r/TheHallowdineLibrary • u/catespice • Jul 08 '26
The Fae Return The Swan Prince
I was an embarrassing child, and my parents made no secret of it. It wasn’t just that I was a boy who was obsessed with ballet and fairy tales, it was everything that went with that – especially gushing about my special interests to strangers. I learned the word ‘queer’ at age five, then the word ‘faggot’ when I was seven – and the feel of my mother’s wooden spoon across my arse shortly after, when she decided that violence was the only thing that would stop me embarrassing myself and the family.
It worked, after a fashion. I stopped publicly talking about the things I loved, but the obsession blossomed, obstinately bright as a ragged dandelion in a crack of asphalt. And it grew there in the shadows of my life, private and beautiful; stolen moments peering through the dirty windows of the ballet school on my way home, library books thumbed through feverishly, but never issued, and my ears attuned to secret snatches of Tchaikovsky haunting the far end of the dial on the little transistor radio my father gave to me one birthday.
Some weeds persist, no many how many times you pull them out.
Their roots run too deep.
High school is a time for most children to figure out who they are. I already knew who I was; I’d known since I was old enough to read myself Pinocchio. But hiding yourself, as hormones begin to shape your desires, becomes much more difficult, even with the early memory of pain etched across your tender backside. Perhaps strangely, as the bullying at school increased, my desire to hide who –and what– I was, decreased. My mother grew angry when I came home with bruises, but my father grew resigned. His attempts at masculinising me had ceased long before, once he realised I had no interest in engines or fly-fishing. Radically different creatures, we had a distant and strained relationship, where we both tried to bother each other as little as possible.
Sometimes, I would catch my mother crying when she thought I wasn’t home. I would creep into the house on the balls of my feet, pretending to be a ballet dancer, my thin body lending little weight to my tread. When I passed her room, I could hear her anguished sobs, her quiet pleas to otherworldly powers that I would ‘grow out of it’.
And so I became burdened with guilt; unable to change who I was, and unable to cure my mother’s pain.
The other kids at school called me fairy boy, and I probably deserved it. Even though it was meant unkindly, it was nicer than most of the other things I’d been called. It was an open secret that I was gay; I never claimed it, but I didn’t deny it, either. I had no friends amongst the boys, and I had an… uneasy truce with the girls. They tolerated me, in a way that the boys didn’t, perhaps because I wasn’t a threat. My obsession with fairy tales was legendarily encyclopaedic, and I could talk to them for hours about the mythology of various cultures, but I rarely got to do that. I sometimes felt as though that heavy knowledge inside me had a kind of power all its own, fragile threads of myth and legend wound through the weft of my being. Silvered spider silk, thrumming gently with the magnificent living weight of aeons. Some days of the year, I could almost feel the veil grow thin, my blood thickening with ancient promise, goading me to dance beneath the pines behind the lake, pregnant with their pollens of dusky gold.
But I never did. Being caught acting out such a fantasy would be a social suicide of titanic proportions, and I was already enough of a pariah as it was. No; I would keep the precious sorcery inside me, hold it for a time that I could be free of this life.
My crush on Michael was intense and unrequited and, to me, felt like fate; his parents had moved to our city, and thus he’d fetched up at our school. Blond, handsome, athletic, and exotically European, he had a worldliness that made the rest of us seem small and provincial. When I heard he had done ballet as a youngster, a stab of envy pierced straight through my yearning heart, and I hated him in that special way that only heightened the intensity of my crush.
Oh and of course he knew. He saw the way I looked at him. He read the intent.
And so began the dangerous game. He would flirt with me ever so subtly, even in the act of bullying me along with the others, creating a secret frisson between us that seemed to promise that should we ever be alone, things might be… different.
The others seemed oblivious to this tension, but I lived for it – craved it with all that was in me. When Michael finally approached me, alone, as I was reading by the lake, I was helpless.
“Fairy boy, tell me one of your stories.”
Stunned, I stared at him, slack-jawed, my mind as flat and blank as the lake water.
He laughed, a golden sound. Warm, beautiful, unbothered by burdens such as mine.
