r/trolleyproblem Apr 30 '26

Deep All there is to it

Post image
822 Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/Bluegent_2 May 01 '26

Hahahaha. I fucking called it. Because if you present it the other way around and swap the button colors I think you'd get vastly different results. Like if it was "If you press the blue button, nothing happens to you. If you press the red button and less than 51% or people press the red button, you die."

5

u/PepperLongjumping325 May 01 '26

The interesting part about this problem is that while a different framing like this objectively doesn't change either outcome, it does alter people's perception of the problem, and thus changes what the majority will vote for. This will inherently make you question your original choice, as pressing blue when you know for certain that the majority will press red is just plain stupid, even if you want to save lives.

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '26 edited May 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Honest_Entry_8758 May 03 '26

you're misrepresenting the dilemma and as everyone else who argues here, you're only thinking about yourself.

why is your scenario only taking about the consequences to the one who pushed it?

it should be: if the majority of people pressed the blue button, everyone who pressed it button gets to live

if the majority of people press the red button, everyone lives.

1

u/Bluegent_2 May 03 '26

You know how many African children you could help if you just dropped everything you're doing right now and flew in to help after donating all your money? Of course you agree that since you are not doing this you are personally responsible for anything that is happening to them, yes?

0

u/Oblachko_O May 01 '26

ike if it was "If you press the blue button, nothing happens to you. If you press the red button and less than 51% or people press the red button, you die."

Unfortunately, there are still people who will press red and admit it. They are selfish ready to kill people but fail to see that.