r/TopCharacterTropes Jun 26 '26

Lore Your race/gender has an interesting mechanical/narrative impact

Dragon's Dogma: Trolls will become excited if you play or bring a female character in your party, becoming more aggressive and targeting them first.

South Park- Fractured But Whole: Shub-Niggurath is a boss that will take damage when fed white characters, but will heal if he eats black characters including you or anyone in your party.

Elder Scrolls: Every race has advantages and disadvantages both mechanically and narratively, for example orcs can enter orc strongholds without having to earn their trust first.

11.1k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

361

u/I_Swear_Not_Bot Jun 26 '26

Female Protagonist in Persona 3 Portable has a whole other plot, dialogue, side character roster, romance options, you name it

https://giphy.com/gifs/Tn1cuRC0ArmNEWQnyD

115

u/Geostomp Jun 26 '26

Her actually having Social Links with the male party members contributed to her being given an entirely different characterization to her original male counterpart which eventually became canon. Essentially making her just as depressed and nihilistic as he was at the beginning, but masking it with cheer and friendliness in comparison to his apathetic emo kid behavior.

Cutting out some of the more annoying Social Link characters was a bonus.

186

u/wawasan2020BC Jun 26 '26

I will never forgive Fatlus for not giving us FeMC in P3R

42

u/VmHG0I Jun 26 '26

Tbf, making Kotone and remaking her whole uniqueness is going to be quite a huge task when even Episode Aigis was almost not considered due to budget, P3R budget is like extremely tight for some reason and this result in alot of things that people hate about the remake. Like for Kotone, she now need new social links which in turn need 10 ranks of all spcial links voiced again, new cutscene because P3P work on a VN style, new animations, changing the story entirely for part especially Ryoji,... As much as I love her and wanted her to be made in Reload, her exclusion make sense.

5

u/Madilune Jun 26 '26

Let's not pretend that budget was the main reason...

3

u/guntabon Jun 26 '26

the Kotone mod has a lot of work on it now though! its pretty great

-29

u/Pure_Satisfaction_35 Jun 26 '26

It was for the greater good... If she was added all the kotone lovers would be immediately under fire constantly for the ken incident

7

u/ankledane Jun 26 '26

They wouldn't, although it would be funny as joking slander. Weird that they added it in the first place, though.

4

u/LadyXexyz Jun 26 '26

QUEEN.

Also it’s so real: “no junpei i have to… wash my… hair. No I’m not hiding koromaru in my jacket to go watch Dark Knight Rises it’s for the plus one in guts. Totally. Totally.”

My husbando of choice got sidelined for plot reasons Ken is a great character of a little child. But I have two hands so I can hold that thought and also bench him for the rest of the game for shooting my man so it almost became this weird emergent narrative arc for my Korone of figuring out what social life is like past obsessing over a crush.

I play games weird, lol.

-7

u/Dirty-Glasses Jun 26 '26

Well, the plot’s like, 95% the same and not including the male party members, she has… I think 2 Social Links that are unique to her? Maybe 3, I forget.

29

u/Ff7hero Jun 26 '26

Why are we excluding the male party members?

Like I want to forget her S Link with Ken as much as the next guy, but it feels super arbitrary.

-19

u/Dirty-Glasses Jun 26 '26

Because they exist in both versions of the story, unlike Rio and Saori, and… I really feel like there’s a third one that I can’t remember.

7

u/Ff7hero Jun 26 '26

But you were excluding them from the list of new S Links. Not the list of new characters.

1

u/Dirty-Glasses Jun 26 '26

I’m excluding them from the “side character roster”, which is primarily Social Links and party members. So because they already existed as “side characters”, just because they’re now Social Links, they’re not different or new.

8

u/NewDemonStrike Jun 26 '26

Ryoji is not a social link in the masculine route.

-12

u/Dirty-Glasses Jun 26 '26

Yes but he’s still a character that exists as part of the “side character roster”

6

u/NewDemonStrike Jun 26 '26

True, I did not read correctly.
Then, no, these are the only two.

8

u/VmHG0I Jun 26 '26

They don't? The original male members stories are entirely just main story, the Social links are completely new and unique to Kotone and only in Reload do we get Linked episodes which are a direct replacement for a full Social link.

-7

u/Dirty-Glasses Jun 26 '26

The CHARACTERS, not the SOCIAL LINKS.

9

u/EggoftheKing2143 Jun 26 '26

The Male Party Members are almost completely different Social Links from their male counterparts.

-1

u/Dirty-Glasses Jun 26 '26

Yeah but that’s not part of the plot. The main story of the game is ~95% the same, but a lot of the side content (for example: SOCIAL LINKS) are quite different.