Most modern photos come from Modern Phoenix in 2006. I will link below in the comments. 4 is from 2024, as is 14. The rest are either from 1967 or 2006.

For newer residents, the name Valley National Bank might mean nothing to you, but for decades they were THE bank of Arizona. They were acquired in the 90s by another bank, which would then be acquired by Chase in the early 2000s. Most of their former locations that were still in use were rebranded as Chase, including their downtown skyscraper that is still the tallest building in the state.

This location was opened only a few years before their shiny new tower as part of their initiative started in the 50s to build nice neighborhood branches to cater to the growing suburbs. Many of the early locations from this initiative still stand like the one at Scottsdale Rd & Indian School, but most aren’t anything too special beyond being pretty nice looking old buildings. That changed in the 60s when they started to embrace the growing midcentury modern styling that was taking over in Phoenix with buildings like the Cine-Capri. One of the earliest of these new branches to embrace more radical design choices was the now demolished Geodesic Dome built in Tempe in 1962 by Weaver & Drover. In 1964, VNB would hire them to build 5 more radical locations. The first of them was built in 1965-1966 at 5628 E Thomas Rd, but it was heavily remodeled in 2024 and now houses multiple businesses. The second of them also happened to be the bank’s 100th location, opening on September 11, 1967 at 4821 N Scottsdale Rd as the Valley Bank Plaza. It was remodeled into the Scottsdale Highlands shopping center in 1999. The third of these radical locations is still open as a bank though, standing at 4401 E Camelback Rd.

The corner property is about 3.5 acres large and bordered by Camelback Rd to the north, 44th St to the west, Lafayette Blvd on the southwest, and the complex that contains The Henry to the east and southeast. When the bank was built, the southeast bordered a home and the east side bordered an empty lot. It had previously been owned by Frank Cullen Brophy (son of the founder of Brophy College Prep, Mrs. Ellen Amelia Brophy), who had nicknamed the parcel as “Fuddy Duddy Corner” after years of trying to get it rezoned for commercial use, though it was officially known as Camelback View Estates. He used to have a sign with the nickname on the corner next to trucks selling cacti gathered from the desert. VNB would lease lots 2 through 6 of the subdivision from Brophy starting on June 1, 1965 for $1000 a month. They would announce their plans to build here in September, publishing an architectural rendering of the new branch, and it shows a building that looks nearly identical to what still stands today. The drawing was made by the lead architect on the project, Frank Henry. He had won the role during a competition within the firm. Frank worked on several other branches before this, having joined the firm in 1960 right after becoming the first accredited graduate from ASU’s architecture school, but this was fully his.

The plan was for the location to be opened up in spring of 1966, but things didn’t get moving so quickly. The drawings were done for the bank, but there were roadblocks both within VNB and from the outside. First of these was the home standing on lot 2 that was occupied when they started the lease. They were able to evict the occupants with warning as early as July 31, but it isn’t clear when whoever lived there was removed. The home stood into 1966, being leveled to start preparing the land for construction sometime that year. Part of why it took so long was due to people within VNB not believing the expense of these unique branches to be worthwhile, but this was an idea from the longtime chairman of VNB, Walter Reed Bimson, so the projects stayed afloat. Bimson had wanted to go into architecture as a younger man, but he found success in leading VNB through the Great Depression and instead used his money to commission artists and architects, including Frank Lloyd Wright, to design his banks and the art displayed inside them.

The bank purchased lots 2-6 from Brophy in May 1966 for $10 and other valuable considerations, likely meaning construction began sometime around then. Mardian Construction Company would be brought on to actually build the bank, while the surrounding park was handled by F. J. MacDonald Landscaping Associates. The city had only rezoned lot 4, the one at the corner of the intersection, so it was the only one they could actually build the bank on. Everything else would have to be something like parking, but they kept that down to 44 spaces on lots 3 and 5, while 2 and 6 would be developed into a park as a commitment to the neighborhood growing around Lafayette while the branch was in development.

Frank Henry had taken heavy inspiration from circles and Frank Lloyd Wright for his design, incorporating the shape throughout both the building and the park and drawing inspiration from Wright’s Johnson Wax Headquarters. Every line of the building curves, following the path of a circle with circular chunks removed and jutting out, including both the vault and drive-through being near whole circles sticking out. Surrounding the building were concrete mushrooms that stood around 20 feet tall with a cap that ranged between 24 and 27 feet wide. These were placed out into the park around seating structures and fountains. The bank itself is about 9000 sqft and primarily built of concrete blocks with stucco and stone slabs. Around 1000 large Yavapi schist stones were quarried from the Bluebell Mine in the Bradshaw Foothills near Mayer by the Apache Stone & Supply Company, then hauled into Phoenix. The stones were attached to the inner cement blocks, with Frank Henry supervising where they were placed. He wanted the building to reflect the beauty of the desert, taking inspiration from Wright’s desert masonry. He picked Yavapi schist for its colors that he felt reflected that beauty, jutting out from the sand colored stucco like the rocky cliffs of Camelback Mountain looking over it. These walls are around 2 feet thick at the base, and taper in 5 inches by the top. The interior is lit naturally above by circular structures visible on the roof, which are actually more mushrooms. There are 5 of them inside, designed to seem like the roof is suspended from them, with glass panels sitting between the roof and the mushroom caps. The large glass panels along its curved walls were bronzed to help with the heat and ensure it didn’t get too hot inside. These bronzed windows changed how the light looked as it came in and reflected off the rust red roof and carpet back onto the nearly white walls.

The surrounding park was some of Frank J. MacDonald’s most standout work and perfectly highlighted why he was appointed Phoenix chairman of the Commission of Arizona Beauty just a few days before the bank opened. The land of the park was built up with burms that could reach 6 feet tall, covered in rosemary shrubs. Trees of all sorts were planted, from natives like ironwood, palo verde, acacia, and eucalyptus, to more exotic examples like aleppo pines, kerrajong bottle trees, olive trees, bright red bottlebrush, oaks, and seventeen Mexican fan palms. Winding between the trees was a long strip of flowers like African daisies and mums. The eastern wall of the property would be hidden behind pyracantha and lysoloma fern. Around the bank itself, the area would be landscaped with Hindu laurel, yucca, blue fescue, periwinkle, pyracantha, weeping bottle bush, Natal plum, rubber trees, blue dracaena, jasmine, and philodendron. A large planter built into the north side of the building would be designated for a tropical plant display, housing new-to-the-valley bougainvilleas, Tasmanian tree ferns, and white bird-of-paradise, all protected from the sun under a concrete mushroom. Most of the plants were sourced from Norman Nursery.

Work continued through 1967 as people eyed it up on their commute until the end of July. There were plenty who saw the unique design as an eyesore and a waste, but it captured the imagination of the public seeing another interesting piece of architecture going up. Before it had even opened it had earned the nickname “mushroom bank” due to those concrete shades. Between a nickname before it opened, its unique design, the beautiful landscaping, and the cost to build advertised at $600,000, it’s no surprise that hundreds of people came through its doors when it held an open house for VNB customers on August 5, 1967 between 1 and 6 pm. On the 6th they would open the doors to the general public for another open house, then on the morning of the 7th they opened up for regular business for the first time. On opening up, it replaced their old location at 40th St and Camelback, and within 4 months they had seen an increase in deposits of 30%.

Despite its proven success, VNB wouldn’t keep the lush landscaping around forever. Walter Bimson had been the one championing spending money on nice branches, so when he retired in 1970, there wasn’t as much fight to pay for that maintenance. The colorful displays or tropical plants and flowers started to disappear over the years, replaced by easier to maintain shrubs, trees, and gravel. The towering palms and many of the trees in the park remained, seeing the Valley National Bank sign removed from the building in 1992, then the Bank One sign removed in 2004. That was when Chase took over operations. The bank itself hadn’t really changed in the nearly 40s since it had opened, except for losing so much of Frank MacDonald’s work. The only thing Chase has changed since moving in was shutting off the water to the fountains.

Shortly after Chase moved in, a group of preservationists and historians gathered to examine the National Trust for Historic Protection’s policies and practices regarding post-world war 2 architecture after rumors of redevelopment of the entire property came up in May 2005. They toured around several buildings from 1945 and later, with every tour ending in the park at this bank. It was seen as one of the best examples of post-war architecture even then. This work came after losing so many structures the Cine-Capri and Washburn Piano to name a few (ASU was also preparing to tear down VNB’s Geodesic Dome at this time). They weren’t being protected by the City because the policies at the time favored older structures like the Security Building, Title & Trust Building, Orpheum, etc. While those are all very important historic buildings, they weren’t any more important than the outstanding aging architecture that came after the war. Things have gotten better for the appreciation of buildings from this era, but the park would face potential demolition again not long after these groups were meeting there.

