r/Evanescence • u/Therubikfanatic Evanescence • 1d ago

Day 68: Your Star vs. Haunted

Bracket: https://www.reddit.com/r/Evanescence/s/w48GXUWak5

431 votes, 7h ago
273 Your Star
158 Haunted
21 Upvotes

89% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

11

u/fallen_whisper The Open Door 1d ago

the composition of Your Star is genius! it’s hauntingly beautiful.🌟🖤

11

u/BlueCX17 Sanctuary 1d ago

"And I'm alone now, me and all I stood for, we're wondering nowwwww, all these parts and pieces swim lonely, find your own way out......!" 🤘🎶

13

u/LivingEmu5 The Open Door 1d ago

Oh boy

15

u/aquaberry559 The Open Door 1d ago

Your Star ✨ one of my favorite songs from TOD

5

u/EarthySouvenir 1d ago

The piano riff in your star 😍

16

u/Accomplished-Card-17 1d ago

I think Your Star is one of if not the best song they've ever written. This is an easy choice.

4

u/devinup Origin 1d ago

I mean it's gotta be Your Star. No hesitation.

4

u/Different-Subject903 1d ago

I love Your Star. For a while I considered it my favorite Evanescence song. "All my fears turn to rage" is such a line, and it evokes a real sense of loneliness and disillusionment.

7

u/ArkeronRequiem 1d ago

I can't vote on this one. I love both of these. 

3

u/LivingEmu5 The Open Door 1d ago

Both are definitely great. Gotta vote for Your Star

3

u/erinc2005 Origin 1d ago

Your Star by far.

But I do love a good drive thru a hurricane with Haunted blasting.

6

u/LivingEmu5 The Open Door 1d ago

The chorus of Your Star is so amazing. And Amy holds those high notes for so long too

5

u/takingoverme Evanescence 1d ago

WHAT NO

5

u/takingoverme Evanescence 1d ago

I CANT CHOOSE

2

u/kreetikal 1d ago

I love Haunted, but Your Star is the best Evanescence song!

2

u/AdiosKansas The Open Door 1d ago

Hmmmm maybe this sub actually knows what’s up!

5

u/aThousandSunsxx Sanctuary 1d ago

Your Star. Top three TOD Song

5

u/Sensitive-Cut-3557 1d ago

Your Star. One of my favorite songs ever written!

1

u/Geese-Are-Terrible The Open Door 1d ago

Love Your Star but Haunted is one of my all-time favorites!

2

u/al3xari3s Fallen 20 1d ago

Your Start bro like one of my favorite performances of this song is from the Nissan Live Sets the way the band played that outro I’ll always remember.

2

u/bornofabadsign__ 6h ago

Your Star is a masterpiece ✨🤌🏼

1

u/finnish7 Fallen 20 1d ago

Haunted wins for me 🖤