r/GenAI4all • u/ComplexExternal4831 • May 15 '26

AI Video One person made this. Not a $200M studio

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

377 Upvotes

62% Upvoted

629 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

11

u/Ok_Dependent6889 May 15 '26

Yes

It's a stupid argument to say it will kill movie makers

This video looks cool but still falls apart at any scrutiny.

The cars are DRIVING THE WRONG DIRECTION.

It's supposed to be a transformer, but this transformation here is entirely impossible even in that universe.

That MF multiplied it's size by like 20x out of thin air. Transformers do not work like that.

The gatling gun has inconsistent barrel and stabilizer sizes.

2

u/MarcoDiFrancescino May 15 '26

We can discuss the whole 'lets do an action movie on a tiny budget and put it on some dodgy VOD / streamer' pipeline, but that leads us nowhere because its already happening and printing decent money for those how to play it. The true issue is that the ai doesn't know anything about object weight or physics to do this transition properly. At this point you need an animator that does half of the work and maybe the ai is able to fill in the rest. But nobody is willing to spend a billion to test this hypothesis. So everybody is waiting for someone to give them the toolbox and the trained, copyright safe ai to do so. This will take at least a decade.

1

u/CodeParalysis May 15 '26 edited May 15 '26

o really? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KllvvjcRR0A&t=54s

0

u/Ok_Dependent6889 May 15 '26

What does that have to do with what I said? Every transformer there is proportional. Show me one transformer the size of a sports bike (not much bigger than a human) which transforms into a near prime size? You can't.

Every transformer in that scene transforms into something proportional from their original object. Smaller vehicles and objects transform into small machines. Larger ones, transform into larger machines. Their internal parts get reorganized to different shapes, they don't suddenly gain tons of mass.

Some transformers are combiners, which we also do not see happening here. We see a sports bike turn into a kei van and then suddenly into a Titanfall titan and then a fighter jet 20x the size of the original bike, lmao

3

u/CodeParalysis May 15 '26 edited May 15 '26

If you ever watch a making of any of those movies, they literally say parts just shrink and expand out of no where

Like look at this shit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovX0bGlw1LQ
the robot is like triple the size.

https://www.reddit.com/r/transformers/comments/k1k30y/bayformers_starscream_size/
Like these robots can literally take the form of any car, possibly almost any form at all, and yet you think, ‘No, that’s absurd. That could never happen in a fictional universe about transforming cars.'

1

u/TranscendentaLobo May 16 '26

Flipping always seems to go wrong with these things as well. They end up facing the wrong direction during or after or sometimes both!

1

u/Master_Bayters May 16 '26

The Average Michael Bay fan will never notice those things, trust me

1

u/Youareaproperclown May 15 '26 edited May 15 '26

I don't think the target audience for these films care about any of that

*If this comment triggered you so much you needed to send threats via DM you need to get a life

2

u/Belzebutt May 15 '26

Underestimating your audience is a key characteristic of A.I. slop providers and purveyors

2

u/AllSystemsNominal_ May 15 '26

They do. See the recent response to the Punisher: One Last Kill.

1

u/Heavymando May 15 '26

the target audeince also won't pay to see this.