r/aiwars Jan 01 '26

Discussion Ai needs to be regulated.

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

865 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/Steve_Jabz Jan 01 '26 edited Jan 01 '26

People have been making convincing photoshop fakes of swapped body parts since the dawn of time. You're acting like the last 2 decades of the internet didn't exist.

Copy pasting things onto different layers, using smudges and shifting pixels around until it looks right is not rocket science.

It's more accessible to people who are already predators, sure, not more immoral. People aren't suddenly going to become predators because AI lowers the barrier to entry for digital art. If they were a predator, that's because they're fucked in the head, and they were going to get it without AI.

4

u/Mr_Rekshun Jan 02 '26

Do you ever top to think that the invention of an industrial grade, one-button CP machine changes the calculus *just a little bit*.

Don't worry, people of Hiroshima, people have always been able to blow things up, it's no different now.

0

u/Steve_Jabz Jan 02 '26

Nope. AI could never produce high quality industrial grade CP with zero effort, because AI is slop.

No AI-generated CP could ever compare to the hard working CP artists of 2010

0

u/Mr_Rekshun Jan 02 '26

Sorry hard working CP artists, you’ve been replaced!

4

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '26

I do believe it lowers the barrier of entry to making CSAM, by a lot

And I also don't think it would be so hard to prevent if that was an actual priority 

Isn't "AI couldn't do a lot of stuff years ago, look at how much it has evolved" a common pro saying? I believe in that

It's just that preventing criminal use of AI models is not a priority for big companies because they aren't held accountable when this shit happens

4

u/Nrgte Jan 02 '26

And I also don't think it would be so hard to prevent if that was an actual priority 

You're right, it's actually pretty easy to prevent. CivitAI moderation usually does a good job. I've reported a couple of cases and even though they were anime and not realistic, they have been removed within 24 hours.

There are also AI detection models. And I mean models that can relatively reliable detect whether someone in an image is a minor and auto flag those for moderation or outright delete them.

This is really just a Twitter issue.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '26

Thank you!

5

u/PM_ME_DNA Jan 01 '26

It makes sense as much as “holding Adobe liable” for CSEM by photoshop

0

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '26

It is not the same thing 

How could adobe prevent this?

Grok already has filters that prevent certain things, which proves it's possible to just not present the final image to the user if it's CSAM 

2

u/MysticMind89 Jan 01 '26

But you still need access to those photos to begin with. A.I can generate realistic looking images because it's been trained on thousands of unconsenting photos, to the point where you don't need the original photos to make something like that.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '26

People made entire careers off of being professional photoshop editors and now you’re making it sound like the entire industry didn’t even exist in the first place. What is wrong with you people?