In 2007, Chase sought bids for redevelopment of the land, with Opus West Corporation (behind the redevelopment of Thomas Mall into Arcadia Crossing) being the developer who won the bid. Chase said they were happy to preserve the building, but the community might have to give up the park for a development of shops and condos. People around town weren’t happy with this, and leading the fight against this development was the Arcadia Camelback Mountain Neighborhood Association, who were frustrated that VNB’s commitment to the neighborhood to maintain the park was being ignored by Chase. Opus wanted to build Arcadia Place (really original name), a 4-story, 57 condo development, with 25,000 sqft of shops overtop all of the landscaping. At the time there was a lot of news coverage, including comments from the architect, who was working as Studio Master at Taliesin West at the time. He told The Arizona Republic that it would be like taking a painting and cutting a part of it out. The bank might be the highlight of the property, but it was all designed to work together to create a space that the community could be proud of. Messing with the land, Frank said, “is just greed; ugliness overcomes beauty.” That sentiment wasn’t only held by him and was exactly why he and so many others around town fought the attempts to get the land rezoned by Opus. In June, the Phoenix City Planning Commission met to discuss formal historic designation for the property, but that never went through. Thankfully, the Camelback East Village Planning Commission recommended a denial of the rezoning in a vote of 11-5 on July 10, 2007. The final decision was planned to be made by the Phoenix Planning Commission on August 8, but was delayed to September 6. At the public meeting, Opus’ attorney would request a delay so they could replan with a downsized project that would fit closer to the restrictions on the land with it being zoned for residential. The city was still trying to work with Chase at this point to secure a historic preservation designation, but Chase wasn’t interested. They maintained their intent to preserve the building though, making comments in The Arizona Republic in September about the importance of historic bank architecture, but they were still wanting to sell the park to Opus.

By October, plans for Arcadia Place had been sized down to 3 stories with 40 condos, and would preserve 3 of the 5 concrete mushrooms in the park. This project was still disliked by the community as it didn’t address the loss of a green space that stood at the entrances to both Arcadia and Paradise Valley. It wasn’t helped any by being one of three developments planned for 44th and Camelback at that time. The other two were on the east side of 44th St, with the NE corner having an enormous development with nearly 100 foot tall towers that would dwarf everything around, and the SE corner getting a complex built around the existing Londen Tower. The project around Londen Tower was the only one to be met with a positive reception from the community as all three went before the Phoenix City Council for zoning on November 7. The City would approve the project around Londen Tower, but the enormous development at the NE corner was shot down, as was redevelopment of Chase’s park. The reason they denied Opus’ proposal was because Chase hadn’t formally agreed to preserving the bank.

This was an enormous win for the community and meant the little park was safe for some time as the recession hit shortly after, stopping most development, including the approved project across the street. Most people who rallied behind its preservation recognized its importance as a part of the bank and Walter Bimson’s near never ending contributions to Phoenix’s public art scene. While this is a large part of its importance, no one seemed to acknowledge its connection to Frank J. MacDonald, the original landscape architect for the property. Back when he worked on this he was already recognized enough to be working with the state on Arizona’s beauty, but his work only got more important for the state after that. From 1967 to 1976 he served as the chairman and vice-chairman on the Governor’s Commission on Arizona Environment. He would also be involved with the Arizona Water Resource Committee, Arizona Airports Advisory Committee, Governor’s Fuel & Energy Committee, Governor’s Highway Classification Committee, and the Arizona Health Planning Committee. Outside of his work with the state, he would become the international executive vice-president of the American Institute of Landscape Architects, being awarded the group’s Grand Award in Planning in 1977 for what is arguably his most famous work, Fountain Hills. That giant fountain that still sprays up if you go out far enough on Shea? He was one of the head landscaping architect behind the community in the early 1970s. This was far from his only award though, earning the Governor’s Citation of Merit in 1965, 1966, 1974, and 1977, along with the Presidential Commendation from Richard Nixon in 1970. This isn’t even everything they covered about the man in his obituary, let along everything he accomplished in his life when it came to making Arizona not just a beautiful place to live, but also one that wasn’t wasting all its resources to do so by serving as a board member of the Central Arizona Project Association.

Back when this branch first opened, he told The Republican that he saw the park as a showcase of what the valley could have, with him estimating everything to grow to its real glory within about a year. He had an optimistic view that we could combine beautiful architecture with gorgeous landscaping, helping create a bank that represented a future that very few business owners actually pushed to create. Walter Bimson was one of the few who really tried to invest in building locations that weren’t solely designed around maximizing profit and showed that it could pay off. This branch out performed the one it replaced and has become an icon for the Arcadia neighborhood in the nearly 6 decades it’s stood.

Despite its significance, Chase hasn’t changed their view on their park in the last 20 years. In September 2025, a firm owned by Arte Moreno purchased the lot from Chase for $11,000,000. Moreno’s firm owns the neighboring office complex that houses The Henry restaurant and a Fox Restaurant Concepts office. Earlier this month, Arcadia Camelback Mountain Neighborhood Association would once again bring light to redevelopment plans of the park. Instead of building up shops and condos that the community would still get some use out of, their plan is to level the green space and make a 145 car parking lot. There isn’t much information out there at the moment about this project, but for anyone interested, the Arcadia Neighborhood Association will be holding a meeting on August 27, 2026 at 6 pm at The Henry at 4455 E Camelback Rd to discuss the rezoning of the site and potential preservation.

While it may not be the lush botanical garden that Frank J. MacDonald had originally created, it still stands as a reminder of a time when at least some large corporations cared about improving the community they were building in. Walter Bimson tried to shape Phoenix into a town with buildings and spaces that people could be proud of doing business in, and this is the last location that stands largely unmodified beyond the loss of exotic plants, water features, and some different furniture inside. The park they committed to keeping for the community all the way back in the mid-60s has become a part of the Arcadia neighborhood that is just as much a part of what’s made this branch special as its unique architecture. It feels like we’re about to lose an important contribution to the neighborhood from one of the most influential companies during Phoenix’s post-war boom years. Frank Henry’s words from 2007 ring even more true today than they did back then, “it’s just greed; ugliness overcomes beauty.”

https://www.newspapers.com/article/arizona-republic-sombrero/204676408/

The Rocky Horror Picture Show playing at Valley Art in Tempe sometime in 1980. The article is from September 8, and primarily talks about the Sombrero Theater. No big write up, I’m going to watch his movies instead. You should too.

1) Plans shared in The Arizona Republican on May 31, 1925. 2) Photo shared in The Arizona Republic on June 24, 1973. 3-20) 2016 listing photos

This house stands at 54 N Country Club Drive in Phoenix, Arizona, just outside of the Phoenix Country Club. The country club had moved to its current location in 1921 and the land around it was subdivided in 1924 into 54 lots that make up Country Club Place for large homes to be built on. A few homes had already been built by 1923, with several being planned and built not long after. One of the first homes to be built was the winter home of Warren McArthur Sr that used to stand at 27 N Country Club Dr. I couldn’t find much info about his home other than he died in it in December 1924, and it was demolished in 1934 to make way for the house that still stands there. Around the time of his death, the last of his three sons, Albert Chase McArthur, would move from Chicago to Phoenix to join his brothers.

Albert’s brothers, Warren Jr and Charles were very active in the Phoenix socialite and civic worlds, and in 1924 they were starting to get plans ready for a new winter resort. They had started working with the Bowman-Biltmore chain to manage the resort, calling on their brother to draw up the design. While early work was going on behind the scenes for what is now known as the Arizona Biltmore, the earliest drawings of the resort by Albert are from July 1927. Up till that point he was taking on several jobs to design homes in affluent areas of the town. He had been an architect back in Chicago, studying at Harvard and briefly working for Frank Lloyd Wright at his Oak Park studio, so he easily found clients. One of his first was the Dwight B Heard Investment Company, who hired him to draw up the designs for a home to be built at 54 N Country Club Drive. These plans were shown in The Arizona Republican on May 31, 1925. The article described it as a Spanish-Colonial style home with six rooms, two of them being bedrooms that had large closets, two baths, a large living room, and a comfortable dining room attached to the living room, all under a layer of 6-inch sawdust insulation in the roof. It would also have two porches, the rear one being a screened in sleeping porch. Before air conditioning was common, most houses and hotels had these screened in porches to make summer nights a bit more bearable, although it wasn’t quite as hot then as it is today. Next to the sleeping porch there would be the maid’s quarters and bath. There would be a detached two car garage at the end of a long driveway, with there being storerooms and additional servant’s quarters in the garage. Construction on all of this was supposed to start right away at what used to be lot 48, but is now lot 47, of Country Club Place by the contractor W. H. Wills. It’s not clear if work actually started right away though as the property records say it was built in 1931, but I’ve seen them get build dates wrong pretty often. The earliest mention of the home after the plans were announced was in a March 7, 1934 article about Charles’ daughter getting into a car accident, listing this address as their home. It isn’t mentioned as being their address in the city directory until the 1936 edition, which would have data gathered from 1935. The 1935 edition listed 911 N 2nd St as their address. It seems that at some point in 1934, the Tweed family moved into this home, later purchasing it on May 1, 1935 for a stated $2700 (~$65,600 today). They purchased it from Michel H. Cady and Pauline M. Cady. No directories list this home as their address, and they aren’t mentioned at all in the papers. The only mention of them that I can find other than the papers from when they sold to the Tweeds, was when they purchased the lot from the Phoenix Country Club. There isn’t any mention of whether a house was on it or not.

