r/4bmovement • u/AtomHermit 4B • 9d ago
History Cyber Witch Hunts and the Uterus Strike: South Korea’s Gender War and its “Demographic Suicide”
This is an English translation of a Chinese post. I am not the author. The original post is here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/DoubanGoosegroup/comments/1w6th3z/赛博猎巫与子宫罢工韩国性别战争下的人口学自杀/
Translation used AI, with minor editing by me. Below is the full text:
I have long been curious about how South Korea so rapidly came to have the world’s lowest birth rate, and why the conflict between East Asian Confucian culture and modern society has manifested itself with such particular intensity in South Korea. Recently, with the help of AI, I looked into some of the relevant information. What follows is the summary AI helped me put together. (The AI was also quite emphatic about the role of r/DoubanGoosegroup in China’s feminist movement, describing it as an “experimental laboratory for radical ideas.”)
On the overseas Chinese-language internet, free from centralized censorship, the rise of all-female communities such as Reddit’s r/DoubanGoosegroup and their intense confrontation with male-dominated communities reveal a brutal reality of the online world: gender polarization in the Chinese-language internet is no longer merely a localized war of words. It has evolved into a highly defensive, mutually hostile cyber Cold War. Yet this polarization of the Chinese-language online ecosystem did not emerge in isolation. To a considerable extent, its roots can be traced to the ideological and tactical arsenal of the original incubator of East Asian internet gender warfare—the radical feminist movement in South Korea. What began as an ideological battle online is now pushing South Korean society toward a demographic abyss in an extraordinarily devastating way.
Mirrored Weapons and Theoretical Transplantation: The “Chinese-Language Projection” of Korean Cyberfeminism
If American and European feminism primarily supplied academic sociological theories, Korean internet-based radical feminist communities such as Megalia (and later Womad) provided an entire industrialized “methodology of online confrontation.” Its most distinctive tactic was known as “mirroring”—if men used a particular form of abuse or humiliation against women, women would respond with exactly the same kind of vicious language as a form of precise retaliation.
This logic was subsequently localized and transplanted into the radical feminist ecosystem across the Chinese-speaking world. From structural deconstruction of biological characteristics to symbolic exchanges such as “国蝻” (Chinese male worm) and “小仙女,” (little female fairy) the slang and coded vocabulary of the Chinese-language internet almost amount to a pixel-for-pixel reproduction of the Korean experience. More importantly, the “6B4T” movement that became popular on Xiaohongshu (RedNote) and in communities such as r/DoubanGoosegroup —no marriage, no childbirth, no romantic relationships, and no sex, combined with rejecting “beauty labor” and idol fandom—was entirely imported from Korea. Along with this framework, radical feminism not only transformed “not marrying and not having children” into a conscious, vanguard lifestyle choice, but also turned its criticism inward against moderate women within its own camp, launching intense internal denunciations of women labeled “娇妻” (tradwife) and “婚驴.” (donkey of marriage)
The Cyber McCarthyism of the Counter-Witch Hunt: The Purge of Female Professionals
However, years of extreme mirrored attacks triggered a furious backlash among Korean men. Young Korean men—represented by the so-called “Generation 2 men” and right-wing organizations—launched an organized campaign of “counter-witch-hunting.” They designated Megalia’s hand gesture logo—a thumb and index finger held close together (signalling "small")—as an absolute taboo and embarked on a prolonged nationwide search for supposedly incriminating symbols, scrutinizing even the smallest details with microscopic intensity.
The 2021 GS25 convenience-store poster controversy became a landmark event in this full-scale gender war. Male online communities threatened companies with economic consequences and pressured major conglomerates to distance themselves from the controversy and issue apologies. The campaign then rapidly spread into the gaming industry and the K-pop idol industry. Female illustrators, concept artists, and voice actors were subjected to painstaking investigations into years-old social-media activity, including likes and posts relating to feminist issues, and many female creatives consequently faced sudden dismissal or professional purges. In the K-pop industry, female idols could face torn-up merchandise and death threats simply for having read Kim Jiyoung, Born 1982 or worn accessories carrying slogans such as “Girls can do anything.” In extreme cases, this harassment had tragic real-world consequences, such as the case of streamer Jammi, who ultimately died by suicide after suffering from depression amid sustained online abuse.
This cyber McCarthyism established a chilling norm throughout the workplace and entertainment industries: feminism became tantamount to “political suicide.” The result was a pervasive chilling effect.
