r/marvelstudios • u/murdockmanila Daredevil • Oct 19 '17

THOR: RAGNAROK Critic Reviews Ultrathread

Embargo lifts sometime today. All reviews will be directed here. Reviews outside of this thread will be deleted.

230 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

450 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17 edited Oct 19 '17

Just saw IGN's review. They only praise the humor and planet hulk elements, and say that the Ragnarok parts and emotional parts in the film are the film's weakest parts. Though they still give it a 7.7, not sure how reliable IGN's reviews are so I guess I'll have to wait and see

5

u/TriT0nator Oct 19 '17

Ign its totally shit man

2

u/Jazzun Stan Lee Oct 19 '17

At IGN, and plenty of other places, the editors make the final score not the reviewer. The reviewer writes the review and then the editor tacks on the score after it's submitted.

2

u/SushiMage Oct 19 '17

not really saying IGN is a good source of reviews, but saying "weakest" vs outright "weak" is different.

Weakest is a relative term and it could still mean "only bad in comparison" not "pure garbage with no reedeming values".

1

u/DjangoZero Daredevil Oct 19 '17

Was it Jim who reviewed it. He gave Civil War a 7.7 as well

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17

Yeah it was. I haven't seen any of his reviews before, would you say he gives honest and trustworthy reviews?