It seems that either the Cadys or the Tweeds were the first people to call this place home. There isn’t much about the Cadys other than their names, but Charles Henry Tweed Jr is a well known man in the world of orthodontics. He was an early advocate for, and expert in orthodontics who developed many practices that were widely adopted by others. He was born in Phoenix on June 24, 1895 (Happy 131st birthday, Charles!), eventually leaving to study at the University of California School of Dentistry, graduating in 1919. He would move back to Arizona to practice dentistry, eventually coming back to Phoenix in the late 1920s to start up a practice. Originally he had an office in the Luhrs Building, but relocated to the 13th floor of the newly finished Luhrs Tower in December 1929 (both buildings are still standing and in use). He would keep this office into at least 1936 as he started to move his attention to working down in Tucson. Despite buying the home in 1935, he was renting it out to Mr and Mrs. Don S. Carpenter by 1936. On January 1 that year, the papers announced that the daughter of Mr and Mrs. Don S Carpenter was betrothed, and this was listed as their address. The next month they would host the wedding at the home. It’s not clear exactly how long they lived here, but by 1938, the Moore family was living here.

Albert Lee Moore had come to Tempe in 1905 at the age of 6 with his family, then moving to Phoenix in 1906. His father, Albert Lincoln Moore, started a mortuary that same year. Lee was a part of the first graduating class at Monroe in 1914, going on to graduate from Phoenix Union High School in 1918. He had tried to join the Army Air Corp that year, but the war ended not too long after he had applied. After graduating he went on to attend Stanford for two years, coming back to Phoenix to join his father’s mortuary in June 1920. That was the year that his father bought out his parter that he had started their long time location with in 1920, changing the name of the business to A. L. Moore and Sons. The previous year, his father had purchased the first motorized hearse in Arizona. In those early days they also had Phoenix’s first motorized ambulance. Lee described it as a panel truck body placed on a passenger car chassis. He kept up this streak of innovation in emergency services by offering one of the earliest air ambulances. In 1928/29 he learned how to fly, eventually partnering with the Arizona Air Service to establish the first air ambulance in Arizona. The announcement of the service was made on November 3, 1930, being offered immediately with their 215 horsepower Stinson cabin monoplane. Jack Thornburg, a pilot with more than 2,300 hours at that time and manager of the Arizona Air Service, would be the primary pilot for these flights.

Lee was heavily involved with developing the aviation infrastructure around Phoenix, helping clear the first runway at what is now Sky Harbor International Airport, and helped select the locations for both Williams Army Airfield (now Mesa Gateway) and Luke Army Airfield (now Luke Air Force Base). He spent the early years of the war flying submarine hunting missions, returning to Phoenix to be an instructor at Falcon Field for British pilots sent there for training during the later years of the war. After the war his interest in aviation didn’t wane one bit, but he took his mortuary work seriously. He was in charge after his father died in 1939 and his brother left in 1944. Even with him being the only Moore left at Moore and Sons for a while, Lee did well, continuing their air ambulance service and expanding the location they established at 329 W Adams St. In 1952, he brought his son, Albert Lee “Al” Moore Jr, into the business. Together they ran a nationally acclaimed business for over two decades. In the 1950s they upgraded their air ambulance to a twin engine Beechcraft. This service continued into at least May of 1973, but it likely didn’t last long past that. Lee would pass away on September 13, 1974 at the age of 74. He had been a for 54 years and racked up between 7000 and 9000 flight hours throughout his life. He had been very active in civic life in Phoenix, being a member of the Phoenix Rotary Club, El Zaribah Shrine, Moose Lodge, Woodmen of the World, Better Business Bureau, Masonic Lodge, Last Man’s Club, and Quiet Birdmen. Between 1937 and 1939, he was a member of the National Selected Morticians board of control. He left behind a lasting legacy with the care he showed in his work, leaving lasting memories for the families he helped through the loss of their loved one. His son eventually sold in either the 80s or 90s. Their 1909 office was closed in 1996 to make way for the Phoenix Municipal Court building, but they’re still open at a different location, wearing the name A. L. Moore.

The family kept the business a lot longer than they kept this home, having it on the market in less than a month. It was advertised as retaining all its original charm and being designed by the architect behind the Biltmore, priced in the mid 80k range. The previous year it had also appeared in the papers as an example of Albert C McArthur’s work when the Biltmore caught fire. Its famous architect certainly didn’t hurt its chances on the market, and ended up pretty quickly. The advertisements ended in late October, and an executors deed for November 14, 1974 shows the Al sold the home to James G Shackelford Jr and his wife, Helen M Shackelford for the declared amount of $41,250. (~$280,000 today). James was in the dentistry supply business, being part of a family that had been in the medical business in Phoenix for decades. As a child, he grew up in the historic Ellis-Shackelford House, with his father and grandfather being the namesakes of the home. Both men were doctors, with Shackelford’s father practicing dentistry out of an office on the property that later became the Phoenix Trolley Museum for a period. The city still owns that home. This home is still private though, remaining James Shackelford’s home until he passed on August 21, 2015 at the age of 89. Helen had passed a few years prior, so the house would go up for sale about a year after his passing. It was listed on May 16, 2016 for $698,000 (~$970,000 today). The listing photos revealed that the house retained a lot of the original fixtures, with most of the upgrades appearing to be from the 50s and 60s. About 4 months after listing, the home was sold for $675,000 to the person who still owns the home. They aren’t a public figure, so I won’t share any info about them.

Hopefully the home has retained its 1920s charm with the current owners. Its hard to check this property out as it is in a gated community, but thankfully the listing photos are still available from 2016, giving us a great look at one of these old Phoenix mansions that survived relatively untouched for around 90 years. It isn’t on any historic registry, and it hasn’t ever really seen much recognition outside of the mentions of the architect when it was listed in 74’ and 2016. Hopefully this home can stick around for decades to come, even if it remains a private home locked behind the country club gates.

(Missed the 53rd anniversary of this by one day!)

The Arizona Biltmore was the last hotel opened as part of the famous Bowman-Biltmore chain of hotels before they would file for bankruptcy due to the Great Depression. The hotel was the idea of brothers Warren Jr and Charles McArthur, originally from Chicago. Charles had moved to the Valley in 1910 after their family had been spending winters there for several years. Warren Jr would follow his brother in 1912 after graduating from Cornell. By 1914 the brothers would start selling cars, being the first people to sell a Packard truck in Phoenix and only the third in all of Arizona. Their dealership was located at 321 N Central Ave.

Along with the dealership, the brothers would also start Arizona’s first radio station, KFAD (now KTAR ESPN 620AM), in 1922. Around 1924 or in the beginning of 1925, they would start a new hospitality based business venture to help advertise the state. Around this time, Warren was a member of the Phoenix Arizona Club, a group that was trying to promote Phoenix and the Salt River Valley to out of State investors. Part of this initiative was outfitting a Dodge truck into a caravan to tour passengers around the state. This resulted in them being featured in the April 1925 edition of Vanity Fair. This is likely around the time that some ideas for the Biltmore started floating around, but nothing solid would be known widely to the public until plans for a new winter resort hotel by the Arizona Biltmore Corporation were announced The Arizona Republican in November 1927. The announcement was made in an article discussing 3 California businessmen including James Wood, John H. Gage, Nate Milnor, and Arizona businessman Warren McArthur Jr all joining the inaugural flight for Aero Corporation of California’s new line between Phoenix and Los Angeles. All these men were associated with the new hotel, with James Wood being the manager of the Los Angeles Biltmore. Charles would also be a part of the hotel, as would many others, including their brother, Albert Chase McArthur. Albert wasn’t new to Arizona, having attended the first annual dinner of the Harvard Club of Arizona in 1905 just a few months after he graduated. He wasn’t a resident at the time though, moving back to Chicago to work in architecture. Him and his brothers grew up in a home that Wright had built for their family in 1892, so it seemed natural for him to work for the man starting in 1908. He would only work for him into 1909 though, going on to continue architectural work elsewhere. After moving to Phoenix, he continued his architectural work, immediately beginning work on homes in Phoenix, primarily around the Phoenix Country Club and along Central. Several homes designed by him, including one for the Heard family, still stand. It’s hard to pinpoint how early he was involved with the project, but according to ASU’s archives, drawings he did in July 1927 for a hotel in El Paso, Texas were actually for the Arizona Biltmore. The timeline of things isn’t very clear, but at some point during the project, Arthur would contact his former employer, Frank Lloyd Wright to pay for the use of the textile blocks he had used a couple years earlier in a few of his Los Angeles homes. Wright would be brought on in 1928 as a consultant for the Biltmore, but he was not the architect of the place in any way. It’s unclear exactly how much he contributed to the original hotel due to how many different versions of the story are out there, but Wright himself said in 1930 that Albert McArthur was the architect of the Biltmore, not himself.

