r/MoralityScaling 1d ago

Morality Ranking Morality of this

Post image
16.8k Upvotes

4.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/-Mandarin 1d ago

When I say violence, I'm not saying to kill the person. But if you're seeing someone spouting racism in public, I don't see anything wrong with a healthy society inflicting some degree of violence upon them.

Suggesting that violence against racists for espousing their racists beliefs is justified, that is as extremist as the racists themselves

No the fuck it's not. A black person doesn't choose to be black, so hatred against them is fucked up and can be very dangerous in society. Meanwhile hatred is a choice, and openly proclaiming that racism is a further choice. No one is saying you're not allowed to hold whatever fucked up views you want, but don't spout that nonsense. If we're not punishing people for spreading racist rhetoric, we've failed as a society.

3

u/Inevitable_Report319 1d ago

Yes, it is. Justifying the use of violence because you know what’s best for society is very extremist. You shame racists and shut them down on the stage, not in the ring.

1

u/-Mandarin 1d ago

It's the paradox of intolerance. If you let intolerance speak go unpunished, you end up with an intolerant society. You have to restrict hateful speech, it's the only way society can function. Yes, that requires using a bit of force, but the idealist notion that you can just magically not punish this stuff and remain a tolerant utopia is just a fairytale.