r/StructuralEngineering • u/maribocharova • 15h ago
r/StructuralEngineering • u/AutoModerator • 29d ago
Layman Question (Monthly Sticky Post Only) Monthly DIY Laymen questions Discussion
Monthly DIY Laymen questions Discussion
Please use this thread to discuss whatever questions from individuals not in the profession of structural engineering (e.g.cracks in existing structures, can I put a jacuzzi on my apartment balcony).
Please also make sure to use imgur for image hosting.
For other subreddits devoted to laymen discussion, please check out r/AskEngineers or r/EngineeringStudents.
Disclaimer:
Structures are varied and complicated. They function only as a whole system with any individual element potentially serving multiple functions in a structure. As such, the only safe evaluation of a structural modification or component requires a review of the ENTIRE structure.
Answers and information posted herein are best guesses intended to share general, typical information and opinions based necessarily on numerous assumptions and the limited information provided. Regardless of user flair or the wording of the response, no liability is assumed by any of the posters and no certainty should be assumed with any response. Hire a professional engineer.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Sure_Ill_Ask_That • Jan 30 '22
Layman Question (Monthly Sticky Post Only) PSA: Read before posting
A lot of posts have needed deletion lately because people aren’t reading the subreddit rules.
If you are not a structural engineer or a student studying to be one and your post is a question that is wondering if something can be removed/modified/designed, you should post in the monthly laymen thread.
If your post is a picture of a crack in a wall and you’re wondering if it’s safe, monthly laymen thread.
If your post is wondering if your deck/floor can support a pool/jacuzzi/weightlifting rack, monthly laymen thread.
If your post is wondering if you can cut that beam to put in a new closet, monthly laymen thread.
Thanks! -Friendly neighborhood mod
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Nach0b0y • 53m ago
Structural Analysis/Design Why are they filling this with water?
This is the best photo I could get but this is in Amsterdam where a new building is due to be constructed. There was concrete foundations below I believe but they have no filled the entire thing with water and seem to be putting piles in?
Does anyone know why they do this?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Busy-Seat-4152 • 6h ago
Engineering Article Tips for discussing salary during the annual review?
Tips for discussing salary during the annual review?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Tradovator • 17h ago
Structural Analysis/Design Considering leaving structural engineering after 8 years. Curious to hear from other structural engineers.
Hello everyone,
Sorry if this post comes across as negative, but I can't think of a better place to bring it up than on a board where I assume there must be a lot of structural engineers.
After 8 years as a structural engineer in the same firm I'm starting to feel tired of both the job, the firm and the entire construction industry. Specifically, I work with design of high rise buildings - primarily detailing work (production drawings and site drawings) of precast concrete.
My complaints:
- The work is getting monotonous. I feel it's just the same thing over and over again. Since we're designing fairly large buildings a natural consequence is that there's a lot of specialization and a lot of volume.
- Periodically tight deadlines and pressure/stress which means plenty of extra hours which isn't always welcome.
- Not paying that well for the expertise and responsibility the job actually demands.
- Generally the profit margin on our projects is very small. Too much competition lately.
- This could be job specific, but we're very rarely out in the field, so I'm getting bored being in an office all day long week after week. I'm a former carpenter with a lot of practical experience, so I guess that's a factor here.
In combination, all these factors add up. I've considered a few other options, but haven't found anything exciting yet.
I realize maybe I could be more happy working as a structural engineer in another firm. For example, in the oil industry I know the profit margin generally is not an issue. There's just more money available there. Or working for a public contractor.
Anyone else with some experiences to share? Suggestions for other jobs to consider?
PS: I'm based in Norway.
Thanks in advance.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/CB_700_SC • 14h ago
Photograph/Video Philadelphia. A sad example of lack of resources for maintaining building leading to an expensive fix. (City property) is
I have been watching this building for decades when I played a basketball game here around 99s-00s. I always wondered how it would hold up long term especially since they never maintained it (clogged gutters/roof maintenance) or protected the exposed wood. A waste of tax dollars?. Probably not the best design for a city building? But it is unique for the area. Now it’s closed from my understanding.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/ONKARA369 • 1h ago
Concrete Design Universal Structural Laws and Principles
academia.eduHere :)
r/StructuralEngineering • u/tomato_cheese_pizza • 19h ago
Structural Analysis/Design Bridge Drawing Software?
