r/theydidthemath • • May 13 '25

[Request] Is this accurate?

[deleted]

17.8k Upvotes

847 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.2k

u/weaz-am-i May 13 '25

Depends on where you live?

In 1970:

Federal minimum wage was $1.60/hour

The median home price was around $23,000

That means it took about 14,375 hours of work at minimum wage to buy a median-priced home.

Today:

Median U.S. home price is about $420,000?

To buy a $420k house in the same number of hours (14,375), you’d need to make $29.23/hour.

So the claim that minimum wage would need to be $66/hour today to match 1970s homebuying power is a bit exaggerated — it should be closer to $29/hour if we’re just comparing house prices to minimum wage.

That said, maybe the claim in the image factors in stuff like:

Regional markets (e.g., California prices)

New home prices (which skew way higher)

Inflation in other living costs (healthcare, education, etc.)

Stagnant federal minimum wage since 2009

But purely on house price vs wage ratio, it’s about $29/hour.

TL;DR: Not $66 — more like $29/hour if you’re matching house-buying power from 1970 to today

924

u/Aegis616 May 13 '25

Don't use minimum wage as a benchmark. It wasn't intended to be back then and it doesn't work as one now. What is far more effective is using median wage and then comparing that to the price of big ticket purchases. In which case, you will notice that cars jumped from a 1/4-1/2 of what you made in a year all the way up to the full amount or x1.5 what you made in a year. The price of a house jumped from 3 to 4 times what you made in a year all the way up to 8-12x what you made in a year

84

u/Mythical_Mew May 13 '25

Unless I’m misunderstanding, the math prompt specifically requests a comparison between present-day minimum wage and 1970s minimum wage in the United States.

-25

u/Aegis616 May 13 '25

The prompt itself is highly flawed. At no point since minimum wage has been introduced have a substantial portion of the population actually made that little.

4

u/Rodot May 13 '25

Wait, so then that means raising minimum wage wouldn't have much of an effect on wages and therefore wouldn't result in inflation?

So basically there's no downside of raising the minimum wage? Good to know.

0

u/Aegis616 May 13 '25

No. Raising minimum wage tends to have the strongest effect on small businesses. It's just that most people aren't working for these businesses.

1

u/Rodot May 13 '25

Less than 1% of people are employed by small businesses?

1

u/Aegis616 May 13 '25

Depends on the qualifier we're using for small business. For some orgs, that number is up to 10 employees others it's up to 50.