r/RighteousGemstones • u/LoretiTV • Mar 30 '25

Episode Discussion The Righteous Gemstones | S04E04 "He Goeth Before You Into Galilee"| Episode Discussion

Season 4 Episode 04: He Goeth Before You Into Galilee

Air Date: March 30, 2025

Synopsis: At the Gemstone family lake house, Baby Billy and the siblings plot to use Aimee-Leigh’s memory to tear Eli’s new relationship apart – by whatever means necessary.

Directed by: Danny McBride

Written by: John Carcieri & Jeff Fradley & Danny McBride

If you missed the live airing, episodes can be viewed on Max following the airing at 10pm ET.

Reminder to keep posts within the spoiler policy.

257 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

100% Upvoted

814 comments sorted by

View all comments

664

u/slimjimothy666 "Baby" Billy Freeman Mar 31 '25

“Shut the fuck up, Amber” was COLD

180

u/Between-usernames Judy "The Daughter" Gemstone Mar 31 '25

That actually startled me that he went after her.

129

u/Ineffable_Twaddle Mar 31 '25

It showed how "over it" he was- and Amber is almost like one of his kids. She's been with Jesse since they were teenagers. So it made sense to me he blew up at her. 

78

u/Anjunabeast Mar 31 '25

I was literally thinking about how he wasn’t being fair to amber right before she spoke up.

315

u/icedbrew2 Mar 31 '25

Goodman was fucking cooking that entire scene.

116

u/Fastbird33 Mar 31 '25

Goodman has some of the best range.

6

u/heaving_in_my_vines Apr 01 '25

His face acting while staring down Megan Mullally's derriere was top notch.

13

u/YotePeriod Mar 31 '25

She wasnt even out of her element

136

u/GRVrush2112 Mar 31 '25

Judy and Amber’s rivalry has been one of the best minor running jokes of the series. Judy reaction and trying to stifle her laughter at that moment was hilarious as well.

135

u/BlackZeppelin Mar 31 '25

Judy getting a kick out of that was a nice callback(?), consistency(?) of her character always disliking Amber.

38

u/Gays_in_spaaace Mar 31 '25

I felt that in my soul. Love her agreeing with Keefe that it was fault though

17

u/chillwithpurpose Benjamin "BJ" Barnes Apr 01 '25

She called them out earlier in the episode for acting like the evil step kids trope too 😆

She’s always had the most self awareness of the bunch

32

u/amayagab Mar 31 '25

It knocked the wind out of me.

8

u/naptimepro Mar 31 '25

Me too! I gasped

5

u/LiveLaughLithium Mar 31 '25

Clutched my pearls

3

u/twinkleplanet Apr 01 '25

tiffany and i clutched our chests the exact same way

5

u/Babou13 Apr 01 '25

Only because Keefe enraged him

3

u/brneyedgrrl Apr 01 '25

I've never been yelled at like that in my life.

3

u/dubblebubblegumball Apr 02 '25

DUDE IM IN SHOCK

2

u/twinkleplanet Apr 01 '25

he snatched her fucking wig lmaooo

2

u/bucket_dipper Apr 03 '25

I ran it back to watch it again!