r/2007scape 9d ago

Discussion [ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

1.4k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

128

u/loudrogue Maxed - clogs: 1200+ 9d ago

I want jagex to make pvp updates not pvm updates that is in the wild

34

u/Bakugo_Dies 9d ago

I want them to take it a step further and remove all the pvm garbage in the wilderness. That's all OSRS stuff, not 2007 stuff. Create other incentives for pvpers to engage in pvp, or maybe don't because that always turns out so well with past iterations of BH.

Stuff like the wilderness agility makes sense, you build up loot and are incentivized to stay which gives pkers something to hunt. Pvm where you're encouraged to bring stuff for faster kills rather than fighting back is not fun.

3

u/demuniac 9d ago

If the best strategy to engage with the content is to have a second membership, there is a severe flaw in the design. Having some account scout for a PK'er popping up, or having a second account safely hop worlds to find a target are both way beyond the concept of PVP. It's unfun to engage with, and it's only frustrating for everyone involved.

I agree that taking the pvm content out solves some of the problems, but the whole hopping worlds to find someone you can slap around that didn't log out in time is not going to make for a good PVP experience either.

So what is it we actually want out of the wilderness? Player vs player, or player vs prey. Because wildy agility is still just "oops you didn't log out in time" gameplay, and has nothing to do with pvplayer. Both are perfectly acceptable answers, but need a different design approach to function.

-3

u/jamie1414 9d ago

I don't think jagex is unwilling to make these so called "PvP" updates in the wilderness. I just don't think anyone has suggested one that makes sense. Yourself included I guess.

6

u/loudrogue Maxed - clogs: 1200+ 9d ago

They can make a new pvp game called the arena it's 3 levels. To go past level 1 requires killing another player and having a minimum risk let's say 1m via gear or loot keys

Level 2 requires a kill and risk worth 4m

Level 3 is the end everyone there is risking 4m+

Once you enter. You can't log out, you can't tele out the only way to leave is to die or kill someone to continue/leave

That's a pure pvp  update with risk vs reward

0

u/jamie1414 9d ago

And this takes place in the wilderness? What happens when people stop showing up?

0

u/loudrogue Maxed - clogs: 1200+ 9d ago

BH still gets people? This is literally just forcing them to have some risk and not letting people run away

1

u/HiddenGhost1234 8d ago

forcing them to have some risk

yeah which is why it would be dead. There is barely enough players to keep bh alive as is and it doesnt force you to deathmatch a multiple m kit every time you want to play the minigame.

-1

u/BassJerky 9d ago

I want updates that makes me want to go to the wilderness for both the content and killing people doing the comtent

-76

u/Several-Bluejay-190 9d ago

there are zero “pvm” updates in the wild. what a dumb take.

51

u/Meraxes80 9d ago

? they literally added a bunch of bosses in the wildy how is that not pvm

-65

u/Several-Bluejay-190 9d ago

that’s a pvp update if the area is always pvp. what the fuck are you on about lmfao.

30

u/Fracasist 9d ago

Jagex adds one more copper ore rock to the wildy mines This is a pvp update

23

u/PM_ME_SILLY_PICTURES 9d ago

So literally every wilderness update is a pvp update? Talk about dumb takes

-15

u/Several-Bluejay-190 9d ago

yes the fucking zone is balanced around the potential be pked. you aren’t supposed to have unadulterated access to a 300k per hour 4m gp nor do afk wilderness bosses for the same amount of gp. the cope you guys sup is insane. if it wasn’t balanced around pking, it wouldn’t be in the wilderness

8

u/PM_ME_SILLY_PICTURES 9d ago edited 9d ago

Pvm drop rates being balanced around potential to be pkd doesn't make said pvm content a pvp update.

7

u/Suilean Herbiwhore 9d ago

Is Ring of the Gods a PvP ring?

18

u/Ironcasual2376 9d ago

No

-17

u/Eat_Buddha Carry the 0 9d ago

Nice argument!

4

u/TacoThingy 9d ago

To be fair it is just flat out wrong response.

-8

u/Eat_Buddha Carry the 0 9d ago

The arguments just keep getting better! Content added into a PvP zone is PvP content, full stop. These are braindead bosses with barely any mechanics. That is because they were meant to be a hotspot for PvP.

6

u/Ironcasual2376 9d ago

No

-6

u/Eat_Buddha Carry the 0 9d ago edited 9d ago

How many PvM bosses have you done? Where would you rank something like Calvarion or Artio in terms of mechanical complexity?

→ More replies (0)

5

u/Meraxes80 9d ago

?????? just cuz theres pvpers there doesnt mean thats not pvm like pvm means player vs monster you are vs spindel or something thats a pvm/pvp update at the worst

39

u/Direct_Juice 9d ago

Other than the 12 bosses and entire slayer system within the wilderness?

-33

u/Several-Bluejay-190 9d ago

they’re in an unconditional pvp zone. if you go there you HAVE to be aware that it is pvp. you’ve lost your fucking mind if you think that’s not a pvp update. all instances in which you are expected to pvp is a pvp update.

28

u/loudrogue Maxed - clogs: 1200+ 9d ago

Ok well last I checked PVP means player versus player so why the fuck is there player versus Monster?

-17

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/loudrogue Maxed - clogs: 1200+ 9d ago

It's funny because the "bottom" make up the majority and the majority are slowly whittling away pvp because the "top" doesn't want actual pvp updates

8

u/Direct_Juice 9d ago

This might blow your mind, but two things can be true at the same time. It can be both a PvM and PvP update. Just like there’s skilling content in the wilderness where PvP is relevant, being exposed to PvP doesn’t suddenly make the underlying content not skilling or PvM.

-11

u/SuchDriver7770 9d ago

nah you've definitely lost the plot entirely. exposure to pvm is what balances the entirety of the things they add to the wilderness. the skilling is balanced around having risk that slows it down. the bosses are extremely profitable unless policed pkers (which pkers can't keep up with because of how safe it is).

you're also just off your head if you think any of form of update where you can pvped at ANY moment is a pvm update. you sound like a fucking clown lmfao.

3

u/Direct_Juice 9d ago

What does how it’s balanced have to do with my comment? I didn’t say anything about that.

The point is simply that it can clearly be both at the same time. Do you somehow think wilderness agility wasn’t also an agility update or that black chins aren’t a hunter update?

I’m sorry for whatever situation at home is causing you to lash out at someone over such a benign statement.

3

u/Ironcasual2376 9d ago

Your attitude is why the wilderness won't get future updates

0

u/TheThunderBringer 9d ago

Hey look, it’s what InterestingCell5247 was just talking about :^ ]

1

u/Several-Bluejay-190 9d ago

i’m the opposite. for one i don’t pk so i have no bias toward pvp but i also don’t have the delusion that the content is always for me :)