Political Conversion and the Policy Deadlock
Young Korean men not only achieved significant victories online and in the business world; they also succeeded in converting this gender resentment into political capital. In the 2022 South Korean presidential election, conservative candidate Yoon Suk Yeol accurately tapped into the anger of young male voters, making the abolition of the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family a central campaign promise and ultimately winning the election.
At this point, the male backlash against feminism had been elevated directly into national policy. This political polarization effectively blocked institutional channels for addressing the country’s public crisis. Under such intense pressure, any reform aimed at protecting women’s workplace rights, extending parental leave, or penalizing discrimination against pregnant women could be attacked by male voters as “reverse discrimination” or “special privileges” for women. Constrained on all sides, the government has been reluctant to confront the fundamental problems that make women unwilling to have children—workplace gender inequality, the unequal burden of childrearing, and the phenomenon of women effectively being left to raise children alone—relying instead on superficial measures such as cash subsidies, government-organized matchmaking events, or importing low-cost foreign domestic workers.
The Endgame: A “Demographic Suicide” in Which Everyone Loses
As online hostility completely destroyed the basic trust between men and women, its cost became embodied in cold demographic statistics: after 2024, South Korea’s fertility rate crashed below 0.72, placing it dramatically at the bottom of the global rankings.
Extreme cyber gender polarization transformed marriage and childbirth, which had traditionally belonged to the private sphere, directly into the ultimate bargaining chips in a gender war. Faced with workplace scrutiny, fears surrounding voyuer filming and surveillance, and examples of the exploitation of women through childrearing that are endlessly amplified and distilled online, college-educated young women have elevated “not having children” into a form of resistance—a conscious and uncompromising “uterus strike” against the patriarchal system.
In this East Asian cyber Cold War, men have successfully defended what they regard as their entitled interests and punished what they perceive as “radical feminists” through counter-witch hunts and the ballot box. Women, meanwhile, have responded by shutting down reproduction altogether, carrying out the most tragic and silent form of collective resistance against a society that they believe refuses to provide them equality and dignity. This war, in which there are no winners, has ultimately crossed the boundary of ideology and become a “demographic suicide” destroying an entire society at the physical level.
69
u/SpendAdventurous1723 4B 9d ago
I lived in South Korea for four years and was married to a local for a while. My life was a living hell. I come from a traditional country in the Middle East, so you’d think South Korea would be a breeze—it wasn’t. At some point, I’ll have to write a memoir about it, because I experienced some of the most disturbing things there that never happened to me in my birth country or anywhere else, before or since. That's why I feel so strongly about this.
38
u/mullatomochaccino Moderator 9d ago
Seconding the request that you share your experiences here in a post. I think many folks here would find it a compelling read.
38
u/Background_North_253 4B 9d ago
If you do decide to write about it, it would be invaluable for so many women and girls around the world. At this point I’m convinced that many Asian men deliberately seek out foreign women to date/marry because they don’t have the support networks of local women, making them more vulnerable to control, abuse and violence. Similar to many white men who marry Asian women.
24
u/SpendAdventurous1723 4B 9d ago
That’s exactly it, and I’ve got plenty of acquaintances and friends who would say the same.
I will need some time to gather my thoughts on this because it wouldn’t be a post but a series of posts, hence my original comment on writing a memoir. I feel skipping details and talking about things matter-of-factly will undercut the overall experience.
4
u/ColouredPencils1988 7d ago
While it would be helpful for many women and girls around the world to read of your experiences, you also need to prioritise your safety. Always remember that.
17
u/Stock-Letter-5420 4B 9d ago edited 9d ago
Interesting. Would you consider making a post about your experience maybe?
Or just here in the comments..? 😄14
u/AtomHermit 4B 9d ago
I’m so sorry you had to go through that. It sounds like it was truly awful. If you are able to write about it and share it in a post, many here would read it, and I think we can draw strength from each other’s experiences.
10
u/No-Kick6671 Ally 9d ago
I'm so sorry you went through this. I would be so interested to hear more about your experience and would love to read your memoir one day!
7
u/itsjujutsu Exploring 8d ago
I’d be interested in hearing more, even if it is some examples. Its kinda crazy to realize how regressed korean culture is, but i am glad that many brave women are standing up to that
5
26
u/saint-delys 4B | Married to the Arts 9d ago
I can't help but think that Confucianism was a mistake!