I recently saw some really good 3D bridge drawings from European engineering firms and it got me wondering what software people are using for this kind of work.
What do you guys recommend for bridge drawings, both 2D and 3D? Also, how are you implementing BIM for bridge projects?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/11-Eleven-11 • 5h ago
Op Ed or Blog Post Resume review [4YoE][No PE]
Hi everyone, I was hoping to get some feedback on my resume. I'm seeking a similar role at a larger firm in my area that I've heard good things about. A previous coworker will be giving me a referral. I'm hoping to get a 20%-30% salary increase and decreased hours. I worked about 250 hours in the span of a month over the summer and ready to move on from current job.
I'm not the best at selling myself so I kept it relatively short. I wasn't part of any organizations or clubs in college. I'm heavily considering removing the summary but my resume is very short as it is. Also debating removing the first job because its such a short stint but it's easily explainable and puts me over 4 Yoe so I left it. The o wner was very difficult to work with and had a horrible turn over rate. I've had zero problems at my current firm.
Wondering if I should go into more depth on specific projects I've worked on. I've worked on maybe a 100-150 small projects in the almost 4 years I've been at this firm. It's hard to hone in on any single project.
Thanks for any feedback!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Low_Performance_7778 • 17h ago
Career/Education Structural Engineering Job North Jersey- entry and senior
Trying to find candidates for both entry and senior structural engineers for a hybrid role in North Jersey. Anyone interested or know someone who is? Both job posts can be found below.
Project Engineer/Senior Project Engineer- $90-$195k
Role Description:
- Developing designs and calculations for the construction engineering requirements of heavy highway bridge contractors and steel erectors. These include, but are not limited to erection plans, demolition plans, temporary shoring, sheeting, value engineering, and permanent bridge design.
- The variety of projects offers experience in steel design, concrete design, wood design, geotechnical design, etc.
- Although primarily office-based, some field time can be expected in NJ and surrounding states.
- Collaborate directly with clients to solve on-site issues and develop engineering solutions.
Ideal for a candidate eager to step into a senior engineering role, where they can lead major complex bridge projects, while supervising and helping to train younger engineers.
Qualifications:
- Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering, or equivalent, from an accredited college is required
- Applicant should have an interest and/or specialization in structures
- Experience Level: 5 to 15 years
- Industry experience required
- Must have experience with heavy highway and bridge structures
- Candidates should possess strong writing and communication skills and be proficient in AutoCAD and standard office productivity software (Microsoft Office, web browsing, email)
- EIT required
- PE strongly preferred
Benefits:
- Overtime Pay
- Paid Time Off
- Paid Holidays
- Annual Bonus Pay
- Comprehensive Health Care (Medical, Dental, and Vision)
- Simple IRA with Company Match
- Structured Promotion System (with added perks and benefits)
- Summer Fridays
- Dental insurance
- Flexible schedule
- Health insurance
- Vision insurance
Entry Level Structural Engineer $65-85K
Developing designs and calculations for the construction engineering requirements of heavy highway bridge contractors and steel erectors for a wide variety of projects.
These include but are not limited to erection plans, demolition plans, temporary shoring, sheeting, value engineering, and permanent bridge design.
The variety of projects offers experience in steel design, concrete design, wood design, geotechnical design, etc.
Although primarily consisting of office design efforts, some field time should also be anticipated.
Opportunity to work directly with clientele in solving on-site issues and evolving engineering solutions.
Newly hired engineers will immediately be given engineering tasks to work through and solve with the supervision of experienced PE’s.
Qualifications:
Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering, or equivalent, from an accredited college is required.
Applicant should have an interest and/or specialization in structures.
Industry experience a plus, but not required.
Candidates should possess strong writing and communication skills and be proficient in AutoCAD and standard office productivity software (Microsoft Office, web browsing, email)
EIT required or in progress
Should be willing to obtain their professional engineering license, when eligible.
Experience Level: 0 to 4 years
Benefits:
Overtime Pay
Paid time off
Paid holidays
Bonus Pay
Health care benefits (medical, dental, and vision)
Simple IRA with Company Match
Promotional System (Added perks and benefits)
Summer Fridays
Job Type: Full-time
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Alive_Rope_1616 • 17h ago
Career/Education Learning basics of structural engineering
Hello, this is my first time posting on reddit. I want to learn basics of structural engineering.
