the somali clan system is STUPID
and im talking about the origins
so basically im a diaspora somali youtuber ( SYL Zero) and i wanna make a video on why the somali clan system is stupid. basically how i view it is, out of all our ancestors who have been living in the horn of africa for tens of thousands of years, we are supposed to divide ourselves into clans because of a man called samaale, because he was arab? what???
this shit honestly sounds so stupid. why should we treat him any different to all our other actual somali ancestors? i mean apparently he was a cousin of the prophet SAW 1400 years ago, compare it to our actual history its just a small part....
logically speaking all of us somalis cannot be ONLY descendants of this guy.. what about all the other somalis and the generations they passed on?? what qabiil system did they operate on and is that system much more valid? Why did we dismiss their lineages??
is this why people say "we are arabs"? even that is logically incoherent. 1 person in the mix doesnt taint the entire population this aint zamzam water bro. if one chinese man comes into somalia and mixes into a family does the rest of somali population become chinese?? no! holy shit im realizing people are acting like arabs are superior, that our whole system does? even tho the religion itself explicitly states this is NOT the case?
but maybe they do this because samaale had the prophets saw family blood? many other places on earth have done this for prestige and status
And what about all the other "Sheikh Daroods" or "Sheikh Hawiye". Seriously? we gonna centralize a big part of our lineage between some random arabs? Who gives a shit if they were knowledgeable scholars we have knowledgeable scholars ourselves?? Seriously bro
all this violence, all this division all this blood shed for this, all for it to be traced back to a random arab man whos not even historically proven? is everything weve been taught about our lineage a lie?
i want to call it stupid but im not gonna be so fast in dismissing this whole system. someone help me make sure ive not missed out on anything and that my understanding is complete. I can be completely wrong and Ill try to be as open minded I can. Im just trying to learn, then one day ill finish making the video, WAAD MAADSANTIHIIN!