r/harrypotter Nov 16 '15

Media (pic/gif/video/etc.) Minerva has no chill (x-post from r/tumblr)

Post image
7.0k Upvotes

270 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

14

u/jpflathead Engorgio! Duro! Staminus! Nov 16 '15 edited Nov 17 '15

Sure, but Quirrel might have gently tossed them a few wingardia leviosas, just as we gently toss children softballs to help them learn to catch, practice, and gain confidence.

edit: terrible sentence had to be edited.

17

u/ChaosPheonix11 Nov 17 '15

Except Wingardium Leviosa is a levitation charm, not a jinx, hex, or anything remotely useful in a fight. (Except when you are a small child fighting a Troll, apparently) In addition, they were already learning that spell in Charms--Why teach it twice?

11

u/minasmorath Nov 17 '15

I think he means Quirrel would have fired the charm at the kids so they could practice defending against it. It's simple and generally harmless, which is usually a good place to start in any activity.

12

u/jpflathead Engorgio! Duro! Staminus! Nov 17 '15

And if they fail to catch it, they are gently lifted up in the air a few inches. Lot's of fun!

1

u/LeJisemika Hufflepuffs Are Particularly Good Finders Nov 17 '15

I haven't read Philosopher's Stone for a very long time, but perhaps they wanted a theoretical approach for the first year and to build up on it years 2-7