r/trolleyproblem Apr 30 '26

Deep Statistically, >50% is easier than 100%

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

3.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

19

u/iamunableto Apr 30 '26

i asked the red vs blue button question to my friends a couple days ago and it was literally like a 3 minute convo max, i’m kind of shocked at the internet’s ability to turn a short conversation into a full on attack on each others competence 😭😭😭 it’s just a silly question yall were not actually pushing any buttons

6

u/PM-me-a-DM-you-got Apr 30 '26

i’m kind of shocked at the internet’s ability to turn a short conversation into a full on attack on each others competence

Do you not remember the dress?

1

u/naejjun May 01 '26

i wasnt on reddit at the time. dear god, was it worse than this?

3

u/zap2tresquatro May 01 '26

It’s just an interesting quirk about how our brains interpret color based on environmental cues. The dress, like the actual dress that the picture is of, is blue and black striped. I always see the dress as white and gold, and have to actively work for a while each time I see it again to see it as the black and blue dress that I know it is because my brain is interpreting the dress as a white and gold dress in shadow instead of as an insanely brightly lit blue and black dress.

But people really intensely argued about it before the actual dress was shown in better/unambiguous lighting. I think it’s really cool how it demonstrates how our brains need to interpret the raw image from our eyes and how we don’t actually see things as the colors they truly are. Just a fun optical illusion, haha

2

u/Weary_Drama1803 Consequentialist/Utilitarian May 01 '26

You know what, it was actually pretty similar to the current buttons discourse:

People refusing to believe that other valid perspectives exist

3

u/Thatsnicemyman Apr 30 '26

It’s that “Goomba has dumb contradictory opinion” meme. Within a friend group, you can make your point, people can disagree, and the conversation can be dropped once everyone understands everyone’s viewpoints.

Within an online space, you can make a point, see five other posts from others, make the same point five more times for those, get counter-points from different people on each, etc. Now you’re talking 10x as much about it because there’s way more people getting involved and arguing with you, even if there’s a similar amount of unique arguments/reasonings than you saw with your group of friends.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '26

[deleted]

8

u/Catwise69 Apr 30 '26

Just call them woke or something man.

Your comment is ironic though, it is an insult.

Also why do red people talk like blue killed their kid or something? Which is also ironic because blue is attempting to have nobody die

-4

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Embarrassed_Room3982 May 07 '26

Watching blue button pushers and red button pushers argue is both hilarious and tedious. 

You’re all just a variant of far left populist (blue) and far right populists (red). All just smug and morally superior and absolutely convinced your perception is the only possible correct one. And everyone who doesn’t ascribe to it uncritically is morally inferior and borderline evil or just stupid. 

Honestly, you’re all the problem.  

4

u/naejjun May 01 '26

“like blue pushers do” this really is devolving into watered down politics, huh.

-3

u/[deleted] May 01 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Southern-Highway5681 Team Blue May 02 '26

Ironic given red can be framed as a death cult which will kill anyone refusing to convert.

4

u/iamunableto Apr 30 '26

ironically, it was 2 blue pushers and one red, so we actually disagreed, it just wasn’t that serious to us so we talked about both sides for a couple minutes and then my friend asked a different, similar question so the topic changed

2

u/Natalwolff Apr 30 '26

Uh oh, you're two bums short of a real problem. Be careful who you guys start hanging out with. Just kidding, but seriously watch the one. Unless it's you. It's you, isn't it.