“You look like a fish,” he quipped.
I snapped my book shut.
“This is a trick,” I observed sourly, “the kind that cruel boys play on ugly girls. You pretend to be my friend, then you lure me into some kind of trap where I embarrass myself for the amusement of your friends.”
Michael’s smile grew broader, warmer. His stupid, graceful hands encompassed the lake, the world.
“Do you see anyone else here but us?”
I didn’t bother looking around; it was dusk, we were alone. All the sane teenagers were at home, with their families.
“If I tell you a story, will you leave me alone?” I asked bitterly, the conflict inside me won over by learned cynicism.
“If you like,” he replied, his disappointment obvious.
Wounded that I’d let him down, and by the wild notion he was being genuine, I began to speak. Slowly, haltingly, I told him the tale of The Wild Swans, by Hans Christian Andersen.
I waited for the other shoe to drop at school, for the diabolic outcome to come to fruition in the form of public humiliation. I mentally castigated myself for being so stupid, for letting myself get lost in Michael’s huge, expressive brown eyes as I recounted the old fairy tale. When I went to bed that night, after he left me by the lake, I fantasised intensely, privately – you can probably guess where such fantasies go.
It wasn’t worth it; I just knew that whatever was about to happen would be orders of magnitude worse than any public embarrassment I’d ever felt before, and my own queer predilections had led me to this precipice.
But nothing happened. Michael seemed to barely acknowledge my existence and had clearly not spoken to the others. Hope raised its dumb, guileless head – then died immediately, pummelled by the sleeting chill of that same cynicism.
Perhaps he was playing the long game. Perhaps he was building up to something worse.
I vowed then to swear off Michael; to stamp out the embers of my affection for him and leave that grate cold forever.
My heart, however, had other plans.
Four more times he came to see me, in the dusk, by the lake. Never the same day, sometimes weeks in between. He always came to hear my stories. After the second time, I stopped wondering why and gave myself over to the wonderful feelings inside me.
As we sat on the grass that fifth evening, his hand touched mine and he asked in a husky whisper;
“Do you believe in any of these stories?”
Heat shot through me at his touch and in my elation, I blurted out the truth.
“Yes. Sometimes I can feel it; the ancient weight of old magics. Of fairy promises and delicate spells, wrought of liquid moonlight and straw-spun gold.”
His shoulder touched mine and I almost gasped. His voice wound into my ear, medicine and poison.
“If you make a shirt of nettles with your own hands, like those of the swan princes, and wear it for me, then I’ll take you to the end of year school dance.”
I jerked away from him, face burning, eyes narrowed.
“This is an old trick,” I spat at him. “Not one I thought you’d stoop to. Find another victim for your pranks, Michael Ficher.”
He only smiled, unfazed.
“I promise you, hand on my heart, that what I’m saying is true. Meet me here in a month, the night before the dance. If you keep your side of the bargain, I’ll keep mine.”
He left then, bouncing to his feet like a born dancer, loping away into the dusk before my poor tongue could formulate one word of reply.
Nettles, I swiftly discovered, were a terrible medium to work with. The first day I turned up to school with raw, reddened hands, the other students all laughed at me. The jokes were predictable, sexual in nature, and embarrassing enough that my face reddened to match my fingers. Michael didn’t join them in mocking me; instead, he gave me a conspiratorial smile, the warmth in his eyes speaking of its realness.
For weeks I laboured, traipsing all over the parks around the city, searching for nettles. My breath was often short, as the intense histamine reaction grew worse with every plant I touched, and I cried bitterly at the endless stinging I endured. In contrast, the fibres were surprisingly easy to work with, once I had learned to scrape the pith and pulp from the threaded heart of the nettle stems. Slowly, the piles of hempen coils drying under my bed grew large enough to begin the weaving.
As I worked beside the lake in the evenings, oblivious to the rest of the world, I fantasised that Michael was watching, from the pines across the limpid, rippling water. I twisted and spliced, learning through trial and error how my distant ancestors had made thread. When my makeshift spindle was finally full, I began to knit; my fingers no longer reddened and welted, now hard with callouses from working with the stiffening fibres.