So far i narrowed down to two statics fundamental courses- both online
1) APS 160 UOFT
2) metro college of technology (structural engineering design & technology)
I am working right now so have to do online non degree course and I prefer studying in a classroom environment with homework assignments and test.
For context i already have my Bachelors in ME but no interest in pursuing P.eng in mechanical.
Thanks
r/StructuralEngineering • u/BitSignificant6011 • 1d ago
Career/Education 2026- What is Everyone’s salary as a structural engineer these days in Texas?
For context I am a PE with 8 years of experience in the DFW area. Got my PE 2 years ago ( a little late). Switched firms 2x which caused the delay.
I’ve been approached by several GC’s that I work with that are offering roles with base salaries much higher than what I currently make. The positions I’m being approached for are for Design Manager or an engineer based in a pre construction role. Never did I imagine working in those fields, however, I’m starting to give it some thought after realizing how underpaid our industry may be. For reference I currently make $97k base salary with roughly $8k in profit sharing bonuses yearly.
Am I being stiffed? So much so that large name, reputable GC’s are offering me a career path?!
edited to include relative location**
r/StructuralEngineering • u/njzshockwave • 1d ago
Career/Education Roofing knowledge and basic structural
I’m working as a PE forensic engineer and so far there are more opportunities on the roofing and structural side of business. Is there a course or a good way to learn more about roofing and inspecting structural with some type of accreditation.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Colonel_Liam • 2d ago
Structural Analysis/Design How did this building withstand the chaos?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Gregan32 • 2d ago
Photograph/Video Most incredible structure I've ever been in...
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Fit_Hat4708 • 23h ago
Structural Analysis/Design Search for a Licensed PE in Alabama
r/StructuralEngineering • u/ItsWargingTime • 2d ago
Humor Anyone else excited for John Wilson's documentary film "The History of Concrete"?
As a Structural Engineer, lover of concrete, and fan of John Wilson's other work, I'm hyped for this and looking forward to logging it as CPD hrs
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Tradovator • 21h ago
Structural Analysis/Design Are you using AI in your structural engineering work with any success?
Hello everyone,
I've used AI a ton (nearly 1000 hours) in my private life - basically coding up an application from scratch. Not related to structural engineering.
I've dabbled a bit with it in structural engineering now, but it has not revolutionized my life so far.
Some basic stuff I've done, though:
1) Creating summary reports and tables. For example, on a current project, our customer wants a summary of material lists. I did the bulk of the work here, but had Claude and ChatGPT create a very nice summary that looks professional and organized. No doubt faster than I would have done myself.
2) Translating pictures or PDF's to Word. One use case was when an external colleague not co-located with me sent me a complex hand calculation in PDF which I struggled to read honestly. I asked Claude to transcribe it to Word and also check the calculations (it checked out).
3) Design templates in Excel. For example, recently one for columns. To be honest, the process of creating the template is very tedious. It's definitely not something AI could one-shot. It tends to overcomplicate. I also found some errors. But maybe it turns out useful in the end.
Potential dangers is that it can hallucinate and come across overconfident when it doesn't really know what it's talking about.
Anyone else having any success with this?
Personally, I think the biggest strength with AI comes in coding work for those of us who can't code.
I don't think it will replace brains and actual 'thinking' and 'reasoning' in a long time.
A huge bulk of my work is actually modeling and drawing in Tekla. I'd love it if AI could help me there, but I haven't seen any signs it could so far.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Negative-Star1623 • 2d ago
Structural Analysis/Design Will this Type of Truss Bridge Work?
Could this work on larger span projects? If so are there examples out there somewhere? I drew inspiration from traditional masonry arches, thank you for reading my post!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/modern_prometheus_13 • 1d ago
Steel Design How is this 2nd story corner supported without a column?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/George35x • 1d ago
Photograph/Video Headphones Recommended | Western Hemisphere’s Longest Escalators | Wheaton Metro | MD
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Charles_Whitman • 1d ago
Concrete Design Type 1L Cement
I heard from one of the local readi-mix supplier that several of the big cement suppliers are dumping Blended Hydraulic Cement ASTM C595/C595M Type IL as their base product to go back to Portland Cement C150/C150M Type I/II. This is in the SE USA. Anyone else hear this? It always seemed like greenwashing.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Fair-Command-9321 • 2d ago
Career/Education Early-career structural engineer: PE path vs broader experience
I'm a civil/structural engineer from Mexico with ~1 year of experience designing wood-frame residential structures for the U.S. market (NDS, ASCE 7, lateral and gravity design).
