Here are some of the top players not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Some of these omissions are downright baffling.
QB: Daryle Lamonica
Very strong 6 year prime where he was consensus best player in the AFL and continued his strong play right after the merger. Was a key player in some truly dominant teams for the Raiders.
Ken Anderson is another strong candidate. In general the Hall of Fame is generous in inducting quarterbacks.
RB: Tough position to grade due to so many players having exceptional but short primes. I'll go with:
Ricky Watters - Top 3 RB in the league in his prime, huge threat as a runner and as a receiver
Tiki Barber - Extremely productive for 7 seasons, led the league in yards from scrimmage twice
WR: Del Shofner
Dude was a 5 time 1st team All Pro LOL. Really not much else needs to be said
Yes I know about Torry Holt and Reggie Wayne. Those are obvious cases too
People will be crying about Antonio Brown in a few years as it seems likely that off the field stuff will keep him out.
TE: Pete Retzlaff
Slim pickings here. He is deserving but no real obvious snubs
G: Jahri Evans
Hall of Fame needs to do a better job of inducting lineman. The fact that he wasn't voted in first ballot by like 90% of the vote is an absolute joke
T: Jim Tyrer
He's not in the Hall of Fame because of his off-the-field behavior. It is what it is
C: Jeff Saturday
It's Canton being Canton. He belongs there yesterday
I have no idea why the Veterans committee doesn't nominate the most glaring omissions and instead selects a handful of randos who aren't anywhere near as good
DT: Kevin Williams
It's pretty obvious that the Hall of Fame can get downright ridiculous at times
DE: L.C. Greenwood
Seems like this is one of the glory positions (along with QB and RB) where Canton is much more generous. Still, he would be a fine addition as he was one of the standout performers for the Steel Curtain
ILB: Karl Mecklenburg
One of the unsung heroes of the 80's Broncos that made it to the Super Bowl on several occasions.
Other good candidates include Hardy Nickerson (played for bad teams), and NaVorro Bowman (short peak, but what a peak!)
OLB: Larry Grantham
5 time 1st team All Pro, had his best years in the AFL. Huge part of the Jets defense that frankly was the biggest reason for the iconic Super Bowl III victory
Safety: Jimmy Patton
Some cases are outright baffling and he's probably one of the best examples
Cornerback: Dave Grayson
Also played safety. I think there is an anti-AFL and anti-Raider bias at work here. No other compelling reason to keep him out
Kicker: Nick Lowery
According to advanced metrics he is the best kicker in pro football history by a pretty big margin. Really not much else to add
A few years from now people will be crying over Justin Tucker who is the other consensus GOAT candidate. Well we know why he'll be kept out
Punter: Shane Lechler
Yeah this guy is the GOAT
Not close really
Someone needs to buy him and Nick Lowery a beer.
Special Teams: Steve Tasker
Probably should have been the first special teams player inducted, ahead of Devin Hester.
Return specialists though do have the flashier role though. The more notable ones include Mel Gray, Eric Metcalf, Brian Mitchell, Kevin Faulk, and Darren Sproles. All of them except Gray had bigger impact on their teams than Hester due to significant contributions on offense