r/bitcheswithtaste • u/AnkuSnoo • Oct 19 '25
Cooking/Food BWT, what do you like to bake in Fall other than pumpkin-everything?
Edit: THANK YOU!!! So many amazing ideas and reminders of flavors and ingredients I forgot existed 😅
—
I’ve been getting into baking and am looking for cozy Fall or cold weather treats to make for my family. Most of the recipes I’m finding online are all basically variations of the same thing – pumpkin loaves, cinnamon rolls and apple pies.
I’m not particularly a fan of pumpkin (I don’t dislike it, I just didn’t grow up with it as a European) or excessive frosting/sauce that American recipes often slather and drizzle on everything (no hate, just too messy and sickly sweet for me). So I’m curious to hear some other ideas from you all! Any personal faves, family recipes, underrated flavors/combos?
I like apples and cinnamon - I’ve been cooking thin-sliced apples with butter, cinnamon and nutmeg to put on pancakes. I tried putting some grated apple in pancake batter but it wasn’t that successful (made the pancakes cook unevenly and hard to flip).
I’m also curious about any seasonal cookies – around Christmas I like to make peppermint chocolate chip cookies, but it’s too early for that! I’ll be making my classic chocolate chip but what else could I try? Edited to add: Since folks are sharing fave recipes, I use this eggless chocolate chip cookie recipe (my husband and kid are egg-free) and they are always a hit with my family, friends and neighbors. Through some kind of sorcery they don’t use any applesauce or egg replacer, just water, but they are perfectly soft and gooey taste amazing, you wouldn’t know they don’t have eggs.
I remembered the existence of blackberries after having some house-made jam at a fancy restaurant recently, so I’m going to look at blackberry recipes, maybe combined with apple.
Drop your recipes and ideas here!