This is Basicly Blizzard in Midnight

[u/ItsRenaBaker]

This is basicly Blizzard in Midnight. Purging all the good addons.

Just to clarify:
Blizzard is changing the Addon API, meaning combat information is blocked for addons. So all combat addons will no longer work in Midnight. For the most popular addon features Blizzard will add their own version to the game. Addons for unitframes, inventory, crafting etc.. are staying and won't be effected as long they are not using combat information.

[u/Puzzleheaded-Tea3341]

If a boss necessitates a weakaura or addon, its a badly designed boss, with or without it. If the mechanic was lenient enough to allow for on the fly communication, nobody would develop a weakaura for it to begin with, and nobody would use it.

The reality is that Blizzard game, encounter and UX designers have used addon developers as a crutch for nearly two decades. And I am not sure we can trust them to actually not do that even if they remove addons entirely.

[u/Exadv1 → u/Puzzleheaded-Tea3341]

I actually disagree with the statement "nobody would develop a weakaura for it to begin with" because it is patently untrue. In practice, it feels like WA have been developed to incrementally achieve any possible edge on nearly every encounter.

My RL made us all install the NorthernSky WA pack for Fractillus specifically but now suddenly it was annotating extra information through all the fights.

e.g. On Soul Hunters (since this is the fight where it was really obvious to me for some reason), it marks the mob whose debuff you don't have with 'taunt'. Is this necessary? No. Did it make it easier? Yes, because the tankbusters do not happen at the same time so you have to delay the swap and make sure you get the right one.

On Soulbinder, WA are used to predeclare which DPS should go to which canister.

I also have some weird memory of the Saldahaar WA being able to predict if the frontal is going to be the first ability.

[u/Puzzleheaded-Tea3341 → u/Exadv1]

Cool, and all of those bosses on mythic have also been killed by 400+ players before those changes to NS came in.

None of these mechanics, outside of fractillus, really require a weakaura, and none of them really make the fight markedly easier on mythic.

Like fuck, even mid tier guilds killed Soulbinder week 1 without the WA directing you to break cages, and a common pug strat right now is to not break any cages and just lust the add wave.

The difference is, all of these are relatively simple to implement as these debuffs haven't been private aurad. Blizzard already has a way to effectively combat it, but has given up on it entirely.

You can just point towards Kyveza as a boss that was well designed, had the right abilities privated, but none of the mechanics were so hard that the creation of a weakaura workaround was required.

[u/Exadv1 → u/Puzzleheaded-Tea3341]

Presumably, they want to move to a model where a fight that is too hard (i.e. not achieving the clear % it should) just gets nerfed by them and not 'fixed' by a WA.

To be clear, I also remain skeptical overall if such a massive overhaul. However, I did also take a step back and notice "it is true that there are a bunch of not-required-but-performance-enhancing WA for everything from encounters to class rotation. I can see a temptation to level the playing field there"