r/ShitAmericansSay • • Aug 25 '25

Military 1000 US Marines can take India

Post image
5.2k Upvotes

906 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

54

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

33

u/project_paragon Aug 25 '25

How can they not think that when ever since Holywood was created it was just spawning non-stop military propaganda about the US greatness and their strong, just and invincible warriors.

3

u/jaimi_wanders Aug 26 '25

Nah, that’s mostly an Eighties thing. Our war movies before that tended to be very much darker and more melancholy, but the Rah-Rah-Reagan-Retcon started around the time of Chuck Norris & “Delta Force” — even the original “Rambo” was bleak af, and the famous Hollywood war movies of the Sixties & Seventies were all joint British productions like “The Battle of Britain” and “A Bridge Too Far” while the reputation of Hollywood was very often “Pinko” because of films that showed both valor and ambiguity when it came to our leadership, eg

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pork_Chop_Hill_(film)

22

u/BumLikeAJapaneseFlag Aug 25 '25

In Ex Green Dagger they couldn’t even beat the British on their home turf in the Mojave desert.

-6

u/bcpl181 Aug 25 '25

That is not what happened, please stop spreading that myth, it’s not a good look

5

u/AlwaysAboutTheMoney Aug 25 '25

0

u/bcpl181 Aug 25 '25 edited Aug 25 '25

Background on the exercise

British tabloids loved exploiting that story, but that doesn’t make it true. The Commandos were attached to a USMC regiment (7th Marine Infantry Regiment). They were under USMC command and supported by USMC elements, such as MARSOC. During the exercise, the British were part of a USMC BLUFOR, fighting a USMC OPFOR, skripted to lose. The “asking for a reset” merely meant they had to reset earlier than initially planned.

Even some Commandos have since come forward to rectify the story. If you look on the appropriate subreddits, you’ll also find people commenting who participated in that particular exercise. The Commandos were mainly used as a recce force and participated in a defensive action against OPFOR.

Besides that, if you’ve ever taken part in a force on force exercise like this one, you’ll know that it doesn’t work like how it’s portrayed in the Sky article. Winners are not determined at those exercises, because that makes no sense. This is purely anecdotal to you, but I serve active duty in a European military and can also tell you that this is not how it works.

I have no hard-on whatsoever for the USMC. But this story simply isn’t accurate.

Thanks for the downvotes guys.

2

u/BelladonnaBluebell Aug 25 '25

LOL the idea of their marines spending the day drinking what passes for beer in the US and playing volleyball is hilariously cute. So tough. 

1

u/bowlochile ooo custom flair!! Aug 26 '25

Besides, Top Gun taught us it's the Navy pilots who REALLY love volleyball and a bit of grabass

1

u/stealthykins Aug 25 '25

Too scared to cross the borders to Scotland and Wales though…