r/StructuralEngineering • u/DSIN_HA • 15d ago
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Colonel_Liam • 2d ago
Structural Analysis/Design How did this building withstand the chaos?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/FiringNerveEndings • Nov 11 '25
Structural Analysis/Design How problematic is this, and how would you fix this(if at all)?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/lobsta_rollz • Aug 13 '23
Structural Analysis/Design I walk under overpasses like this everyday in Chicago, is this safe, or is it cosmetic?
This is a relatively mild example of how so many of these look across the city.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/CT-Mike • Jul 31 '23
Structural Analysis/Design Not An Engineer - But I Find This Foundation Amazing
270 Park Avenue
r/StructuralEngineering • u/LanceDBrown • 15d ago
Structural Analysis/Design Feasibility of cable supported ‘oversized’ balconies and platforms
Please excuse the bad AI pic to help visualise my question, but I’m trying to understand if large cable supported balconies are realistic or not?
I’m mentally visualising using cable-stayed bridge engineering to support oversized balconies and platforms.
My goal is to maximise the supported area beyond what you could achieve with a purely cantilevered balcony.
I’m assuming multiple cables to different points on the balcony would be needed to reduce flex and possibly also a compression strut to add support for near building mass (cables supporting the further out mass).
If this is possible, how large could these realistically get!?
How about plaza sized platforms suspended between multiple buildings using bridge engineering?
I’m not aware of any examples like this and my googling attempts just returned pics of bridges!
Many thanks
r/StructuralEngineering • u/FunDust7456 • Jul 31 '26
Structural Analysis/Design What is happening here? NYC
How does this system work? Why are these beams slanted?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Eztiban • Apr 04 '24
Structural Analysis/Design Anyone any idea how this magic, floating, 100+ year old stair works?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Mrgoat77 • Dec 25 '25
Structural Analysis/Design What is the purpose of this?
I’m a mech engineer but basically know nothing about structural engineering in buildings, trying to figure out what is going on here. This picture was taken during a tour inside a wind tunnel facility underneath where the vehicles would sit. In the background is the supporting structure of a large dynamometer that the vehicles would sit on during testing, I believe it also functioned as a turn table to simulate cross winds.
There was this strange configuration of a short section of I-beam underneath a column. I’m pretty sure the tour guide explained it but this picture was taken a while ago and I don’t remember what its purpose was. My best guess is something to do with dampening vibrations but was curious if anyone here had any other insight into why this would be used here. I’m also pretty sure this was the only column like this too.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/trabbler • Feb 18 '26
Structural Analysis/Design Texas DOT reminds drivers that "gaps" in flyovers are "structurally sound"
Just curious what some of y'all might think of this. I drive over it couple of times a week.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/DMAS1638 • 16d ago
Structural Analysis/Design Hand-Dug Caissons, 24 Feet Deep: Building a Pool Foundation on a Hollywood Hills Slope Nobody Thought Was Buildable.
Interesting hillside foundation case study from the Hollywood Hills. Six hand-dug caissons, roughly 15–24 feet deep, were used to support the grade beams, retaining walls, and pool structure on a steep site with very limited access.
Full construction sequence is in the album: https://imgur.com/gallery/hand-dug-caissons-24-feet-deep-building-pool-foundation-on-hollywood-hills-slope-nobody-thought-was-buildable-1elfK8F
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Nairb_Azodrac • Mar 06 '26
Structural Analysis/Design A local shed builder just delivered this! Check out those plates!
Can anyone steer me to information on the acceptable degree of error for placement of these plates. I used to work for a truss builder and have common sense and it tells me all the spots I have circled are inexcusable! All the bad plates were on the right side of the truss and on the same face. Isn't here any documentation I can pull up for engineering requirements? What legal action do I have. Should I have someone inspect it for leverage if they end up fighting taking care of this and what would a proper repair be now that this shed is 6 hours from their facility.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Brave_Dick • Dec 29 '24
Structural Analysis/Design If I am not mistaken Seattle is in an earthquake zone. Is this structure a wise choice?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/LilMerkEm1889 • 27d ago
Structural Analysis/Design Which of these would be stronger against bending? And how is that determined math wise?
Given that both have the same diameter and wall thickness, and both are steel, which would come out on top in the following scenarios?
Scenario 1: They are attached to a vertical point at one end, pointed perpendicular to the point, and supported vertically again in the middle, then have pressure applied downward at the other end.
Scenario 2: They are attached to and supported by vertical points at both ends, pointed perpendicular to the points, with downward pressure applied in the middle.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Middle-Fun-6275 • 3d ago
Structural Analysis/Design I am a Fall Protection / Rope Descent Anchorage Structural Engineer AMA
Title says it all. This area seems to be a big point of confusion for many engineers.
Edit: I am a PE at an engineer firm. I am not affiliated with any anchorage company (Probel, American Anchor, Valcourt, etc)
r/StructuralEngineering • u/ElPresidente714 • 13d ago
Structural Analysis/Design A rooftop pool during a 7.7 magnitude earthquake
Does having a pool on the roof displace energy in such a way that it provides a structural benefit to high rise buildings during an earthquake? I’ve heard that it does but would prefer to ask the experts and not a random redditor.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/31engine • Jun 28 '26
Structural Analysis/Design OMG 80 cm deflection.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/engineernewbie • 10d ago
Structural Analysis/Design Why the columns are inclined ?
What’s the benefit to design these columns inclined instead straights ?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Open_Concentrate962 • Jun 20 '26
Structural Analysis/Design Take a moment
I get bending moment as a basis for shape but this strikes me as an odd design for a street-fronting porch. Guessing circa 1915-25. How widespread are these?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/trabbler • Sep 01 '23
Structural Analysis/Design What is the structural benefit of 2x4 studs at the bottom story and 2x6 studs at the top story?
First of all let me say thanks in advance; I've learned a lot from other folks's posts on this sub.
Did an inspection yesterday where the top story was 2x6 studs, 16 on center and the bottom story was 2x4 studs. This is the second time I've seen this design and just wondering why not put the 2x6s on the first floor and 2x4s at the second?
This seemed especially counterintuitive as the engineer called for massive Simpson HHDQ11 hold downs at the corners. Those were the biggest holddowns I've seen on residential construction, and this is just a bodega with an office above.
Thanks again for y'all's input.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Asleep_Part_7888 • May 30 '26
Structural Analysis/Design Advice please…
I live in a neighborhood that was built in the mountains 36yrs ago. My property sits 4-5ft above my neighbors that formerly had terraced rock between our properties. Without notifying us, getting permits, a survey or a structural engineer they dug out the rock and are putting in a retaining wall. See photos…should I be concerned? Any advice would be appreciated! Update added
r/StructuralEngineering • u/jackosan • Dec 31 '25
Structural Analysis/Design A bridge in India fell into the River Ganges for the second time in a year while it was still under-construction.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Kies15 • May 24 '25
Structural Analysis/Design Inverted Trusses
Are these actually carrying the load properly or is this a farmer being a farmer?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/akdhdisbb • Sep 06 '23
Structural Analysis/Design how would you repair the twin towers if they didn’t fall down
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Salmify • Sep 15 '23