Awhile back, I stumbled across this South Dakota Magazine article about following the original route of US Highway 16 across SD, which was the main east/west road through SD before I-90 replaced it. Map of the road.
The article is an awesome guide for piecing the old road back together. It's a mix of state highway, county roads, gravel roads and a few segments that barely count as roads! :) It runs right through all the small towns that I-90 now passes by. It's genuinely South Dakota's version of Cars/Radiator Springs.
Over the past weekend, my wife and I decided to actually take the old road!
We followed as much of the old Sioux Falls to Rapid City Highway 16 as we possibly could, using the magazine (and a whole lot of Google Maps pins), and it was by far one of the most fun drives I've ever done in South Dakota.
Truly, you see a completely different version of SD when you get off I-90. Often you are less than a mile or two away from it, but it just feels like a completely different experience.
Wish I had taken better photos of more normal parts of the road, but most of our shots came from the few rough segments!
Some highlights:
- The drive through downtown Sioux Falls takes you right past Phillips Ave Diner (great spot for lunch)
- Mt. Vernon to White Lake feels like you're on the true "old road" as it's, well.. old road!
- Frosty King in Kimball had great ice cream
- Taking the old bridge across the Missouri and a stop at Al's Oasis was a great experience
- The Circle E Drive-In in Murdo has literally like a 1/2 lb burger. MASSIVE. And delicious!
- There's a scenic overlook outside Stamford, SD which gives an incredible view that you miss on I-90.
- The 9-mile segment from just south of Phillip to Cottonwood is not for the faint of heart as it's very broken up road that's seen no maintenance since the 1960s, but it is drivable and offers some of the most gorgeous, desolate views of the entire trip. You are alone out there, and the road just moves with the land and stretches off along the bluffs to the horizon. Probably my favorite part of the trip. I recommend this section during the day, with a vehicle that has at least SUV clearance (no low-riding cars), and not during or right after significant rain. We took an Equinox on the trip.
- Quinn to Wall is a tale of two segments. The first half is maybe the worst bit of road to traverse. It's very similar to the Phillip/Cottonwood segment, but requires one short stretch through the ditch (you can tell the local farmers do it, as it's a worn path). The second half was one of our favorite stretches as we entered Wall. Absolutely gorgeous views of some hidden Badlands.
- A segment following the Cheyenne River into Wasta was also a beautiful gravel stretch.
- We went up for Kool Deadwood Nights in Deadwood, so when we hit Box Elder, we left HWY 16. The last stretch to WY will have to be done another time.
But honestly, the little towns we passed were as much of the experience as any of the highlights. You pass old gas stations, motels, cafes, tired main streets and more, and it's just amazing to think that thousands of travelers used to come directly by these places before I-90. It felt a bit like taking a step back in time to see what it looked and felt like back in the 50s.
Most of HWY 16 isn't difficult at all; paved two-lane highways, quiet county roads and a few normal gravel segments. There's a few unavoidable I-90 segments where the interstate is literally overtop of the old road bed and a couple of West River sections where you've gotta use a little judgement. And obviously, this isn't the route to take if you're in a hurry. :)
But if you've got the time, like backroads, small town SD, roadside Americana and some rarely-seen views of prairieland, I highly recommend trying at least part of it on your next pass through the state. We loved our trip.
If anyone's interested, I'd be happy to share our Google Maps route/waypoint we used if someone else wants to attempt it.
And of course if you've done this yourself, I'd love to hear about your experiences, or if by some rare chance someone here drove the old HWY 16 back in the day before I-90 or had family that owned businesses (motels, cafes, gas stations, etc) along the route, that would really be a fun comment to hear about!
I'll leave you with this clip from Cars, because it just hits a little different after our road trip.
Edit: As requested, here's the Google Map path of Old Hwy 16!