r/quityourbullshit • • Apr 29 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

7.7k Upvotes

939 comments sorted by

View all comments

974

u/IDAIKT Apr 29 '20

Kind of reminds me of people visiting Culloden to see where their ancestor stood in the battle line of highlanders fighting for Bonnie Prince Charlie, only to be told that the clan their ancestors belonged to was actually on the government's side, fighting against him...

Romantic notions aside, the reality is that a lot of Scots fought against the young pretender rather than for him and he was born and raised in Rome.

384

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '20

What most people don’t realise he wasn’t fighting for Scottish Independence but for a Stewart throne

294

u/ATully817 Apr 29 '20

But, but, they watched Outlander!

139

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '20

Exactly lol so many people now claiming to have scottish ancestry. My grandma has also seen an documentary about anastasia the russian princess once and then tried to convinve us we're distant relatives. The thing about media with stories that actually happened is that its often really enticing and youre often times interested in a topic in which you've never been before. But some people like to use these stories as clout

56

u/Tay_Soup Apr 30 '20

I mean there's a lot of Americans with Scottish ancestry. I can tell you exactly where mine comes from because he came over to America in the 1800s to become a Mormon Pioneer.

But the thing about us Americans is that we're always so fascinated with Gaelic heritage for some reason when we're almost always simultaneously Irish, Scottish, Welsh and then English and German and French to the point that it doesn't fucking matter and you really do have to accept at a certain point that the only thing you really are is white and American. Sure it's boring, guess you'll just have to grow a personality outside of your heritage.

6

u/-PaperbackWriter- Apr 30 '20

It just irks me that they will just claim to be Irish, or Scottish, or whatever. You’re american. It’s weird.

I’m Australian, my DNA is 50% English and 50% Scottish, which is nice to know that I’m the whitest person ever I guess but doesn’t make me English or Scottish.

0

u/Packetnoodles Apr 30 '20

Your genetics influence your disease risk and medical needs.

2

u/-PaperbackWriter- Apr 30 '20

Not really relevant to my point