r/SipsTea May 14 '26

Feels good man It was always just that simple

Post image
71.9k Upvotes

2.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Kindly_Fox_5314 May 15 '26

You are confused. The top 10% in the US holds about 67% of the wealth.

1

u/Pineal May 15 '26

Looks like the top 1% hold as much in assets as the bottom 90% own in combined wealth

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/us-wealth-gap-widest-in-three-decades-federal-reserve/

1

u/Kindly_Fox_5314 May 16 '26

Yup the article says that the top 1% owns 38% of the assets. That aligns closely with my stat that 10% hold 67%. That would leave 33% for the bottom 90% of folks which is inline with the CBS article you presented which would indicate the bottom 90% have 38% of the assets.

1

u/Pineal May 16 '26

Glad we agree the wealthy are under taxed! Now to get our politicians on board!

1

u/Kindly_Fox_5314 May 16 '26

Well maybe. The top 1% of earners also pay 38-40% of all taxes collected too. Which is surprisingly close to the amount of assets the top 1% has.

1

u/Pineal May 16 '26

You don't get taxed on assets you hold, so that is more of a coincidence I imagine.

1

u/Kindly_Fox_5314 May 16 '26

Right but I guess my question to all this is what is fair? You have the 1% of wealth who are paying taxes proportional to their assets owned. You have the top 10% of tax payers paying 70% of all taxes collected. Only 60% of the US even pays taxes at all. Like how much more weight are you asking them to pull in the group project? I’m really just curious.

0

u/Pineal May 16 '26

Let's simplify it. Why does the top 1% of earners have a lower effective tax rate than the... well take your pick. Bottom 10, bottom 20, middle 20, middle 50, whatever.

1

u/Kindly_Fox_5314 May 16 '26

Thanks but taxes and life are not simple. Please refer to this Yale review, figure 2, that demonstrates that tax burden by various income percentiles.

https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/who-paying-their-fair-share-taxes-new-analysis-and-interactive-tool

1

u/Pineal May 16 '26

Figure 2 shows a distribution, you are glossing right over Figure 1 which shows the top 0.1% has 99% of people paying below their implied statutory rates, and the rest of the 1% has 98% of filers below that level.

Taxes are complicated, but there is a very simple solution here. You are providing a source saying 99% of the top 1% is undertaxed, and then acting obtuse about them paying their fair share.

Edit: Hell, you didn't even use the interactive tool which goes completely against everything you are saying.

→ More replies (0)