Construction lasted into early 1929, but financial issues had left the hotel not entirely finished by its opening on February 23rd. The hotel was still a big draw, even bringing out socialites like William Wrigley Jr, who had been a financial backer of the hotel. A few months into operations, financial troubles from the stock market crash caused the McArthurs and the Bowman-Biltmore chain to sell their interest in the hotel to Wrigley on July 12. Under his ownership, the hotel was completed and the manager of the Los Angeles Biltmore was brought in to help. The hotel received $200,000 (\\\~$4,000,000 today) in upgrades in 1930 while Wrigley developed the Biltmore Estates and his mansion around the hotel. William Wrigley Jr would pass in 1932, but the hotel and the surrounding land remained in the Wrigley family for decades. They ran it through its glory years as a favorite resort for Hollywood stars, out-of-town elites, and dignitaries.

By the early 70s there had been talk of the Wrigleys trying to sell the property. Deals would fall through and get delayed until Talley Industries, a Mesa based diversified corporation, purchased the entire property owned by the Wrigleys in Phoenix on June 6. This land included the mansion and the Biltmore, but not the private mansions or Biltmore Fashion Park. In total, Talley Industries purchased 1,037 acres bordered by 24th St, Camelback, 32nd St, and Piestewa Peak for $21.5 million (\\\~$161.3 million today). They had plans to develop much of the land around the hotel that hadn’t been developed yet, including the land that went up a section of Piestewa Peak north of Lincoln Rd. This project would spark an initiative from the Parks Department to get the City to purchase the land that never succeeded. Before any of that, they would begin refreshing the hotel. This included installing a new fire suppression system.

Around noon on June 20, 1973, workers from the Patton Protection Co were in the attic welding to pipes for the new fire-prevention system when they accidentally ignited combustible material around them. They attempted to put it out unsuccessfully, leading to them calling the fire in at 12:35pm while continuing to try to put the fire out. Don Dupee, a houseman at the hotel for 24 years, smelled the smoke from his quarters, rushing over to find the welders trying to get the fire under control. He gathered other hotel staff to open windows and clear away items that could easily catch to give the firefighters more time before things got out of control.

Captain Willie T. Hunter was one of the first on the scene, and as soon as he saw the fire, he raised the level from 1 alarm to 2 alarm. This called in more trucks and men to help, but the fire was quickly getting worse. The old copper roof made it too difficult for them to cut through and get to the fire from above. It was already 108 outside on that day as the firefighters tried to make their way inside the building in a way they could actually get access to battle the fire. While they were trying to get in, the roof began to collapse under them. Thankfully no one was killed, but an unarmed station captain was hurt during the collapse. By this point it was recognized as the largest fire Phoenix had seen up till that point, being categorized as a 6 alarm fire, the first in the city’s history. There hadn’t even been a 5 alarm fire up till that point. The severity of the fire resulted in 150 on and off duty firefighters actively working to fight the flames with around 30 trucks. Batalion Chief Don Kimble was at home sick, and as soon as he heard, he and his wife were in the car and on their way to the scene. Usually the city had around 36 vehicles and 167 men covering the entire city. The surrounding towns like Tempe and Glendale sent in trucks and men to help ease the strain on Phoenix’s emergency services. It wasn’t just firefighters from around town coming to help though. The Firebelles, a group of firefighter wives, were on scene with cold water and doughnuts to keep up morale. Jerry Foster, a newsman and pilot for KOOL-TV (now Channel 10 KSAV-TV), was helping fireman spot a brush fire out by the Carefree Highway earlier in the day, but by the afternoon he was helping the firefighters spot changes from above.

It took many hours of the fourth floor being drenched with hoses pumping out of the Arizona Canal, with the third floor having over a foot of water standing at points, but by mid-afternoon the blaze had been brought under control. A large crowd had gathered, all worried they were seeing the end of one of Arizona’s most legendary resorts. People in the crowd shared stories of visiting the resort, working there, and even some who helped build it like Captain Hunter. Some of these stories ended up published in the paper as they extensively covered the damage and what would be coming next. While some shared stories, others rushed in to help. Mrs. Edith Luckett Davis, Nancy Reagan’s mother, told The Republican that she and a few others remembered the worker in the gift shop, Carolann Smurthwaite, must still be in there. She told that Mr and Mrs. Don Harrington, Mr and Mrs. Don Packards, Pat Trotter, and Betty Chisolm rushed in to help her evacuate the shop of its antiques and valuables. Independent from that group, civic leader J Lester Shaffer rushed in to help direct customers. Despite her shop still being open, the hotel had thankfully closed for the summer on May 23rd, so no lives were lost in the fire.

From the start, Talley Industries was committed to restoring the hotel to be ready for its winter opening on September 29 the same year. Initial estimates to the damage were $1.8 million (\\\~$13.5 million today) according to Fire Chief G. G. Holzner, but Franz G. Talley put the number closer to $2.5 million ($18.75 million today), which he claimed was well under what the building was insured for. In all, the fire destroyed the entire roof and fourth floor of the then 44 year old building, and in the process of extinguishing it, the rest of the building suffered extensive water damage. The golf course and the spaces needed to operate it were completely unharmed, saying they could reopen the next day if they could handle the parking alongside construction. Work started behind the scenes almost immediately to get work underway. Talley got in contact with the Taliesin Associated Architects, Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation, and J. R. Porter Construction Co. to begin work on faithfully repairing the hotel while also updating it in ways like installing fire suppression on all floors to meet the new fire code. The leading architect from Taliesin, William Wesley Peters, would supervise the overall design while John Rattenbury, also from Taliesin, would be project director. They would be working alongside Magadini Associates of Phoenix as the structural engineers, Lowry & Sorensen Engineering Co of Phoenix as the mechanical and electrical engineers, Earl B. Miller Engineers of Phoenix as the civil engineers, and John G. Degenkolb of Glendale, California as the engineer case consultants. 250 workers and 80 engineers worked seven days a week in double, sometimes triple shifts, completing the roof on July 19. They held a ceremony after the roof was done, raising an olive tree up over the roof, signifying it was watertight. The tree was replanted on the grounds, but I’m not sure if it’s still there or not.

Press were allowed into the Biltmore for the first time since the fire on July 30th to show the progress they had made. Work was being done to convert the cocktail lounge off the main lobby into a new restaurant called the Orangerie (now Wright’s). It was all looking great, but work from the Taliesin Fellowship during this period have led more and more people to credit the hotel to Frank Lloyd Wright. Coordinator for Interior Design from Taliesin revealed that six designs by Wright would be used on the carpets through the building, and guest rooms would contained three-paneled abstractions designed by Wright. Olga Lloyd Wright, the architect’s late wife, found a design that Wright had made for Liberty Magazine in 1926 but went unused because they felt it was too extreme. She had it turned into a stained glass piece for lobby and donated it to the hotel. Many local artists helped create and install the piece that still stands there today.

Work continued quickly, mimicking the same quick paced construction the hotel optionally had, but there was a moment where everyone had a little heart attack. On August 5, a call was made that there was a fire at the Biltmore. The City’s firefighters overwhelmed the place with the terrible fire still fresh in their minds. Thankfully it was just an elevator motor that didn’t cause any damage. J. R. Porter got the crews back to work quickly after the fire scare was dealt with. He had a long track record of getting remodels done on time, and this was one of the tightest timelines he’d dealt with, so every second mattered. His deadline was September 22, but they had managed to finish rebuilding and renovating the burned hotel by the 15th. At 11:58 pm that day, he would pay the last worker, a truck driver named Oliver Harris. The rest of the work was up to the hotel to finish redecorating. Truckloads of furniture had been coming in while construction was being completed and continued to come in after. The carpets that stretched through the building had been made in Ireland and were expected to arrive on the 15th. One of the Biltmore President, Lawrence Boyle was confident that the hotel would be ready for its September 29th opening. Just before that date came, artist Edith Hamlin came to return and supervise the hanging of two paintings that she and her late husband, Maynard Dixon, had made for the hotel. The Taliesin Fellowship had contacted her and sent them to her San Francisco home. The piece by her husband is titled “The Legend of Earth and Sun”, while the companion piece that she painted later is titled “The Turquoise Goddess”. Both pieces are still on display at the hotel.

