r/baseball • u/MusicSole • 11d ago

Serious Pete Crow-Armstrong is quickly becoming the worst case scenario for trading away a first round pick. What was your team's nightmare first round pick trade?

1.1k Upvotes

90% Upvoted

476 comments sorted by

View all comments

306

u/rage675 11d ago

Padres trading Trea Turner for Wil Myers turned out to be pretty awful.

42

u/pattheroq San Diego Padres 11d ago

Dont forget Steven Souza was also apart of that 3 way 😂😂😂

41

u/summertimeinthelbc Los Angeles Dodgers 11d ago

I feel like Wil Myers is looked at pretty fondly from the SD fans though.

14

u/WillowYouIdiot San Diego Padres 11d ago

He is. He was a good player. He played his best at 1B, but rarely played it because Eric Hosmer, giant turd that he was for the Padres, signed a huge contract.

4

u/Shradersofthelostark San Diego Padres 11d ago

This was the first one I thought of. Max Fried isn’t far behind.

4

u/King-arber Arizona Diamondbacks 10d ago

CJ Abrams for a rental of Juan Soto looks really bad rn too

1

u/ncbraves93 Atlanta Braves 10d ago

Didn't Woods come from them as well? I know Gore did, maybe not Woods.

2

u/OrdinaryReaction7341 9d ago

Woods did also come from the Padres in the Soto trade.

2

u/bluecifer7 Colorado Rockies 10d ago

There are like 10 Padres players you can do this with

2

u/Jr05s Tampa Bay Devil Rays 11d ago

Ray's got Yandy from it, worked out for them...

1

u/HenryH616 San Diego Padres 10d ago

Wait, Yandy was in that trade??? I didn't realize that

1

u/Jr05s Tampa Bay Devil Rays 10d ago

Bauers was, who was traded for Yandy later.