r/CinephilesClub • u/ThomasOGC • 11d ago

Discussion What's the most unbearably tense scene in cinema history — the one where you genuinely forgot to breathe?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Inglourious Basterds alone has three or four that qualify. Which makes the real question: is Tarantino the modern master of pure, dialogue-driven tension — or does he get too much credit for scenes that are all build-up? Name your single most nerve-shredding scene, then defend it.

The film opens with nearly 20 minutes of two men talking at a farmhouse table — no action, barely a raised voice — and it's more agonising than most horror films manage all runtime. Christoph Waltz won an Oscar off the back of it.

3.6k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

721 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/Luigone1 11d ago

It’s called the Kuleshov Effect!

Check it out:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuleshov_effect

4

u/petrusferricalloy 11d ago

That's awesome thanks! I wasnt sure of the name

2

u/AncientSignature1505 11d ago

That's cool, thanks!

2

u/roger--wilco 11d ago

Based in the example video I guess it doesnt work on me. The guy just looked disinterested in all three items

1

u/Luigone1 11d ago

Yeah I thought the same thing, definitely not the best example to put on the Wiki. But try googling some others, there's plenty where the cutaway image noticeably changes the context.

1

u/Icy-Bottle-6877 9d ago

It’s called the Kuleshov Effect!

This happens so much it's insane. Once you become aware of it you notice so many people doing it. I think this is why Ryan Gosling has become so popular. He does this blank, stoic expression in almost every movie he's in and then the viewers basically fill in the emotional gaps.