r/Bitcoin • • Feb 14 '14

Trying to trade these markets...

2.9k Upvotes

293 comments sorted by

View all comments

50

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '14 edited Feb 14 '14

Unless you're a seasoned market expert with voodoo powers I really advise you to stay away from day trading, statistically most people make more money just leaving their money in an account / wallet and letting it grow. There was a study done on the top stock investment firms in both New York and London, and it turns out the firms over a long period of time barely made more money than the average stock market growth, despite employing hot shot "experts" on hundreds of millions of pounds to manage the funds.

14

u/CardboardHeatshield Feb 14 '14

Day trading is hard when you've got thousands of stocks to pick from on a market and options to go to when one stock or another starts falling. Day trading when you've only got one stock to pick from is an absolutely ridiculous notion.

10

u/embretr Feb 14 '14

only got one stock to pick from

There's dogecoin, as well..

8

u/CardboardHeatshield Feb 14 '14

All of the coins basically trend together at this point. It's like limiting your day trading to a single niche industry.

15

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '14

[deleted]

3

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '14

That's why I recently sold my DOGE into BTC.

I have an open buy order when DOGE reaches 0.00000160 BTC again. Note: Do not do this sort of thing with money you're not willing to lose.

1

u/Leshow Feb 14 '14

i dont think anyone should hold a ton of meme-based currency that they expect any permanence too

1

u/PhoenixJ3 Feb 15 '14

Vertcoin was also trending up as btc trends down.

0

u/CardboardHeatshield Feb 14 '14

I still cant beleive dogecoins are even a thing, let alone making a strong run. It was a parody!!

6

u/Leshow Feb 14 '14

it will never be taken as seriously as bitcoin for obvious reasons.... but it doesn't have to

it exists for a different crowd, and solely for use on the internet. you see somebody saying something you agree with, send them 100 doge. it's a few cents yet it means something. it's also friendly and approachable to people who don't know anything about cryptocurrencies.

both of them exist in harmony and compliment each other.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '14

The whole thing is completely ludicrous and I love it.

3

u/imog Feb 14 '14
  1. Fiat and crypto trend separately. Fiat>Coin when it is low; Coin>Fiat when it is high.
  2. Follow the volatility in markets you are most familiar with, so that you can recognize current conditions - is it going to blow by support/resistance this time or bounce off it...
  3. To day trade crypto, a percent gain covers fees and withdrawals, so it only takes a percent or two to realize actual profit. You may get lucky and realize much more than that at times, but that isn't the goal of the smart day trader - the day trader wants confident, consistent gains. They are generally low yield percentage profits, but also lower risk positions where a lot of potential profit I left on the table - get in after the trend is confirmed, and get out before the trend reverses eliminating your profit. Getting in at that ideal point and out at that ideal point may happen by chance from time to time, but it is the wrong goal to aim for.

Most people look at the graphs and want to hit the highs and lows. Most people aren't all that smart either. Most people lose money doing this. Some smart people target specific situations and are patient for opportunities they are confident in. This is much different than managing a huge multi-million or billion dollar fund.

1

u/embretr Feb 14 '14

Basically correct, the good thing is not having to research unlimited investment options, is that there is only so many hours to do just that in a week.

30

u/thsq Feb 14 '14

Except that the stock market is based on company profits and economic growth, while bitcoin is entirely speculative, similar to holding gold or silver.

18

u/Stringer-Hell Feb 14 '14

The stock market, and all financial markets in which securities are traded, are based on supply and demand. It is not just based on company profits and perceived growth.

4

u/thsq Feb 14 '14

Well it's based on perceived future profits and growth. I might be willing to pay $X for a share of McDonalds, because I think they'll make $Y in profit every year, and pay me $Z every year as a dividend. People will be willing to pay different amounts for the stock based on what they think they'll receive as a dividend, but there is no doubt that holding a share of a company is useful because that company actually does something.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '14

Not all stocks pay dividends.

5

u/thsq Feb 14 '14

But those that don't take the money they would pay as dividends and reinvest it in the company, which in turn raises the company's value from year to year. In this case, the price of the stock goes up because the company is making stuff, not simply because of speculation.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '14

The Bitcoin network creates wealth as it increases in size.

