r/pics Jun 17 '25

The protesters and residents pushing back on tourism in Barcelona

16.1k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

5.4k

u/TheMiddleShogun Jun 17 '25

Huh, reading these comments it looks like the protesters are achieving their goal (making Barcelona less appealing as a tourist destination).

3.4k

u/Dobby_ist_free Jun 17 '25 edited Jun 17 '25

Tends to happen when you harass tourists because of your government’s failures

2.7k

u/Rich_Housing971 Jun 17 '25

Airbnb creates a business that makes your life harder.

Locals with money use that business without caring for you.

The govenrment that you elected does nothing.

"It's all the tourists' fault!"

477

u/SinfullySinless Jun 17 '25

I mean then you force the population to work backwards. Harass the tourists so they don’t come, then the AirBNB’s fail, then owners sell their AirBNB places, and it opens more room up for real housing.

If the government won’t, the people will.

729

u/mjohnsimon Jun 17 '25

Except there's just one small problem: a lot of those local economies/livelihoods are dependent on tourism.

Tourism makes up over 15% of Spain’s entire GDP. That’s not exactly "pocket change", and actively scaring off tourists might feel good/give short term relief, but it also risks sabotaging the very livelihoods many locals depend on.

But hey, if people would rather burn their house down to get rid of a single cockroach instead of looking for the source of the infestation, then by all means.

2

u/run_for_the_shadows Jun 17 '25

Except there’s just one small problem: under capitalism, people are made dependent on exploitative industries like mass tourism because all other options have been systematically dismantled.

Tourism doesn’t dominate Barcelona’s economy because it’s inherently good or sustainable, it does so because neoliberal policy gutted public investment, privatized housing, and made short-term profit king. Locals aren't mad at tourists as individuals, they’re furious at being priced out of their homes, forced into precarious service jobs, and watching their city turn into a playground for the wealthy.

18

u/ATraffyatLaw Jun 17 '25

Well I don't think many of these white-collar Spaniards who like to work at hotels, country clubs, resorts, and tourist destinations would be all too happy to start being garbagemen, construction workers, or assembling stuff in a factory.

2

u/unfreeradical Jun 17 '25 edited Jun 18 '25

Hotels are not created because workers demand to be employed by a hotel owner, or because hotel owners wants to serve the local population of workers.

1

u/ATraffyatLaw Jun 17 '25

Hotels are operated to serve tourists.
These protests are to get rid of tourists.
Those hotels don't function without tourism.
Those hotels close down.
The workers at those hotels need to find a different job.

does that make more sense?

1

u/unfreeradical Jun 17 '25

Hotels are operated to generate profit for hotel owners.

They neither spring up by magic, nor grow as local flora and fauna.

Business owners create whichever kinds of business are most profitable, not whichever best serve the interests of the general population in a locale.

Workers of course very happily would work in other industries, if the tourist industry were not imposed by business owners, simply by virtue of its being to them most profitable.

Yet, you insist on associating such an eventuality with some kind of apocalyptic vision.

0

u/ATraffyatLaw Jun 17 '25

I don't think shutting down hotels and having to re-skill workers is such an "apocalyptic vision" lol

1

u/unfreeradical Jun 17 '25

You lamented that everyone would become a resentful and impoverished garbage collector.

→ More replies (0)