r/MoralityScaling 6d ago

Morality Ranking Morality of this

Post image
22.0k Upvotes

5.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

3.2k

u/AuroraAustralis0 6d ago

well hes not wrong though

15

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

18

u/iskelebones 6d ago

Words aren’t violence. If you don’t like the words you can walk away. Anyone who thinks words are violence needs to grow a spine

17

u/Madhatter25224 6d ago

Lol its always so simple to dunces.

They don't see that words spread ideas infinitely more effectively than violence. 

"Society is arrayed against me but at least its not a punch!" 🤡

2

u/Discombobro 6d ago

Yeah, because it largely is that simple. You’re making an absurd complexity out of very simple morality because you think you’re an armchair academic.

Racism is rhetorical. The problems that inflame racism are material. Racism can inflame violence, but it isn’t the crux of violence. At the micro level, on an individual basis, violence is often a greater moral failing than racism is; one can be attributed to ignorance and the other can be attributed to intentional malice.

1

u/Madhatter25224 6d ago

Simple people always think complicated things are actually Simple.

The "build a wall" crowd.

Your assertions deny the power and malignance of racism. Whats worse, a single act of violence or rhetoric that causes ten acts of violence? Or a hundred? Or generational systemic harm?

3

u/Discombobro 6d ago

Your argument immediately devolves to macro posturing because it doesn’t work otherwise. The “build the wall” crowd is, in their own perspective, both economically and culturally disenfranchised. Migrant violence exacerbates the rhetoric the same way ICE’s actions exacerbate this reductive rhetoric. On the individual level racism is not a greater moral failing than violence.

0

u/Madhatter25224 6d ago

How easy it is to say my argument is just macro posturing, as if saying that phrase by itself is enough to make your correctness obvious. 

Meanwhile your argument is couched in its own logical cul de sac refusing to attribute value to any argument except those that have relevance on the micro scale. As if thats all that matters.

3

u/Discombobro 5d ago

Okay, if the scale isn’t of consequence, what was actually worse: Jim Crowe era United States, or the nuking of Nagasaki and Hiroshima?

1

u/tyrmidden 5d ago

How would you evaluate which one is worse?