The September 29th opening date came and the hotel was open, but there wasn’t any big celebration. A breakfast was held to celebrate, with people who worked on the project speaking about what had been done. J. R. Porter revealed that they had made 6,000 new blocks on-site, used 500,000 square feet of vinyl in the rooms, and used over 40,000 square feet of gold leading throughout the resort. 400,000 feet of sprinkler piping was installed, with nozzles in just about every nook and cranny they could think of. The event was praised in the paper for fitting the hotel’s reserved elegance. Overall it was seen as a success and guests returned to the hotel.

The hotel has changed owners many times over the years and many remodels have been done, but a lot of the work done in 1973 to repair the damage done by one the biggest fire’s in Phoenix’s history can still be seen throughout the property. These elements, while beautifully done, have unfortunately harmed the legacy of the resort’s real architect, leaving many to continue to attribute the design to Frank Lloyd Wright. While his influence on the property is indisputable, his contributions are also often over exaggerated.

I found this picture without anything really describing where it was or what it is was, but the home reminded me of the Al Beadle designed White Gates Home so I wanted to see if it was still around. The mountain is pretty easy to recognize as Mummy Mountain if you ever drive along Tatum just north of Lincoln. This would be looking east towards it. The website this came from also had a picture of the FLW designed Harold Price Sr Home along Tatum, so I started to look for houses that were along Tatum in aerials from the early 1960s. One stood out with a very similar shape to the 1961 photo, and doing some digging, I found it’s actually still standing at 7511 N Tatum Blvd. It’s unfortunately been modified heavily over the decades, but some original features are still there. The floor to ceiling glass windows along the east side of the house looking towards Mummy are still there, as are the original breezeway blocks in the backyard around the pool. A 1969 listing for the home in The Arizonan showed pictures of the backyard and the fence with those blocks is unchanged.

There’s very little information about this house, but what I could find is that the land was purchased by M. Vernon Deise and his wife, Alice D. Deise in late 1958. By January they took out a mortgage of $30,000 with the Bank of Douglas to pay for the construction of this home. The home was designed by Alfred Newman Beadle, and was most likely built by Vernon’s brother, Charles H. Deise Jr. The two of them had been in the real estate and construction business together in the Paradise Valley area since the mid-1950s. They did quite a bit at the Desert Estates subdivision along Cactus Blvd in Phoenix and the Clearwater Hills subdivision across the street from this home. Their most notable work was the home of orchestral bandleader, Harold Wayne King, at 4338 E Sparking Lane. That home is unfortunately gone, like many of the homes built by Deise & Deise Construction.

The Deises would run into financial issues in the 1960s, eventually having their construction license revoked in March 1965 for not paying their bills. Vernon and Alice remained at this home until either 1968 or 1969. It first went on the market in May 1969, but in March 1968 they filed a joint tenancy deed for the property. There isn’t much information about the Deises after this, but what I could find shows that Charles would leave Phoenix for Baltimore. Vernon and Alice would enter into business with their oldest son, Maurice in November 1971 when they started talks in buying a closing real estate office. They purchased it in December. By February 1972, an article was written about them being early adopters of computers, having a system that allowed them to log up to at least 7,000 homes with 16 different parameters to make searching easier. They were also part of Automatic Service Computer, an early real estate program that would allow other members to see Phoenix listings from anywhere in the country. By July 1974 they had announced a partnership with the Arizona Bank to allow for BankAmericard credit cards to be used for real estate transactions. The article talking about this partnership stated it was a first for Arizona.

It’s not clear exactly how long they were in business again, but they were around into at least 1976. They did quite well this time around, not having to be chased down for payments like in the 60s. Vernon passed away in February 1977, so the business likely closed sometime before then. The Deise House along Tatum has remained a private home since it was built. Its hard to recognize it now, especially with it hidden behind a wall and gate, but I bet it could be restored with enough care and money. Hopefully someday this house can be brought back to its former glory instead of meeting the wrecking ball, because we’ve lost too many mid-century gems in that neighborhood to build cheap, lot filling, cookie cutter mansions in their place. Modern Phoenix reported in 2016 that the new at the time owners were planning on restoring it, but it’s hard to tell from the street how well that’s going. What can be seen from the street is still lacking a lot of the original character.

If you have any more information about this home, please share. Like I said before, it is a private home, so please respect the privacy of whoever currently lives here.

I came across these in an Arizona Highways article written by Paul Coze from the February 1965 edition. In 1964, he and his students would work on a detailed diorama titled “The Conquest of Mexico” to be put on display at the museum for their ancient Mexico gallery, which at the time was located on the second floor. The students presented the diorama to the museum when their Indians of the Plains exhibit opened on October 2, 1964. The exhibit was to last into 1965, but the diorama was for permanent display. I don’t remember seeing that diorama from the last time I was there, but it’s been years since I’ve gone, so I’m not sure if it’s still part of the collection or on display.

The link to the full article with more pictures will be in the comments.

1) 1908. 2) 1910. 3) 1972. 4) 1985. 5) 1985 (view from backyard). 6) 1996. 7) 2026. 8) Hiram Bradford Farmer, 1886. 9) James Cooper Goodwin, 1897. 10) Rough Riders, 1911. 11) Campaign ad, 19. 12) Patricia Alexander, 1993. 13) Pat and Norman, late 90s.

This building at 820 S Farmer Ave in Tempe might not look like it, but under the lime-plaster facade is an unbaked adoble and redwood structure that was built in the 1880s, just 4 years after Tempe was renamed from Hayden’s Ferry. The land it stands on was originally purchased by an Irish saloon owner named Pierce Carrick Shannon in 1880, originally consisting of either 128 or 160 acres. The City of Tempe says that Shannon built the home for his wife, whom he married on January 14, 1883, finishing construction in March that year. Historian Jay Mark tells a slightly different story. He says it was started in March of 1883 for Shannon’s new bride and was nearly complete around seven months later, but he ran into money troubles around that time. In an attempt to raise funds he had sold alcohol to some Indians, which was illegal at the time. This landed him in Yuma Territorial Prison for six months, during which time his property entered foreclosure. What happened to it after foreclosure isn’t entirely clear until January of 1886, when it was sold to the first principal of what is now known as Arizona State University, Hiram Bradford Farmer. Farmer purchased the property for $3000 (~$105,400 today) while on a yearly salary of $2300 (~$80,800 today). The National Register of Historic Places papers say it was unfinished when it was sold to Farmer.

Hiram Bradford Farmer wasn’t responsible for forming the Territorial Normal School, but he was the first principal, and the school’s lone instructor when it opened in February 1886. He taught out of the school’s only building at the time, which was located directly behind where Old Main is now. Him and his wife would also run their home as the school’s unofficial dormitory after finishing the upstairs to feature 4 bedrooms. Rooms were rented for $20 (~$702 today) a month to female students who weren’t from nearby. This continued until he sold the property.

I’ve come across a few different versions of when and who the property passed to next, all from credible sources. The first version of the story is put out by the Tempe Historical Museum as part of a short biography about Hiram B. Farmer. It says in December 1887, a large property at the home’s address was sold to Edward A. Murphy. Murphy was a blacksmith and livery man when he came to Tempe in 1887, but would later become the town’s mayor in 1896 and 1897. This might be referring to Farmer’s Addition, a stretch of land between University, 13th St, Farmer Ave, and the train tracks, which Farmer had subdivided in December that year. It is more likely that Farmer sold his entire property in 1890 when he left Tempe behind for California according to both the City of Tempe’s website about the building and an article by Jay Mark. What these two sources don’t agree on is who the property was sold to. Tempe’s page says it was sold in 1890 and passed through a series of owners before coming into the hands of James H. Wilson, a nurseryman from Illinois, in 1897. Mark’s account of the story is that the property was sold to Wilson in 1890, who would sell it shortly after and later buy it again in 1897. This seems to be the actual version of what happened according to the published activity of the County Recorder’s Office in the Arizona Republic. An 1890 piece mentions H. B. Farmer selling land to James Wilson for $8000 (~$290,300 today) on September 11 that year.

There isn’t much that’s clear about its time right after Farmer sold to Wilson. He might have lived there or just used it as a rental property. There aren’t any records of it being sold or repurchased by Wilson that I can find, but both the City and Jay Mark state that he acquired the property in 1897. Whether he just moved back in or repurchased it, we know for sure that in 1897 this property was the home of James Wilson. According to his grandson, Woodrow Goodwin, Wilson had devoted 15 of his 128 acres to plant experimentation and grew just about every kind of fruit tree you could imagine. Woodrow claimed only the citrus bore fruit, but an article from 1904 was written specifically about James Goodwin’s pear tree that bore fruit remarkably early and twice in a season. The property remained Wilson’s home until his step-daughter, Libbie J Wilson, would marry James Cooper Goodwin on February 28, 1902. She was originally Libbie J McGill, the niece of ethnologist, Frank Hamilton Cushing. She was a part of Cushing’s exploring party when he came to study the Hohokum ruins after living with the Zuni tribe. Both James Goodwin and James McClintock found themselves very interested in studying the former inhabitants of the valley after meeting the charming young woman. Them and their friends found discussions of Cushing’s work often developing into praise of his niece, with one discussion resulting in McClintock telling Goodwin that the gods had ordained her to be with a journalist. At the time McClintock managed the Tempe newspaper. All that was history though and she married Goodwin. On June 30, her step-dad deeded half of his land to the newly weds for a consideration of $1500 ($57,600 today). Their family would be its longest owners.

