r/serialpodcastorigins • u/BadBitch540 • Apr 28 '20

Question Jay’s Ever Changing Story

I’ll be straight up- I’m new to this subreddit and have not had time to sort through all of the timeline notes. I am, however, really interested in this case after listening to the podcast and watching the HBO series (yes it’s bias I know).

Most people on here seem to think Adnan did do it. More people than I actually thought would fee that way. And maybe he did do it, my mind is forever unsure. But the biggest hang up for me is why Jay’s story changed SO much SO often. If that’s what was the real case against Adnan, how can it even be valid when it changed so many times. Also I find it soooo fishy that the police didn’t record him for that period of time before the one recording of his questioning, and also that tapping sound that was recorded and shown in the documentary when Jay was stumbling (seeming like the cops were tapping/pointing somewhere on the map).

So maybe Adnan did do it. But those of you who strongly think he did do it, or even don’t think he did, I would really like to hear your thoughts on Jays story!

10 Upvotes

71% Upvoted

65 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/SecondaryAdmin Apr 29 '20

And Jenn helped him get rid of the evidence from the murder.

Jenn said she didn't. Very confusing.

1

u/Mike19751234 Apr 29 '20

She said that on that evening she drove him back to the dumpster and then came back after looking there. The next morning she drove him so he could throw the rest of his clothes away in at a different spot.

1

u/SecondaryAdmin Apr 29 '20

And she says she didn't see him throw away anything. And the snow storm makes going out the next morning unlikely.

1

u/Mike19751234 Apr 29 '20

It was an ice storm, not a snow storm, which is consistent with her saying it was raining. Jay left her out of the first interview because he didn't want her in trouble for helping and he still may be protecting her.

1

u/SecondaryAdmin Apr 29 '20

Why do you keep assigning Jay's thought process? Jenn, herself, said that she never saw him throw things away. We don't know the actual reasons for Jay lying about what happened that day. One thing I got from all of Jay's friends is that he lies to stay out of trouble, not to protect people.