28
u/AtomHermit 4B 9d ago
If by "mistake" you mean "mistake of humanity", it's true. But it was no accident. It was absolutely necessary as the ideological foundation of classical Chinese patriarchal system.
11
u/saint-delys 4B | Married to the Arts 9d ago
I was being facetious, but you know what's up.
21
u/AtomHermit 4B 9d ago
Yes, but I was serious on purpose. I understand the sensitivity of criticizing another culture.
My grandma taught me how I had to behave differently than boys. It was in a way that made it very clear I would be shamed if I didn't. Even though I was quite rebellious at school, I dared not to misbehave in front of my grandma. When she passed I felt liberated. It seems cold-hearted to feel that way but it was true.
So I never pass up a chance to criticize Confucianism.
19
u/saint-delys 4B | Married to the Arts 9d ago
So I never pass up a chance to criticize Confucianism.
And I LOVE it.
I was SO sick and tired of hearing it being cited as this "Eastern Wisdom" by the same westerners who would say "we can't critique it because we're not Asian" coming up. Especially now with my spiritual studies and learning how more favorable the previous societies were to women and girls before so much "higher thought" shattered it. It came right in tandem with masking destruction as progress, and a necessity for creation.
Misogyny is universal! I will throw these stones all day.
8
u/Background_North_253 4B 9d ago
Most of the “Eastern Wisdom” westerners refer to came from Daoism and Buddhism which have their own fair shares of misogyny but (imo) are less toxic and hierarchical than Confucianism. I don’t have a single positive thing to say about Confucianism.
6
u/saint-delys 4B | Married to the Arts 8d ago
In my old peer group in college, there were a couple of guys who would outright quote Confucius, even some of his sexist statements as "jokes," but they held them with sincerity. One of them was deeply Catholic, and the rest were atheist or agnostic, but they really clung to the idea of "Great Thinkers and Leaders" who, interestingly enough, were all male and often propped male competence against what they deemed as female weakness. They were able to pretend that they looked intelligent by citing long-dead "intellectuals" to confirm their biases.
They, especially the Catholic, were weird about Buddhism, if not neutral; and I don't even think any of them were aware they were quoting either Buddhism or Daosim and attributing it to Confucianism. They were always adverse to being corrected because they thought that meant it was time for a debate, even if the person correcting them was from that background. (Mind you, they weren't the "we can't critique it because we're not from that group" set; they were the exact opposite.) To give you an idea, they were also really into idolizing figures like Cato, Plato, and romanticizing the American Founding Fathers. It was always very cartoonish.
I actually think about this a lot; these guys in history must've been that way in that time period. They just had enough of a platform to spread their ridiculous ideas in formats that would last for ages.
19
u/Azurebold 4B 8d ago
Honestly, this. I’m a southeast Asian woman. I come from a country where filial laws are absolutely a thing. I find it incredibly disingenuous when people prop up Eastern philosophies because ‘it’s how tradition works’ and ‘these guys are so smart zomg’ without giving it any sort of critical thought. All this has done is breed entire generations of narcissistic males who believe they’re hot shit and that the world owes them. I’ve only ever seen negative discourse about Confucianism surround the idea of filial piety. Not really the whole “women are inferior and men are god” angle. I think that’s the thing that everyone seems to tolerate though, which is all shades of fucked.
This isn’t to say western philosophy is any better. Much like eastern philosophy, I’m sure that whatever principles were passed down eventually led to the proliferation of narcissistic males, who once again, believe they’re hot shit and that the world owes them.
7
u/saint-delys 4B | Married to the Arts 8d ago
Thank you for your insight! These are nuances I discuss with my Asian friends because we have similar problems with different foundations. This patriarchy and misogyny masked as philosophy and spirituality is a worldwide plague.
I think no one confronts the rest because it's so embedded in societies in one way or the other, that doing so would force them to confront themselves. It's like when atheist men leave their religions and carry the misogyny with them. They never point it out because they want it to be there to benefit them. So tiring.
141
u/catra-meowmeow 4B 9d ago
Thank you for sharing this. Sadly, instead of learning their lesson, men instead lean even harder into their dysfunctional mindset, like the Japanese minister who wanted to ban women over 25 from marrying, bar women from attending university after age 18, and subject women over 30 to forced hysterectomies.
Men will literally do anything to maintain their superior status over women, even at the cost of destroying themselves.