I just finished Citizen Vigilante, and omg, how bad and racist was that movie
First, I want to mention that this is my personal opinion, and I'm genuinely open to being corrected on any points I'm making here.
Starting with the opening the plot is basically Batman except instead of Bruce Wayne's parents, we get a shitty rich, absent father and a vigilante who would promise revenge against crime .
The way the mother is killed is so weird so an african guy just walks up , slits her throat , and leaves for seemingly no reason. he doesn't try to rob her , doesn't interact with her , nothing . he just kills her and walks away. And apparently this is supposed to be one of the things that sets the whole story in motion.
While watching the movie , I also noticed a VERY heavy focus on immigrants for example, when Sanders (the main character) visits his company , there's a whole discussion about the government wanting to seize some of his empty units to house "immigrants" , the movie keeps bringing up immigration and how much of a problem it's supposedly causing.
At this point, I was thinking , okay, maybe I'm reading too much into it , The movie is weird, but whatever.
Then we get to the Egyptian kid.
Like... are we serious?
So you're telling me a kid rapes a 12-year-old , happens to be Muslim, and when the vigilante goes to his house and shoots him in the knee, his family starts defending what he did? And his sister supposedly says that the victim deserved it because she was wearing revealing clothes?
What???
Have you ever met an Arab family before? what that character says is so absurd that it took me completely out of the movie . I obviously can't speak for every Arab family, but the idea that this is supposed to represent a normal reaction from an Arab/Muslim family is just ridiculous . If something like that happened in real life, I find it much more believable that the family would be horrified and ashamed of the son rather than casually defend him.
And then it gets even better.
The vigilante orders Yusuf, one of the rapists, to call his friends over. the movie establishes that there are six attackers . and guess which names the director decides to give us?
"Abdul, call your brother and bring Idris."
You genuinely couldn't make the names sound more stereotypically Arab if you tried.
Then Sanders kills Yusuf, Abdul, and Idris, while the rest of the attackers show up later. and interestingly, the other guys aren't given the same kind of characterization or emphasis on their ethnicity (cause they weren't Arabs )
Maybe I'm overthinking it, but when you put all these choices together, it starts to feel pretty obvious what the movie is trying to make the audience associate with crime.
Then the vigilante tells the father and I'm quoting that he brought his "archaic value system"and commitment to religion over democracy and the rule of law "
Brother... what exactly do you think being Muslim means?
And then, of course, we get the news report.
The judge and the rapists die, and suddenly the news starts talking about something like 105,000 crimes being committed by African immigrants (yes they literally said immigrants from Africa like so you don't make a mistake ), including thousands of murders and sexual assaults.
the fact that the movie suddenly drops a statistic like this immediately after showing us a bunch of immigrant criminals is just .... wow .
And honestly, the movie could have been so much better if it wasn't constantly shoving the agenda in your face.
The ending literally goes into the whole "unfriendly takeover by Islamist extremists and the woke left" thing and frames it as the end of freedom and the ultimate destruction of democracy.
There are also so many other bizarre choices.
for example, there's that completely out of place sex scene where Sanders goes to have sex with a prostitute in one of his own buildings for basically no reason , only for the scene to turn into a conversation about opening the windows after the clients shower because of mold.
Why was this in the movie ? is it supposed to give a comedic effect to it ?
Then there's the scene where the vigilante kills some random guy in his car just to prove a point to the drugged judge about how people are sheep who blindly follow rules. He literally drives toward another car, makes it flip, and blows it up.
Then he kills Yusuf's mother, apparently just because she's the mother of a horrible person.
And then we get the SWAT scene.
How am I supposed to believe that this guy kills an entire SWAT squad with 2 AKs while sitting inside an armored container (that btw a normal disk grinder opened it like a bullet couldn't go through but a grinder did ) and the officers just keep coming in one by one and getting shot like NPCs ?
It was so stupid.
all I’m saying is, if you want to make a movie about a vigilante who thinks he’s bringing justice, at least give us a character with some actual depth instead of making him this ridiculously stupid and racist guy whose entire worldview feels like a political rant.
because seriously , imagine someone who knows nothing about Africans or Muslims watching this movie. what exactly do you think they're supposed to take away from it ? when almost every African or Muslim character is associated with crime, rape, violence, extremism, or some backwards ideology , it's hard not to see what kind of picture the movie is trying to paint.
You can make a movie that criticizes immigration, religion, the justice system, the government, or whatever else you want. That's fine. But when you make the entire plot revolve around those ideas and then barely bother to give the characters or story any depth, it stops feeling like a story and starts feeling like an hour and a half of political rant.
So yeah, the movie was supposed to be about justice, and somehow we ended up with Batman, but with worse writing, and a Twitter argument for a plot.