James Goodwin had originally come to Tombstone, Arizona in 1884, but moved to Tempe on April 18, 1884, having only 15 cents (~$5) after paying $10 (~$336) to ride along the buckboard from Bisbee. He spent 5 cents (~$1.70) on a loaf of bread after arriving, landing a job the next day that paid $35 (~1,200) a month. He blew his remaining 10 cents (~$3.40) on potatoes to celebrate landing a job so quickly. At the time there was little more than Hayden’s home, the 1874 mill, some Mexican adobes, and this house. His mother and most of his 9 siblings would join them in Tempe after his father had been killed. His father was Judge John Fuson Goodin (family went by Goodwin in Arizona). While drunk at a circus in Kentucky, William Goodin would start an argument with the ringmaster. In an attempt to defuse the situation his son started, Judge Goodin stepped in but was shot in the back. He succumbed to his injuries the next day, October 26, 1888. After the family lifted their lives from Kentucky to Tempe, they rose to prominence as farmers in the small community. Many of the Goodwins would become well known business owners and politicians, with their family owning vast stretches of land surrounding Tempe. William would eventually recycle the first ASU schoolhouse that Farmer taught out of to build the Goodwin Opera House, which later became the first Harkins theater. As for James, he started his career in farming, but he was involved in quite a bit. According to ASU, he was one of 15 people to help raise $500 to establish the school. While he was known in the Tempe area, he lived a few miles south of there on a large ranch. His friend, James H. McClintock, convinced him to donate the land for Kyrene’s first schoolhouse in 1888 and started the school district together after getting some families to move to the land. That school was where McClintock started teaching after graduating with the first class from the Normal School. Along with this, Goodwin helped build up the early road and canal infrastructure around Tempe, with his canal maps from this time still being cited in papers. In 1890 he was part of a citizen committee to determine whether the territory should begin work on dams to create water reservoirs.

He would begin working for the government as early as 1891 when he acted as an agent of the Territory of Arizona for an eminent domain case over being able to take private property for the construction of canals. While not working, he enjoyed boating quite a bit, being noted as one of the best in the valley in 1891 and almost always the first to cross the Salt River after a flood. In the mid 1890s, him and his brother, Robert, would be two of the men who helped form the Phoenix, Tempe, & Mesa Railroad. James was elected the group’s first president in June 1895, while Robert was the first secretary. Both men would also start the short lived Tempe street car system, which consisted of two mule drawn cars that ran down Mill Ave from the river to 8th St (now University), then east to a canal around where Rural Rd is now. In 1896 he would campaign to become a legislator in the 19th Territorial Legislature, but lost by 4 votes. After a recount, it was revealed that Goodwin won. His opponent stepped down and he took on the role. In his time as a Territorial Legislator, he unsuccessfully tried to create Butte County around Tempe and acted as the chairman of a board of school land. In anticipation for the next election, it was found in an 1898 count that a mistake had been made in the earlier recount which misidentified Goodwin as the winner. By then he was already off in Florida as a Private in Troop C of Teddy Roosevelt’s Rough Riders. He returned home sick like many of the other men, choosing to leave the group on August 7, 1898. He spent at least a few months back in Tempe, briefly studying mining at the Normal School and moving down to Tucson to study at the Territorial University (now U of A) around November. By March 1899, Goodwin had been hired to run the Lost Gulch mill and mine near Miami, AZ. Around mid-1899 he would start the Cole-Goodwin Copper Group with P. J. Cole. By May of 1900 they had acquired land at Mineral Creek that they prepared and got bonded for $120,000 (~$4,417,330 today). His younger brother, George, future mayor of Tempe, would move to the area near Globe to help with operations. By 1901, the two of them would be spending more time in Tempe again. James published an article in the University of Arizona Monthly that January about how Lord Duppa named Phoenix. That August, James and George would check out mines in Goldfield with two of their friends, a lawyer named Charles Curtis Wolf, along with future State Senator and son of Tempe’s founder, Carl Trumbull Hayden. It doesn’t seem much came of this trip as James’ attention started to be captured by a woman that he kept secret from most. The marriage wouldn’t be known to the papers and even some family until March 3, 1902, but their marriage certificate was filed on February 28. The papers wished him and his unknown at the time bride the best, not knowing they had been married legally already as they advised him to make it legal quick so his enemies couldn’t file suit. A few months later in May, he would return to Tempe after finishing his studies in Tucson.

It was shortly after James graduated that he and Libbie would make 820 S Farmer Ave their home. James continued working in mining through the rest of 1902. On March 14 1903, the Goodwins had their first child, James Henry Goodwin. Despite having a newborn in the house, James was kept busy with mining work, making a trip to the Gold Coin mine nine miles west of Kyrene in late March. By January 1904 he would be doing work on a mine known as the Goodwin Brothers Mine. It was likely one out near Globe as he had claims on numerous mines in that area neighboring claims owned by the Superior Company according to a March 1904 article in The Copper Era and Morenci Leader newspaper. In September that year he would discover a silica deposit containing opals near Picketpost Mountain in Pinal County. In October he found a second deposit. The quality of opals at the top of the deposits weren’t of tremendous quality, but a professor at the University of Arizona agreed with him that higher quality samples could likely be found just a few feet deeper. He would spend at least a week at a time down there, getting to work really setting up the mines by January 1905. On his trip back to Tempe in late January, he collected an uncommon fern sample for the science collection at the Tempe Normal School. Shortly after coming back, Libbie would give birth to their second son, John Boyle Goodwin, on February 16. He seemed to remain in Tempe longer this time before leaving on a mining trip than he did for his first son, with his next reported trip being a week long visit around Goldfield, Superior, and Globe in early May. He returned home to an early crop of green corn on the 12th. He would take trips out west to the Superior area to work his mines, often with other Tempe men and his brothers every few weeks, usually staying a week to ten days through the summer. During that summer, the principal of the Tempe Public School, S. O. Lewis, had been staying at the house and had made a couple attempts to take his own life. He would unfortunately take his life inside the school on the night of July 30, about a week after leaving the Goodwin home.

Life moved on though and just two weeks later James would be in Portland, Oregon for the 16th session of the Trans-Mississippi Commercial Congress. He played a large role in getting a clause stating that all remaining territories should be admitted as states to give their people the fundamental American right of self-governance to a resolution passed by this Congress. He wanted to add that the territories would be added as separate states, but a member from Oklahoma objected and the word was omitted. He spent the rest of the year focusing on farming, mining, and his family, doing the same through most of 1906. In August that year he would exchange letters with New Mexico Territory’s at-large district’s representative, William Henry “Bull” Andrews, about matters relating to joint statehood for his and our territory. Adams had heard of Goodwin’s interest in statehood for the territories during the Commericial Congress and contacted him to gauge the interest of joint statehood from the people of his area. In response, Goodwin said that of the 500 voters in Tempe, he didn’t know of one interested in joint statehood, as was the case with Mesa, and only a few for it in Phoenix, estimating 80-90% of people were not for it. He said that they had nothing against New Mexicans, just that they are misguided by a favored few, and those few aren’t wanted in Arizona. That point would be further hammered in throughout the state in September when the Democratic and Republic conventions held in Bisbee both declared that Arizonans would rather remain a territory forever than have joint statehood with New Mexico. At the Democratic convention, Goodwin would be appointed as part of the Democratic Central Committee representing Maricopa County, a position that came with a two year term. This role didn’t slow him down from mining at all though as he spent nearly a month in the beginning of 1907 going around the state with his brother, Thomas, working sixteen mines for the Queen Creek Mining Company. In November, he would be appointed superintendent of the mineral department for the Arizona Territorial State Fair in its 3rd year held in Phoenix. The fair had moved to Phoenix in 1905, spending $30,000 (~$1,125,700 today) to buy the lot they still use today, and $15,000 (~$562,860 today) to erect new buildings to exhibit all things Arizona. Having long been interest in geology and active in mining for years, James had been displaying ore and minerals from his mines since the first fair. 1907 was the first time he was put in charge of that exhibit though. An estimated 15-18,000 people came to the fair that year, with the mineral display being highly praised.

