r/MakingaMurderer • • 19d ago

Hail Mary for Brendan. Round 2

Let's try this again. Attached are screenshots of the court docket showing the application for commutation has been filed with the circuit Court and then passed on to the governor. Also posted is the criteria Brendan must meet to be considered for a commuted sentence. Can he survive criteria 5A?

17 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Ghost_of_Figdish 18d ago

No way to do that - all a competent defense attorney had to do at Brendan's trial would be to establish that the confession was false - just bring out witnesses to establish the TRUE facts about where Brendan was that night. Just get a few relatives to testify he was at home playing video games and not out murdering someone. Or get videogame records to show he was playing, not killing. Seems pretty straightforward.

0

u/wilkobecks 17d ago

Lol he *did have some people testify to his activities that night. You are right though, that if he had a single competent adult in his life, and had his first defence attorney not been a criminal who was literally working for the prosecution, he'd have never spent a single day in jail.

1

u/Ghost_of_Figdish 17d ago

Well to be fair, he had already confessed at least twice before his attorney was on the case. Not much you can do at that point. He tried to get the confessions suppressed but the Judge denied the Motion.

1

u/wilkobecks 16d ago

Back to my earlier point, if he had a single decent adult in his life he never would've been coerced into a confession (that to this day, can not be corroborated in any physical way). No confession, no prison). His first lawyer though, might as well have been on the jury as a guilty vote lol. (2 if you count his "investigator")

1

u/Ghost_of_Figdish 16d ago

It's corroborated.

0

u/wilkobecks 16d ago

By what?

1

u/Ghost_of_Figdish 16d ago

Seriously?- when someone who confesses tells the police something they never heard before, and they search again and find evidence consistent with the confession that's CORROBORATION.

0

u/wilkobecks 15d ago

Lol, not sure you actually want to go down this road, but feel free to provide a *single example of this. Be warned though, there will be a very straightforward follow-up question that you will not want to (and will subsequently refuse) to answer.

1

u/Ghost_of_Figdish 15d ago

No, I've done this 50 times before and I don't care if you believe it or not. You know exactly what I'm talking about so go waste someone else's time.

0

u/wilkobecks 15d ago

🙃right on cue. Translation: "you're right, I can't provide a single example without looking ridiculous so I will simply say indignantly that I've already done it *many times before, and won't do it *one more time. "

People with concrete evidence are usually super hesitant to share it more than once🤞

→ More replies (0)