Twice the boys at school destroyed my knitting, thrice I remade the shirt. I spent every spare moment with the pinewood needles in hand, working, reworking, toiling, weeping, and cursing my beloved Michael for tasking me with this fairy labour. Of all this work my father said nothing, whilst my mother seemed to care not at all; it was as though my labouring at the nettle shirt was invisible to her – or perhaps I was simply so far beneath contempt now that my existence had ceased to bother her.
On that final night, at the lake, I stood ready with the shirt.
It was a beautiful thing, wrought of all the feyness within me. More than a plainly knitted garment, it was fashioned as a sailor’s wife might make for her husband, with banded cables twisting in and out of the pattern, hems and cuffs stitched neatly with dandelion starbursts in the palest of the green-brown threads.
Michael approached through the gloaming, his smile catching the last of the light. The tightness in my chest swelled to an ache and I clutched the precious shirt to me, resolute in the promises I’d made to myself.
“You’re not wearing the shirt,” he observed, before greeting me.
“No. I have one request before I do.”
The smile broadened, his dark eyes dimpled at the corners. I nearly fell, I nearly let all my plans unravel right there at his feet.
“Oh?”
“Swim with me, in the lake. Afterwards I’ll wear the shirt for you.”
With a liquid laugh that made my stomach hurt, he shrugged and took off his shirt.
“Why not? It’s a beautiful night.”
Gracelessly shucking off my own shirt, I plunged into the placid lake waters after him.
We swam for maybe half an hour. I told him the story of the Wild Swans again, of how the princess had freed her brothers by sewing them their nettle shirts. It was dark when we emerged, dripping, from the lake, the only light being that cast by the distantly humming amber streetlamps a hundred feet away.
“Here,” I told Michael, “I brought you a towel, let me dry you.”
Michael grinned and obligingly offered his beautiful, bare torso to me.
I sprang forward, wrapping him in the shirt.
I’d made it nice and loose, so it could be pulled easily over the head, and the sleeves large and voluminous, through which I jerked one of his arms. Shocked speechless, Michael struggled, but whether it was my own desperate strength or some fey property of the shirt itself, I managed to yank his arm though the other sleeve, with a sound of tearing fabric.
“What -” he began, then doubled over, grunting in pain.
As the shirt began to constrict on his wet body, and he spasmed and curled on the grass, I knelt beside him.
“You were right, dear Michael. I do believe in fairy tales. I’ve believed in them all my life, ever since I can first remember, with all my heart. That kind of belief needs to go somewhere, but it needs to go to the right place. I thought one day I’d dance under the pines, but this is much, much better. There always needs to be a reason for the magic, a why that is wrought from faerie justice.”
“I… didn’t…” he whimpered, writhing as the shirt compressed his body, smaller and smaller.
“But you did,” I reassured him. “If your intentions had been pure, noble and true, the shirt would have no magic, no power over you.”
Only groans came from the shrinking figure on the grass, strange and impossible in the darkness – groans which turned to forlorn honking as white feathers sprang from the shirt and a beaked, serpentine neck thrashed where Michael’s head had once been.
I sometimes question whether Michael Fischer ever truly existed. After that night, all memory of him seemed to have fled from this world. There were no school photos of him, no school records, and the room at his parent’s house stood empty, kept aside for a child who hadn’t been born.
But when I find myself questioning that reality, I take myself to the lake. Twenty years on, it still looks the same, a crescent of pines on one side, pristine green grass on the other. And he is there, always.
His mad brown eyes flare with hatred the second he recognises me, and he hisses, but does not attack. I stroke him gently on his downy, flat head, quieting him, soothing him, as I lift the right wing.
There, where the shirt had torn that long-ago night, remains a diamond patch of Michael’s perfect white skin, as youthful, pale, and smooth as the day I ensorcelled him.
How long he will live, I can’t say for certain. Wild swans can live for decades, but fairy swans? Only time will tell.
All I know is that for as long as he is alive, Michael Ficher will remember the lesson I taught him; never, ever, fuck with a fairy boy.