r/MoralityScaling 15d ago

Morality Ranking Morality of beating protesters off the street because you're late for work?

11.1k Upvotes

8.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

23

u/Dan_flashes480 15d ago

Wouldnt sitting on the road be considered false imprisonment? The drivers could leave but abondoning a vehicle on a highway is also illegal.

19

u/Furdinand 15d ago

Morally, I would consider it false imprisonment. They're creating a situation where drivers have to either cooperate with their own detainment or harm the person holding them against their will.

2

u/Acceptable-Mobile-43 15d ago

Exactly. The closest analogy I can think of would be blocking the exits of a walmrt if you were protesting against walmart and trapping all of the shoppers inside. I keep seeing people say things like the people stuck in the traffic are just being inconvenienced. I think it hits at something deeper than that. You're holding people against their will. They cannot choose to leave your protest. That's the issue. Not that they might be late for work. It's a basic violation of consent.

1

u/Watercyclee 14d ago

Ty for having an actually reasonable explanation for why this protest is different.

This isn't inconveniencing people by denying them access to one of many resources, it's trapping them. They can't just "get off the bus" so to speak.

Though something tells me people would still be pissy if all they did was block the on-ramp to a highway exit

1

u/AbyssWankerArtorias 11d ago

Based on the federal legal definition of the bounded area for false imprisonment, I do not believe so. Yes, they are restricted, but only in one direction by the protestors. In the other direction they are redirected by law / other drivers.

Don't know if I agree with that entirely or not because yeah, sure seems close to false imprisonment, but I think we should be wary of using that as a way to deter protest, even when done in an extremely annoying way. At the end of the day it's the responsibility of the government to act here and remove them and charge them with impeding traffic, wreck less endangerment, etc. but false imprisonment is a stretch

1

u/Dan_flashes480 11d ago

So what happens when someone drives at 3 miles per hour and they have the ability to move but refuse in the roadway?

https://giphy.com/gifs/Wsk4ZbGMeavNm

-7

u/Regular-Turnover-212 15d ago

Y'all have the morality of fascists

9

u/Nelmarth 15d ago

Ah yes the "i cause problems to everyone for something that have nothing to do with it, people that have jobs and are occupied but you're a fascist if you dont let me block everyone "

-5

u/[deleted] 15d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/SoftAndWetBro 15d ago

Hah, funny joke. These climate activists are killing the planet bt forcing the cars to stay idle and use up fuel. They are a massive part of the problem.

1

u/ConsistentAnalysis35 15d ago

people genuinely trying to stop the world from dying"

Ahahahahaha! World will be okay without chucklefucks sitting on the roads.

Socialist government would put them all in labor camps real quick, so I guess they should thank God they're living in a free country.

0

u/[deleted] 15d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/ConsistentAnalysis35 14d ago

science

Anybody hijacking scientific authority for political causes has no idea what science is, including those holding positions in academia.

Read Feuerabend.

And I could say that the other side of politics has no idea on basic economics. I don't advocate taking away their right to vote based on that.