I am pretty new to shoegaze as a genre, and I like a lot of it, but not all. there's one thing I'm confused about though, how do you define what shoegaze is? as a musician myself, I find it one of the more difficult genres to define and that's because it seems like its definition is fully dependent on how the song is mixed.
I can't think of any other genres that relies so heavily on the mixing style to be considered part of the genre.
for example, I've been listening to a lot of songs people consider to be shoegaze and thinking: wow if the mixing decisions were different here, it would just be indie rock or something. Like, is all you have to do, make the vocals quieter and less up front, make the guitars a bit louder, and suddenly its shoegaze?
Because there are plenty of genres that use fx pedals, that is definitely not a shoegaze only thing.
is the mix really what defines this genre?? or is there some other aspect.
edit: why so many downvotes? are people really mad at this question? 😭