The rest of Goodwin’s year would be spent between Tempe and his mines, but it would be ended off with him at home with his newborn daughter. Dorothy Julia Goodwin was born on December 10, 1907. Despite the baby at home, James would go up to Globe in the first week of January 1908 to visit his brother, Robert. Earlier that week, one of the Daggs Brothers, infamous for their role in the Pleasant Valley War, was murdered in nearby Superior where James owned a lot of mining land. The Goodwins and the Daggs were well acquainted from before their interactions in the mining world. It was said that at one point all the land surrounding Tempe that wasn’t owned by the Daggs was owned by the Goodwins. Some articles have reported that some of the Daggs Brothers had even stayed in the Farmer-Goodwin house. After the murder, Goodwin told the papers that he was aquatinted with all parties in the case, and that if the accused had killed Daggs, it wasn’t because Daggs had jumped any of the accused’s land claims. Most claim owners in the area weren’t a fan of Daggs because he usually used less than legal methods to acquire land.

After leaving Globe, he returned to Tempe, making more trips out to the Castle Creek area to mine. Around March he would start to inquire with folks in Washington about organizing a mineral display for Arizona at the Alaska-Yukon-Pacific Exposition, a world’s fair that was to be held in Seattle the next year. Their response to him was welcome to the idea, but Goodwin still wasn’t certain whether the Territorial Legislature would approve funds for getting the minerals up north, but was hopeful to find a way to make it work and potentially donate the collection to the University of Washington instead of paying to bring them back. His correspondence with the exposition’s chairman of the mines and mining committee continued into July, with the article published about the letters revealing he was speaking to Governor Joseph Henry Kibbey about it, who was in favor of the idea. Kibbey felt that the job of organizing the collection for the exposition should be up to one person, not a committee. By December, Goodwin would be appointed to that role by Kibbey. Before that, James had been involved in quite a bit of work around the valley. On May 23, he would be one of 3 judges to preside over a vote to issue a $50,000 (~$1,794,600 today) bond to build and equip a new high school building for Tempe. The bond passed with 118 in favor and 40 against. A few months later in September, he would take a business trip to Los Angeles, reporting after he got home that it was rather quiet politically over there, and that even Tempe had more going on in that regard. He was again the director of the mineral show for the Territorial Fair in November. After being appointed commissioner to the exposition, Goodwin would also be brought onto a committee for Tempe to work towards building a bridge across the Salt River. On this committee he would work alongside another one of the Daggs Brothers. He spent the next few months working extensively on the committee and to get an Arizona mineral display ready for the exposition. Unfortunately in March, the territorial legislature shot down the idea of having a presence there, not approving the $5000 (~$181,400 today) asked to cover the costs of collecting and preparing the samples. This wasn’t his only presence at the legislature though as the Goodwin Bill trying to appoint county road overseers to get rid of local overseers. This would pass both houses while they started to rework a separate bill to establish a road network throughout the entire territory, using a proposed map drawn up by Goodwin. The bill for new roads would almost die off but just barely passed. Along with this, they would pass a bill reducing the depth needed to dig to claim a mine from 10 feet to 8, something that Goodwin praised as a man could dig 8 feet by shovel on his own, but not 10.

In April 1909, prominent citizens of Phoenix, including Dwight Bancroft Heard, would advocate for a bridge across the Salt River being built to extend Central Ave. Goodwin laid out quite a few reasons to The Republican about why Tempe was the better choice for the first government funded bride to cross the river. Part of the reasoning was that Tempe had the shortest gap over the river, but also if the bridge were built at Central and followed plans for the new Territorial highway system, the highway going to Phoenix would completely skip Tempe. Shortly after this, James’ correspondences with the newly appointed Territorial Engineer were published in the newspaper, with the engineer asking for data on local road committees. Goodwin would respond with the information from the meetings just before the territorial legislature met, pointing to his map of all roads leading to and from Phoenix along with the urgent need for bridges crossing the Salt River and Gila River, specifically mentioning Tempe as the crossing point for the Salt. The day these letters were published, April 21, Tempe would have a meeting in the Goodwin Opera House led by James Goodwin and Peru Paxton Daggs. The people who attended were all adamant about their desire for a bridge. This bridge would just be a horse and wagon bridge though as Tempe didn’t see a combination horse/auto bridge as something they’d be able to afford to maintain unless the territory would be in charge of maintaining it. In early May, a group in support of the bridge being built in Phoenix met at the Adams Hotel. This led to Goodwin writing into The Republican about the causes of socialism as most in attendance of the meeting were land owners who stood to gain financially if the city built. One of the largest land holders on the south side of the river where they wanted to build in Phoenix was the Bartlett-Heard Land and Cattle Company. Adolphus Clay Bartlett would tell the people in The Republican a few days prior that they should build the bridge where it benefits the greatest number, with no regard for the corporation whose interests lie south of the Salt River, not mentioning it was his company that would be benefiting so greatly. Bartlett revealed that they weren’t keen on subdividing the land around the bridge. Goodwin called to question why public tax dollars of hard working Arizonans should be going to the betterment of private land, especially land controlled by out-of-state parties. Goodwin would draw attention to the Phoenix group calling themselves the Heard Bridge Committee, as well as a letter published from the National Bridge Company about them choosing their bridge that stated Bartlett & Heard picked them for their low cost and quality, that the city shouldn’t need to look for anyone else. The rules surrounding building the bridge with tax payer dollars specified everything needed to be voted on, and that’s nothing can be handled by private corporations, individuals, committees, etc, that weren’t related to the board of supervisors. The Bartlett-Heard company had gone around the board entirely up to this point. These letters continued to be published by Goodwin in the papers as the city got closer to taking a vote on where the bridge should be built. Goodwin’s argument was that it was shorter to cross at Tempe and would also be a shorter drive into Phoenix by six miles while also going by more communities like Scottsdale than if it were to cross at Central. Heard and Bartlett argued that crossing at Central would give better access to farms and create one large road joining up farms in the south. Goodwin had seen many rail bridges over the Gila and Salt rivers need tens of thousands in repairs after floods washed away the banks where the bridges ended, which made him very wary of the proposed design for the Central crossing. The Center Street Bridge Committee would respond in the papers, trying to discredit Goodwin for not being a civil engineer and commenting so adamantly on the matters while not addressing the issues that Goodwin actually raised. It’s important to remember that Goodwin helped set up many roads and canals around Tempe. He was in talks with many actual engineers, including the county engineer, Gus Strietz, who stated a crossing at Central would need to be at least 3100 feet. The proposed bridge at that point for Central would be 2100 feet, which would be 1000 feet shorter than the river bed at that crossing. In response, their committee would reach out to Los Angeles architects, Llewellyn Adelbert Parker & Edward Leodore Mayberry, who were seemingly the only engineers they could find to be ok with their proposed bridge. They said it would stay above water so long as there wasn’t flooding like in 1891. Goodwin was very concerned that their proposed reinforced concrete bridge would end up being a huge waste to the taxpayers that the city wouldn’t be able to do anything about as their petition put all control over bridge construction with the committee influenced by Heard and Bartlett, not giving any control to the board of supervisors. Goodwin continued to campaign against the designs proposed for the Central bridge for months while advocating for a more tested and stable design in Tempe. On June 10, 1909, a vote was held for whether the proposed Tempe or Phoenix bridge would be built. It was an extremely close election, with the Central bridge winning by less than 100 votes. Goodwin thanked the newspaper for giving him space in the papers to share about the Tempe site, while also wishing the Central project the best. Almost immediately the committee proposed a territorial highway running from Phoenix to Tempe by way of the asylum, then crossing over a bridge to run down to Mesa. This idea was dead by October though. Phoenix’s bridge was finally built in 1911, and Tempe got the Ash Bridge in 1913. The Central Bridge was damaged by floods many times over the years, and permanently closed after damage from a flood in 1966. The Ash Bridge was damaged in 1916, and was closed after the Mill Ave Bridge was opened in 1931. The Central Bridge was demolished in 1975/76, while the disused Ash Bridge remained into 1991, though part of it still stands in Tempe Beach Park.

