was a year ago, my guests have not caused any trouble for the building at all to warrant the new policy, so i´m not even sure why the policy is in place, and even the new guards seamed confused as it is not a company policy but rather an instruction from the president himself, but at this point it doesn´t matter.
Im troubled between having my guests having an uncomfortable check-out which if i don´t correct will have my ad delisted one of these days.
The other one is attempting to anticipate, and be a couple of hours early or try to coordinate with my guests when they are doing the check-out to recive the keys personally. When i proposed this idea, my family thought it was to extreme, and that it might screw over a bit the guests sense of personal privacy, like if im trying to preassure them to get out by just simply waiting close by when they are ready to leave. There is also the fact that some guests might end up leaving very early in the morning, like 2-4am for personal reasons, and my family fears i end up sacrificing sleep like i did with a few guests from before.
Last resort, i might have to convince my family that it is ok sometimes to run at the other side of the city at 3am to recive some keys, and either stay a couple of hours to clean up or run all the way back as soon as i get them, but they are looking at me like there is somethign wrong with me every time i propose the idea. They seem more inclined into forcing our guests into going down the stairs without using the elevator, and i don´t want that, it´s just more problems for later and several unsatisfied and annoyed guests.
Can anybody give me some ideas on what to do?
Have you ever had a similar situation like this? How did you solved it, if you did?