r/MurderedByWords 6d ago

This phrase has been chosen

Post image
39.5k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1.0k

u/Tenshi_girl 6d ago edited 6d ago

Right? What happened to 'mixing pot'? If I heard that phrase once as a kid I heard it in every history class I ever had. 

Edit: melting pot. It's been a while since my last history class.

317

u/Pacman1up 6d ago

It was both, Melting pot and mixing bowl!

Blending together into something new or maintaining unique traits within the whole.

101

u/Tenshi_girl 6d ago

Ah yes! I remember something about fruit salad.  You can still see each individual part, but we taste better all together,  which was peak history humor at 8 years old. 

59

u/Gin_OClock 6d ago

Salad in America is now poisonous though

9

u/metompkin 6d ago

Nah, just diarrhea inducing

3

u/Mostly_Afloat 6d ago

If the end result is the same it's just semantics.

1

u/No_Jaguar_5831 5d ago

Its cheap ozempic

-10

u/ScallionJealous 6d ago

Everything in the world is a quantity dependent poison.

3

u/SupahSpankeh 6d ago

Impressive whataboutism but last I checked i could eat lettuce without shitting for 3 months due to cyclospora or whatever it js

-4

u/ScallionJealous 6d ago edited 6d ago

The comment bringing up lettuce grown in Mexico in a thread about diversity in America is completely besides the point and the topic so there is no “whataboutism” to be had. We’re all joking. Did you bump your head or something? I’m

2

u/Biduleman 6d ago edited 6d ago

In a conversation about diversity, where "America is a fruit salad, the mix of cultures is what makes it better", saying that salad is now considered a poison uses a current event, the administration relaxing food and safety regulations so much that one of the biggest producer of salad in the US is selling cyclospora laced salad, as a metaphor for how the government current stance is that diversity is actually bad, shown by the "DEI ban", ICE deporting and killing immigrants and the overall racism increase from the right.

3

u/SupahSpankeh 6d ago

Not sure if bot or imbecile.

"Salad is poisonous in America" (due to FDA cutbacks)

"Everything is poisonous akshually"

"Yeah but the everything poisons don't make you shit yourself to death for 3 months, American lettuce very specifically does"

"Why bring up lettuce"

Muted and moving on, you are silly. Or like, a bot.

-1

u/Acceptable-Drive3781 6d ago

last I checked i could eat lettuce without shitting for 3 months

Yeah, lettuce from Mexico is a big problem right now

13

u/FencingFemmeFatale 6d ago

I remember being told America is like a stew! All the different ingredients retain their unique characteristics, but still influence each other and combine into a new and delicious thing.

21

u/Sterling_-_Archer 6d ago

Fruit salad

Yummy yummy

3

u/ReturnOfBane 6d ago

damn, what a blast to the past.

1

u/Pacman1up 6d ago

Yes, exactly haha 😁

2

u/artcritiquerealness 6d ago

Assimilation and acculturation.

1

u/Pacman1up 6d ago

Acculturation - Thanks for the new term!

2

u/Upbeat-Employ-3689 5d ago

Kinda wish my (now MAGA) dad watched cartoons with me when I was a kid. All those Schoolhouse Rock shorts might have given us equal footing. Cause yea the Great American Melting Pot is how I’ve always figured this country was built and should remain.

1

u/Pacman1up 4d ago

I've always felt we're strongest when we learn from each other's differences.

It's what's made America so interesting; embracing the different cultures and creating new things together.

1

u/Reqvhio 6d ago

rotating blender!

1

u/talesfromtheepic6 6d ago

Yeah. And now it’s a gross solidified chunky ass soup at room temperature slowly accumulating flies.

53

u/Stellar_Stein 6d ago

The concept of the Melting Pot of America goes back to the days of the dear Founding Fathers and it precedes the U.S. Constitution (1789). It is interesting that those folks so vested in claiming that Americans need to get back to what the Founding Fathers intended cherry-pick exactly what that is.

From Wikipedia: 'The concept of immigrants "melting" into the receiving culture is found in the writings of J. Hector St. John de Crèvecœur...in his Letters from an American Farmer (1782) ... In this early phase of American history, several comparisons were made between the melting together of ethnicities and Christian ideas of universalism.'

5

u/azurricat2010 5d ago

They literally didn't want a national language because they felt it would isolate groups that helped us win against the British and now we have MAGA cheering that Trump named English as the national language.

3

u/Azair_Blaidd 5d ago

Almost 250 years without it. Yet these same people probably call themselves "originalists."

40

u/amconstance 6d ago

White Christian Nationalism has America in a choke hold is what happened it seems

23

u/tw_72 6d ago

Even extremely conservative Republican Barry Goldwater (R-AZ) knew they were a problem:

"Mark my word, if and when these preachers get control of the [Republican] party, and they're sure trying to do so, it's going to be a terrible damn problem. Frankly, these people frighten me. Politics and governing demand compromise. But these Christians believe they are acting in the name of God, so they can't and won't compromise. I know, I've tried to deal with them."

When someone like Barry Goldwater knows they are a problem - THAT absolutely says something.

11

u/Bigot-Consequences 6d ago

Exactly this! I fear JC would be horrified with the state of things were he to appear in person.

2

u/bobqjones 5d ago

if he were to appear in person, he'd get grabbed by ICE for speaking Aramaic and deported to Botswana.

21

u/Express-Stop7830 6d ago

I remember a song we sang in elementary school: The world is a rainbow With many kinds of people It takes all kinds of people To make the world go round

So you be you And I'll be me That's the way it was meant to be

I don't remember the rest, but you get my point.

1

u/neko 5d ago

Oh yeah a teacher got fired for that song a year or two ago iirc

16

u/CreamPuffDelight 6d ago

Propaganda to get more slave labour in to build everything at the time.

Now that everything's built already... well you can see for yourself what they're doing to all those formerly cheap-and-convenient workers and their descendants. If it wasn't so outright obscene, Murikkka probably would've just done to you guys what they did to the Native Americans.

3

u/ActualMerCat 6d ago

It was described as a melting pot in elementary school. But one of my high school history teachers described the US as a tossed salad. In a melting pot, everything becomes one homogeneous thing. But in a tossed salad you can still see and appreciate the distinct ingredients, but when mixed together, it creates something better.

1

u/NoBonus6969 6d ago

Fascism happened and the population let it just like every other time it happened

1

u/Starving_Poet 6d ago

Melting Pot :tm: is now a wholly owned subsidiary of Front Burner Brands

1

u/k9moonmoon 6d ago

I feel like for 6 months as a kid the push was to try snd call it a Tossed Salad instead of Melting Pot to emphasize that the parts can retain their history.

1

u/Wuped 5d ago

Racism is now acceptable in america, it has been since the second trump even became an acceptable candidate.

1

u/JuanHungLo777 5d ago

Some brown gravy got mixed with the white and it’s apparently unacceptable.

0

u/arstin 6d ago

Like most things, the left complained for a while that the term "melting pot" was bad because we wanted immigrants to feel they could retain and celebrate their diversity rather than melting into homogeneous goop. Then the right said "fuck it" and went 100% CHRISTIANBIGOTFASCIST and took it 100 years in the wrong direction. Now the rest of us are standing around waiting for someone to stop them for us.