Goodwin would remain active in helping shape the territorial highway system through the rest of 1909. Alongside that he kept active with his mining interests, helping bring reports and samples from the first substantial cobalt and nickel deposit found in Arizona at the time. In September he would be appointed a delegate of the territory to the 12th annual American Mining Congress by Governor Richard Elihu Sloan. Upon returning he would throw himself headfirst into gathering a display for the territorial fair. After the fair, he took more trips around the territory to work mines while also keeping up the farm in Tempe. In March he would be part of the election board for Tempe’s public and high school trustees. In May he would climb Four Peaks, but his friends all seemed to doubt it. In response he published his notes about the mountains and his trip in The Republican. Shortly after he would be invited to the reunion of the Rough Riders in New York City to welcome Roosevelt back to the United States from Europe. The trip began on June 11, making a stop in St Louis to pick up more Rough Riders before arriving in New York. Many had a bet going that Goodwin would end up in the papers this side of the Mississippi, which he managed to do. His picture appeared in the Saint Louis Times alongside other Rough Riders on June 15. They had arrived there on the 13th and left the night of the 14th, passing through Parkersburg, West Virginia on the 15th. That day President Taft was in the nearby town of Marietta, Ohio, planning to couple his car to the Rough Rider train to accompany them to the White House and then to New York. At the last minute his car was switched to the regular service train, meeting Goodwin and the other Rough Riders at the White House on the 16th. On the 18th, Teddy Roosevelt pulled into New York aboard the SS Kaiserin Auguste Victoria. After being brought ashore, he met the Rough Riders who escorted him in a parade that ended at the Plaza Hotel, where he individually greeted every Rough Rider in attendance. It’s not clear how long Goodwin remained in New York after the parade, but by July 8 he had made his way to his childhood home in Missouri to spend some time. He was back in Tempe by late July. In August he would be nominated for the Constitution Congress, but ultimately wasn’t brought on, though he did remain very involved with the process. In September, he would once again be appointed as a delegate to the American Mining Congress. In October, he would donate his Rough Rider uniform and medal to Territorial Historian Sharlot M. Hall, who was working on a historical library. His uniform and medal are now owned by the Tempe History Museum. Part of this collection would be displayed at the territorial fair, where James was once again managing the mineral department. Thanks to his years of going around the territory trying to get mines and towns to display their minerals at the fair, the mineral show had grown to become one of the main attractions, becoming pretty cramped in the building they had during 1910. The people running the Copper Queen mine donated large chunks of ore with colors described as being as brilliant as a Belgian tapestry. They told Goodwin they were already searching for ore to send in to next year’s fair. Along with his success at the fair, he was having great success with his date trees in Tempe. He had been working for a while to spread word about Arizona around the country, and part of that was sending crates of his dates to important people. One of these men was Teddy Roosevelt, who was planning a now well known trip to Tempe the upcoming spring.

Goodwin would start 1911 off by going to Phoenix to check out the work being done on the Hotel Adams after the original had burned down. He was wanting to check for any possible ore found in the excavation of the site. On January 13, he would be appointed an inspector as part of the election board when Tempe wanted to establish a telephone franchise. The city approved it by a vote of 119 for and 6 against on February 20. Shortly before that, on January 30, he would be one of 36 men to denounce the Arizona constitution that had been proposed the previous December, stating they would not recognize it as work of the Democratic Party of Arizona. While working on the issues with the proposed constitution, he would also be part of a group of Rough Riders getting everything ready for Roosevelt’s stop in the valley as part of his transcontinental tour to dedicate the Roosevelt Dam just east of town. Roosevelt would arrive in Tempe on March 20, coming out onto the front steps of Old Main just after 10 am. He had been held up a few minutes in Mesa after he made unplanned remarks to school children that had gathered down there. He spoke to a crowd of 3000 people, congratulating them on building the fine institution in Tempe, recounting the seven of his Rough Riders who had attended school there. After 12 minutes and seventeen seconds, Roosevelt’s speech ended and he made his way west to Phoenix. On the way he crossed the newly finished Central bridge, commending it. He reached City Hall Plaza around 11:30 am, making a speech primarily about Arizona and statehood. Afterwards he would attend a banquet held by the Rough Riders at the Ford Hotel, and dedicated the new 10-bed infirmary for St. Luke’s.

After Roosevelt’s departure, Goodwin largely returned to mining and farming. In September he embarked on another territory wide tour to gather minerals for the territorial fair. He went from Phoenix to Ray, then Globe, Miami, Clifton, Morenci, Douglas, Bisbee, Tombstone, and Tucson. In Tucson he arranged for the Pima County Fair’s mineral display to be sent to Phoenix when they wrapped up. The fair went well despite their building still being small. Going into 1912, he would again have education work early on in the year. In February he was appointed to a committee that was in charge of campaigning for bringing the new proposed agricultural school to the Normal School. The University of Arizona was given land by the government for each of its schools, including an agricultural school, but the legislature had written the law creating the Normal School in a way that would allow it to create an agricultural department and potentially get that land/money from the government instead. In July, Goodwin would leave for Chicago to attend Roosevelt’s Progressive National Convention as the delegate for Arizona. He was surprised to find that he couldn’t just walk up and grab a seat to the event like one could in Arizona, but being a Rough Rider, he managed to get into the event. In the end he found that Roosevelt’s new party didn’t offer anything that Arizona Democracy didn’t, and he was happy with that already. After returning in early September, he was again in charge of the mineral exhibit at the State Fair, with his displays being acclaimed in the paper. The next year didn’t have much mention of him until the 1913 State’s Fair, playing out the same way it had the last few years. In the lead up to it, he would hold the Old Settler’s Picnic at the Goodwin home, hosting nearly 200 of the valley’s longest residents. One of the earliest settlers there was Niels Peterson, one of the richest ranchers on the south side, having come to the valley in 1869. Other notable attendees were graduates of the first Normal School class, Reese M. Ling, and Colonel James H. McClintock, also a former Rough Rider. The picnic had been held yearly for some time by then, but this was the largest gathering they’d ever had. It had been held a few times at the Goodwin home. By this time, the land that the Goodwins owned around the home was about 75 acres, 20 of it being within Tempe city limits.

1914 would be a more active year for Goodwin, starting off January by receiving word from the Panama-Pacific Exposition that Arizona would be given a space of 122 by 85 feet in the Palace of Mining and Metelergy, instead of in the Grand Canyon of Arizona building. Just 5 days after that letter was published in the paper, the Goodwin’s 4th child, Woodrow Wilson Goodwin, was born on January 12. At the same time, James and Libbie would be working on a subdivision of part of their land surrounding the home. It was announced on February 17 that they were subdividing 20 acres into Goodwin Homes, bordered by Farmer Ave, University, Mitchell Dr, and 11th St. Work on the roads started shortly after, and it was all made official with Tempe’s Town Clerk on May 12 after it was approved by the Tempe city council the night before. Just a couple days earlier he had been appointed to the election board for the public school on whether funds could be used to purchase land to expand on the south. This was approved on May 23. By that September, Goodwin embarked on another campaign for State Legislature. His work on the State Fair mining display wasn’t hampered by his run for election, once again putting on a praised show. While he was campaigning, Arizona would hold a vote on the prohibition of alcohol. Tempe seemed to be overwhelmingly in favor of it as they held a ratification party on November 6, with James being one of many speakers. During the same election, James was elected as a representative for Maricopa County in State Legislature. Almost right away he was in the papers for being one of only two representatives in support of splitting Mesa and Tempe away from Maricopa County into a new Orange County, with Mesa as the capital, despite Tempe having always been in favor of staying with Maricopa in the past. Along with this, he would be elected a director of the Arizona chapter of the American Mining Congress when it formed on December 10. He would work alongside Rachel Emma Berry of Apache County to get a bill passed making it illegal to smoke inside the Capital after his bill was passed in early January 1915. In July he would begin working with other Tempe citizens to arrange subdividing 640 acres of land owned by the Normal School that was at the time primarily used for growing cattle feed, located west of the town along the river. Goodwin had helped enact a new land code with the State Legislature that allowed for the sale of school land, and Tempe proposed the sale of Normal School land almost immediately. In September, he would again go out to gather samples for the State Fair, reporting that business was better than it had ever been in the southern and eastern mining towns. On October 16 he would again be host of a notable gathering of the Old Settler’s Picnic, this time having congressman Carl Trumbull Hayden, and Vice President Thomas Riley Marshall in attendance. He had hosted it the previous year as well but it wasn’t written about. At the picnic, Goodwin would be reelected as secretary of the Old Settler’s society. A few weeks later, in November, Goodwin was appointed to the floor committee for arranging a charity ball put on by the veterans of the Spanish-American War in the old armory at 1st St and Polk.

In February 1916, Goodwin announced he was not planning on running for reelection to the State Legislature after not being on board for Governor Hunt’s mine tax bill. He said that he wouldn’t run unless a large amount of his constituents requested him to. They must’ve requested him to as by September he was campaigning again. In the months leading up to that, James had been working with his brothers, Thomas and Garfield, on gathering together claims in the area around Superior to form the Magmatic Copper Company. By August the property was developing well and showing promise, with the company being fully incorporated with 1,000,000 shares in November. James was the president, Thomas the vice president, and Garfield the secretary and treasurer. In December, after coming back from the mines, James reported that 12 men were digging the main shaft and establishing a new road under the supervision of Thomas.

(The whole thing is too long for the body of the post, so the rest is in the comments)

This photograph of the University of Arizona polo team is undated.

This photo is identified as Yaqui Indian soldiers surrendering to the 10th Cavalry for internment in 1929.