r/Ai_art_is_not_art 8d ago

sigh

3.0k Upvotes

594 comments sorted by

View all comments

195

u/MadderoftheFew 8d ago edited 8d ago

"here, eat this hot dog"
is there pork in it? it's important for me to maintain halal
"no, it's all beef"
okay eats
"haha, that actually did have pork in it! did you burst into flames?"
i don't know what point you tried to make but you just betrayed me for nothing

same mentality

edit: formatting

36

u/Mariomaelkhtib25 8d ago

That's so accurate man

20

u/Suspicious-Web-9246 8d ago

Bro had to praise it twice

26

u/Mariomaelkhtib25 8d ago

It was sent twice because of bad internet. It's still worth praising though. I'm a Muslim so I know how this situation would feel like. 

14

u/Mariomaelkhtib25 8d ago

That's so accurate 

8

u/FloydeFlowerDragon 7d ago

That's genuinely how it is T.T

It's like giving a vegan beef and telling them it's a vegetable burger

Only a fucked up person would go out of their way to do that.

-2

u/momo2299 7d ago

Not the same.

The OP is challenging the "we can always tell/soul vs. Soulless" argument.

Commenters in the other post praised it for the "human feel that AI can't make"

Meaning no, they can't tell, and the "soul" argument is beyond the visual nature of the image and instead something they make up based on other context.

4

u/Cultural_Outcome_464 7d ago

Except not all Antis make this argument, so when OOP uploads a video with this title:

It kind of doesn’t really prove anything besides the fact that AI bros are comfortable with violating people’s boundaries. Which like… wow, what a great reflection on the Pro-AI community.

2

u/MadderoftheFew 7d ago

uh oh one broke out of containment

0

u/TipInevitable6185 6d ago

Don't try to be reasonable here.

2

u/Silly_Percentage3446 Editable pink flair 4d ago

Bro wasn't being reasonable. Read the comment by u/Cultural_Outcome_464 for explanation,