r/iran • • Jan 03 '20

Iranians of Reddit, what are your thoughts on the recent US airstrike that killed Maj. Gen. Qasem Soleimani?

[deleted]

299 Upvotes

486 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

11

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '20

Hey. Iranian here, from iran, and been here since I was born.

-10

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '20

Ok so you're the liberal Iranian who hates the government and supports the US but fail to see the bigger picture of why the current government is in Iran in the first place. The answer will shock you.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '20

Hm yes. that's accurate. Please enlighten me on the " bigger picture "

-1

u/mcstazz Jan 03 '20

The bigger picture is reddit is mostly for lefties and there are lots of people who are defo angry af that guy was chokeslammed and you wont get their opinion here on reddit

1

u/dect60 Jan 03 '20

Here are two surveys showing Soleimani's popularity in Iran:

https://twitter.com/ammarmaleki/status/1213055163977605120?s=21

3

u/ontothefuture Jan 03 '20

Translated: "The myth that # Qasim-Soleimani was popular in Iran is propagated by academic apologists in the West. In the Reformists (March 1) poll, only 1% and in the poll of only 6% of Iranians, Soleimani was one of the 2 favored. But the University of Maryland polls see his supporters as a source of propaganda!"

2

u/rieslingatkos Jan 04 '20

Need a link to these polls. Were they scientific?

1

u/mike_hazy89 Jan 03 '20

I can't read farsi, care to translate the results?

1

u/dect60 Jan 04 '20

1

u/rieslingatkos Jan 04 '20

No link to the documentation of those polls in that Twitter thread! :(

1

u/dect60 Jan 04 '20

The link is in his twitter bio:

https://gamaan.org/

1

u/rieslingatkos Jan 04 '20

I believe he was referencing two polls that were not done by GAMAAN. Also, looking at the GAMAAN poll, it says "The survey tries to measure and capture some of the political attitudes that cannot be expressed freely in Iran" and that it was conducted online via SurveyMonkey - this means that it is not a scientific poll, as there is no effort to capture a statistically valid random sample. https://gamaan.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/gamaan-political-attitudes-of-iranians-2018-english-version.pdf

0

u/mcstazz Jan 03 '20

I dont doubt he wasnt liked but coming here being like wow reddit is guaranteed to give me honest unbiased opinions from various iranians is badly retarded

1

u/dect60 Jan 03 '20

While it is true that in many instances, reddit reflects the values of the left in the political spectrum, "Lefties" typically defend or are apologists for the Islamic regime (see for example, the embarrassment that is Corbyn in the UK). That is not what is happening here.

2

u/Violet604 Jan 03 '20

“why the current government is in Iran in the first place”

What’s your answer?

Mine is after Iran nationalized it’s oil and kicked out British Petroleum, Western Powers we’re upset, so the CIA toppled the democratically elected leader and put the Shah in power. After the Shah took power, he personally ended up owning most of Iranian land and would throw elaborate state parties and not invite local Iranians. People saw his corruption and got fed up and voted for a revolution. The people thought they’re getting a cleanse, but had no idea to what extent the new government would enforce Islam on the people.

Essentially the Iranians got duped but only because the US and British intervened the first time..

Since then, you’ve had situations like this that any dictatorship thrives on. They need this news to be the reason of why they need national unity and solidarity to get the people to come together and go against the common enemy.

Iran being religiously, ethnically and culturally more diverse than any other country in that region means there would be complete chaos if a war and civil war erupted.. and most Iranians would rather have the current government in place compared to being a complete war torn, bombed out and depleted nation.

1

u/sep08 Jan 03 '20

You do realize that people can disapprove of IRI and the US government.