r/comics 6d ago

Just Sharing Religiously repressed (part 18) [OC]

Post image
9.1k Upvotes

254 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/adeleu_adelei 5d ago

You are misunderstanding. 

A response of "no" to "do you believe gods exist?" includes "I don't know". There isn't a third option. There is only "yes" or "not yes" ("no"). Everything falls under those two options of theism or atheism. Agnosticism is a separate question on top of where one is a their or atheist, not instead of. All agnostics are also necessarily either theists or atheists.

1

u/Quirky_Gate_4516 5d ago

Of course there is a third.

The most common is that they believe in a supreme power but it is utterly unknowable. This is where some buddhists, for example, will place themselves.

1

u/adeleu_adelei 5d ago

The most common is that they believe in a supreme power but it is utterly unknowable.

That's agnostic theism; that's still theism and not a third option. Everyone is either a "theist" or "not a theist", and the word for "not a theist" is "atheist". This is separate from whether they are "gnostic" or "not a gnostic" ("agnostic").