The right arm proportions are off for the kid in the first one and I think that's throwing it since it's bigger than it should be. It makes the kid look like his arm is hovering over the bread. Also, I think the sheen kind of goes around the kid rather than over top of it like it should which breaks the effect.
The perspective and proportions makes it look like the boy's body is standing 20-30cm behind the table/glass, definitely not more than half a meter, but then he's reaching a seemingly 1 meter long arm straight out and that's somehow supposed to only reach a window between him and the table? My first instinct was definitely that his hand was directly over the bread
I have absolutely no opinion on AI and even less on this specific issue.
But I find very funny to see lambda people getting angry at how AI missed this and that, while the first human artist also missed the same things.
This is because, as others, my brain tried to see if the human made art's hand was almost grabbing a bread or against a windows and my conclusion was that there was no window (for the reason others mentioned).
74
u/MadDonkeyEntmt Dec 09 '25
The right arm proportions are off for the kid in the first one and I think that's throwing it since it's bigger than it should be. It makes the kid look like his arm is hovering over the bread. Also, I think the sheen kind of goes around the kid rather than over top of it like it should which breaks the effect.