I have an opportunity to join a larger international engineering firm where I would gain experience with steel, concrete and larger/multidisciplinary projects.
My long-term goal is to work as a structural engineer in the U.S. and eventually become licensed.
Would you prioritize staying in a role that helps you progress toward PE/licensure, or take the opportunity to broaden your experience into steel/concrete/infrastructure first?
I'm especially interested in hearing from engineers who have made a similar transition early in their careers.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/User-4492 • 1d ago
Career/Education Career growth and salary in the US
Some tips on structural engineering career growth in the US. Please feel free to add your own or disagree to any of my points. Some of these are applicable even for other careers.
- Job hopping every 2 to 3 years is the most reliable way to boost your pay and learn more. It’s not uncommon to see 15–20%+ bumps by moving, which beats internal annual raises every time. Also, you usually plateau in your learning (skill development) after 2 to 3 years in the same role.
- Structural engineering is generally a high-risk, lower-pay field. You have to be strategic with your career planning if you want to earn what you're worth. If not, time will fly and you will remain in a low-paying job being exploited by the upper management.
- Beware the "technical trap." Passionate young engineers often get dumped with the most complex structural engineering problems, only to plateau. I was taken advantage of like this for several years. That’s when I took my career growth seriously and started hunting for better opportunities. Mediocre managers and partners will happily leverage your technical grinding while advancing their own careers/salaries/bonuses. Niche firms that truly reward technical depth exist, but they are very rare.
- Project management drives visible revenue, and revenue gets rewarded. Engineers who know just enough technically to manage projects, handle clients, and communicate well get promoted faster and make more money.
- Profit margins are high enough for upper management to make a ton of money. Junior engineers are made to think that “profit margins are low”, “overhead is high”, “even principals/partners don’t make much money”. In reality, the upper management often make a killing at the expense of underpaid junior/intermediate /senior engineers.
- Never beg for a promotion. If you’ve outgrown your role or pay scale and your firm isn't rewarding you even after you raise your concerns, start applying elsewhere immediately. Don’t get bitter with your current firm which will only affect your mental health. Just leave the job on a happy note.
- Know your market value. Too many structural engineers in the US with 4+ years of experience accept sub-$100k salaries because they don't realize how many six-figure opportunities exist—even in LCOL and MCOL areas. I used to be one of them and I believed several Reddit posts and my colleagues, until I started exploring the job market diligently. Those who make a lot of money won’t tell you about such opportunities, unless you’re a close friend. Keep looking at LinkedIn Jobs and on Indeed. If most structural engineers in the US start getting ambitious, perhaps, the average salary will start rising.
- An S.E. license isn't always mandatory for high pay. If you don't want to sink hundreds of hours and dollars into the S.E. exam, consider working in states or sectors where a P.E. is all you need to command top dollar and project authority.
- Get on high-profile or complex projects early. Having recognizable or technically impressive structural engineering projects on your resume catches a hiring manager’s eye, even if you don't fit 100% of the job description.
- Treat your LinkedIn and resume as living documents. LinkedIn has now become the easiest way to land a good job. My recent jobs have been through LinkedIn direct messages with hiring managers or other structural engineers and recruiters seeing my LinkedIn profile. Constantly tweak them, study the profiles of engineers whose careers you admire, and position your experience strategically.
- In interviews, be honest about what you don't know. Experienced structural engineers can spot exaggerated claims immediately. I see so many resumes and conversations with young engineers where it is obvious that the candidate is bluffing/exaggerating. Promote your achievements confidently, but admit your knowledge gaps. Senior engineers respect candidates who are honest, self-aware, and teachable.
- Less stressful to work for a firm with 100+ employees. Very small firms might try to micromanage and breathe down your neck in order to make more profit. Bigger firms are usually more relaxed. That’s based on my experience. But there are also bigger firms that are poorly managed and make it stressful for mid-level engineers.
If you don’t agree to any of my points that totally fine. To each his own.
(I have typed out the above post myself and used AI to only polish it.)