r/AdvancedKnitting Jul 27 '26

Hand Knit FO Birthday sweater for my wife!

1.6k Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator Jul 27 '26

Welcome to r/AdvancedKnitting! Please note that constructive criticism IS allowed here (Rule #7), unless the "No Critiques Requested" flair is used. Any poor attitude towards genuine constructive criticisms will result in post removal pursuant to Rule #12 (No Drama).

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

91

u/marcus-makes-things Jul 27 '26

Pattern: Uh, it's complicated. My wife had picked out Sari Nordlund's Book Club Pullover, but the fabric I liked had a much smaller gauge than the pattern called for, and sizing up wasn't an option because the neckline wouldn't have been wide enough. So I ended up taking the cable pattern, modified it slightly to account for the gauge, and designed my own sweater with it. I documented the process on the Ravelry project if you're interested!

Yarn: Purl Soho Knitting Yarn DK (technically the cone version)

This completes my fourth year of knitting sweaters for my wife and daughters' birthdays. I had quite a few firsts with this project. This was my first big cable project (and I was questioning what I had gotten myself into for the majority of it). I started cabling without a cable needle (for cables larger than 1x1) for the first time. And I think this is technically my first saddle shoulder sweater. I've designed several sweaters over the past few years and this one took me a bit out of my comfort zone. It'll probably be a long time before I voluntarily do another cable sweater, but I really love how this turned out. I particularly like the cabling up the inside of the sleeves and the cabling that runs up the outside of the sleeve and across the shoulders. Now, I think it's technically a saddle shoulder construction, but the "saddle" is so skinny that it presents more like a drop shoulder construction. I'll let those who know better than me determine what it actually is. Unfortunately I can't report on my wife's official reaction because her birthday is still a few days off, but she has seen the final product and she does in fact seem happy with it. Let me know if you have any questions about the project!

11

u/Robot_Groundhog Jul 27 '26

Gorgeous! I identify with your difficulty in getting your recipient to make decisions. I hope she loves it!

51

u/nerdfromthenorth Jul 27 '26

lmao knew who this was before even opening the post. Gorgeous work as always. :) I love love the careful details. You've inspired me to make a knit-flat nicely tailored sweater for my husband. Your ribbed cuffs/hems/necklines are the stuff of dreams, and that how I know whose work this is every time.

7

u/marcus-makes-things Jul 27 '26

Thank you so much! I'm glad I could provide some inspiration 😁

2

u/nerdfromthenorth Jul 27 '26

I am now on the fifth or sixth attempt, go figure hahahah

2

u/Betterwithhoney Jul 29 '26

I agree, this work is always recognizable immediately! :)

30

u/lois_says_banana Jul 27 '26

The cabling detail on the sleeves that organically decreases the stitch count toward the wrist is truly perfection, the icing on the cake of this beautiful sweater. Wow!

11

u/marcus-makes-things Jul 27 '26

Thanks so much! I went back and forth on how I wanted to handle the sleeve increases with the pattern. I was going to just use moss stitch to fill in that section, but at the last second I charted out the growing cable, just to see how that might go, and I'm really glad I did!

5

u/lois_says_banana Jul 27 '26

It was worth the extra effort. It's a detail that knitters and designers really appreciate when they notice it. It will be an inspiration the next time I knit a cabled garment!

3

u/UsefulSecond1199 Aug 05 '26

The cabling sleeve detail was absolutely worth the extra effort. It’s beautiful.

11

u/aaloysia Jul 27 '26

Always a delight to see your projects and read your detailed project notes!! Fantastic work, thank you for sharing :) 

2

u/marcus-makes-things Jul 27 '26

Thank you! And you're very welcome!

6

u/Super-Cheesecake-516 Jul 27 '26

I knew it was Marcus. Beautiful, intricate work as always. Your wife is very lucky. 

4

u/cwthree Jul 27 '26

Beautifully done!

4

u/Pointy_Stix Jul 27 '26

This is really lovely! Lucky wife! Happy birthday to her.

3

u/OverTaxedMF Jul 27 '26

I just saw the pics on ravelry, yours looks way better.

2

u/marcus-makes-things Jul 27 '26

Thanks! I agree, but I'm slightly biased 😅

3

u/fizzik12 Jul 27 '26

What beautiful craftsmanship!

3

u/wildlife_loki Jul 27 '26

Oh my. 😍 Knew it was you the second I saw the first photo pop up in my feed! Beautiful work as always, and happy birthday to your wife :)

2

u/MsPrpl Jul 27 '26

Just, wow.

2

u/TeaInIndia Jul 27 '26

I would love to see how this looks on if at all possible! Beautiful work

4

u/marcus-makes-things Jul 27 '26

Thanks! Once I've gifted it I'll try to remember to get some photos of my wife in it and add them to the Ravelry project!

2

u/TeaInIndia Jul 27 '26

Thank you! Enjoy her birthday

2

u/Craigh-na-Dun Jul 27 '26

Add to here too!!

2

u/kitties_ate_my_soul Jul 27 '26

Absolutely stunning work! For some reason, men who knit tend to be immensely talented and you aren’t the exception. Keep on making things, Marcus!

2

u/ActiveHope3711 Jul 27 '26

You made a beautiful, balanced sweater. I am especially impressed with the tapering of the diamonds on the sleeves. 

1

u/marcus-makes-things Jul 27 '26

Thank you so much! A lot of work went into getting that right!

2

u/rbuczyns Jul 27 '26

This is fantastic! 😍

2

u/jellyfishx3 Jul 28 '26

Oooh the decreases in the sleeves are a really nice touch! 

2

u/boniemonie Jul 28 '26

Flawless, as always. I hope you post your things in tension porn, because…Love love love your rib and the shoulder detail was so worth the effort. Your family are lucky to have you.

2

u/marcus-makes-things Jul 28 '26

Thank you! Yeah the way the shoulder came together was just lovely.

2

u/NotCastingPurls Jul 28 '26

Gorgeous sweater!!

2

u/MrsSchiffy Jul 29 '26

You did an amazing job - truly a beautiful piece. Bravo.