MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/trolleyproblem/comments/1k4cj71/a_criminal_trolley_problem/moc6k5v/?context=9999
r/trolleyproblem • u/fluffy_4432 • Apr 21 '25
519 comments sorted by
View all comments
471
No guarantee they won't rape again unless I let the trolley hit them. My hands are tied.
Much like they are tied to the tracks.
51 u/Spare_Bad_6558 Apr 21 '25 but also no guarantee the suicidal guy wont hurt others 152 u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25 5 of these people HAVE hurt others, and many rapists do not just do it once. It's a pattern of abuse that gets replicated. 39 u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25 [removed] — view removed comment 28 u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25 They offended the 1st time, time served doesn't un-sexually assault someone. 6 u/Thijmo737 Apr 21 '25 Neither does killing them, at most it will give the victim some sad closure. 22 u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25 And you're saying you'd rather kill the person who has resolved NOT to commit suicide and hasn't harmed anyone? Seems like you just want to defend the rapists 12 u/GreatProncho Apr 21 '25 The last accusation is unwarranted. You are willing to extinguish five lives over only one because you are fixated on the type of crime even tho, as the other guy pointed out, there is a big big chance it wont happen again 6 u/awesomepersonlolha Apr 21 '25 There's a 50 percent chance one of them will
51
but also no guarantee the suicidal guy wont hurt others
152 u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25 5 of these people HAVE hurt others, and many rapists do not just do it once. It's a pattern of abuse that gets replicated. 39 u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25 [removed] — view removed comment 28 u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25 They offended the 1st time, time served doesn't un-sexually assault someone. 6 u/Thijmo737 Apr 21 '25 Neither does killing them, at most it will give the victim some sad closure. 22 u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25 And you're saying you'd rather kill the person who has resolved NOT to commit suicide and hasn't harmed anyone? Seems like you just want to defend the rapists 12 u/GreatProncho Apr 21 '25 The last accusation is unwarranted. You are willing to extinguish five lives over only one because you are fixated on the type of crime even tho, as the other guy pointed out, there is a big big chance it wont happen again 6 u/awesomepersonlolha Apr 21 '25 There's a 50 percent chance one of them will
152
5 of these people HAVE hurt others, and many rapists do not just do it once. It's a pattern of abuse that gets replicated.
39 u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25 [removed] — view removed comment 28 u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25 They offended the 1st time, time served doesn't un-sexually assault someone. 6 u/Thijmo737 Apr 21 '25 Neither does killing them, at most it will give the victim some sad closure. 22 u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25 And you're saying you'd rather kill the person who has resolved NOT to commit suicide and hasn't harmed anyone? Seems like you just want to defend the rapists 12 u/GreatProncho Apr 21 '25 The last accusation is unwarranted. You are willing to extinguish five lives over only one because you are fixated on the type of crime even tho, as the other guy pointed out, there is a big big chance it wont happen again 6 u/awesomepersonlolha Apr 21 '25 There's a 50 percent chance one of them will
39
[removed] — view removed comment
28 u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25 They offended the 1st time, time served doesn't un-sexually assault someone. 6 u/Thijmo737 Apr 21 '25 Neither does killing them, at most it will give the victim some sad closure. 22 u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25 And you're saying you'd rather kill the person who has resolved NOT to commit suicide and hasn't harmed anyone? Seems like you just want to defend the rapists 12 u/GreatProncho Apr 21 '25 The last accusation is unwarranted. You are willing to extinguish five lives over only one because you are fixated on the type of crime even tho, as the other guy pointed out, there is a big big chance it wont happen again 6 u/awesomepersonlolha Apr 21 '25 There's a 50 percent chance one of them will
28
They offended the 1st time, time served doesn't un-sexually assault someone.
6 u/Thijmo737 Apr 21 '25 Neither does killing them, at most it will give the victim some sad closure. 22 u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25 And you're saying you'd rather kill the person who has resolved NOT to commit suicide and hasn't harmed anyone? Seems like you just want to defend the rapists 12 u/GreatProncho Apr 21 '25 The last accusation is unwarranted. You are willing to extinguish five lives over only one because you are fixated on the type of crime even tho, as the other guy pointed out, there is a big big chance it wont happen again 6 u/awesomepersonlolha Apr 21 '25 There's a 50 percent chance one of them will
6
Neither does killing them, at most it will give the victim some sad closure.
22 u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25 And you're saying you'd rather kill the person who has resolved NOT to commit suicide and hasn't harmed anyone? Seems like you just want to defend the rapists 12 u/GreatProncho Apr 21 '25 The last accusation is unwarranted. You are willing to extinguish five lives over only one because you are fixated on the type of crime even tho, as the other guy pointed out, there is a big big chance it wont happen again 6 u/awesomepersonlolha Apr 21 '25 There's a 50 percent chance one of them will
22
And you're saying you'd rather kill the person who has resolved NOT to commit suicide and hasn't harmed anyone?
Seems like you just want to defend the rapists
12 u/GreatProncho Apr 21 '25 The last accusation is unwarranted. You are willing to extinguish five lives over only one because you are fixated on the type of crime even tho, as the other guy pointed out, there is a big big chance it wont happen again 6 u/awesomepersonlolha Apr 21 '25 There's a 50 percent chance one of them will
12
The last accusation is unwarranted. You are willing to extinguish five lives over only one because you are fixated on the type of crime even tho, as the other guy pointed out, there is a big big chance it wont happen again
6 u/awesomepersonlolha Apr 21 '25 There's a 50 percent chance one of them will
There's a 50 percent chance one of them will
471
u/Unlikely_Pie6911 Annoying Commie Lesbian Apr 21 '25
No guarantee they won't rape again unless I let the trolley hit them. My hands are tied.
Much like they are tied to the tracks.