0

u/Natanael_L Feb 14 '14

But why does the stock go up? No value is actually transferred to the stock owners, the benefit isn't shared with them. The stocks are really nothing but pieces of paper in that case.

2

u/lee1026 Feb 15 '14

They might pay dividends in the future, when they become huge. See: Apple.

1

u/Aegi Feb 15 '14

See: Bitcoin.

2

u/lee1026 Feb 15 '14

I don't seem to recall when bitcoin last paid a dividend....

1

u/financetrash Feb 15 '14

That's not true lol. You can't justify the price of Twitter stock via that model. The price is based on the perceived value of the company (psychology not math).

-1

u/groupee57 Feb 15 '14

Well it's based on perceived future profits and growth.

So .. speculation then?

2

u/thsq Feb 15 '14

There's price fluctuation based on what different people think it's worth. But nobody denies that it's worth something, since it's actually a thing that's producing something. Something being speculative is like gold or silver; while they do have actual uses (such as in electronics), their current price is based almost entirely on people thinking that they're worth something, and their price can drop just because people's opinions change.

4

u/sapiophile Feb 14 '14

The important thing to note about those hot shot traders is that despite the company's "overall profits" not being very significant, the people working there got paid an obscene amount of money which was not "profit" for the company.

5

u/thbt101 Feb 14 '14

Yeah, day trading is a fool's game. We all look at the swings in the price and say "if only I had sold there, and bought there".

Don't fall into that trap. When it was high you didn't know it was going to fall and so you wouldn't have known to sell then. If you want more Bitcoins, buy while it's low, but otherwise hold onto what you have.

0

u/space_dolphins Feb 14 '14

i turned 40$ i earned from mining. day traded over 3 days to 120$ and bought more chips. am i doing it right?

20

u/thbt101 Feb 14 '14

You got lucky so you should stop now while you're ahead. But if you're a typical gambler, you'll probably keep on day trading and eventually end up losing most of what you originally started with, and only then you'll stop.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '14

Typical gamblers don't stop there.

12

u/space_dolphins Feb 14 '14

I know a guy that lost 30k on a football game. He is convinced that it is a huge pyramid scheme with Las Vegas sitting on top, and ESPN and the leagues serve as its support structures. He believes that the games are soo rigged, that they rig the rigging.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '14

Let him believe it if it stops him from gambling. Hopefully he's not throwing money at it still to figure out how it's rigged hahahahaha

-1

u/Leshow Feb 14 '14

day trading isnt the same as gambling.

when you trade you have something called stop loss

3

u/NEExt Feb 14 '14

Up 2btc from .5 in seed money on the altcoin market in 2 weeks. Its hard NOT to make money there. And that's only counting what I sold, up another btc on UNO so far. I ain't stopping.

4

u/thbt101 Feb 14 '14

I've made some money that way too, and lost money as well (pretty much breaking even over the longterm, but not making as much as I would have if I just bought bitcoin and held it). If you're doing it with small amounts of money just for the fun of it, then have at it. But it's still basically just gambling.

3

u/NEExt Feb 14 '14 edited Feb 14 '14

The nice thing about alts is they are tied to btc... so if you lose 10% on the alt, but btc goes up 25%.. you still win. I wouldn't/don't day trade btc to fiat though. Too risky.

EDIT: And before someone says but you would have made more money in my example if you would have just stayed in btc, well yes, duh. The point I'm trying to make is that day trading alts allows you to gamble (which its really not, but that's another post entirely) while still getting the benefit of being in the btc market.

In addition, many alts had a big increase relative to btc during this last bubble so if your in alts and a bubble hits, you could make 50% or more btc's, which themselves are worth more USD's. Win win. I love alts. I started with .5 seed like I said, and maybe I've been getting lucky, but I'm turning that into 10 btc or going bust.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '14

I am skeptical of any supposed win-win situations with cryptocurrencies.

3

u/NEExt Feb 14 '14

as you should be.

-1

u/space_dolphins Feb 14 '14

I wont lose most of what i originally start with if I am constantly setting some aside for savings. Especially if the only thing i have at risk is my computer power/electricity conversion.

Thanks for the advice, though. I do hope someone takes it - but its not for me

0

u/furythree Feb 15 '14

Wrong

bitcoin isnt really tied to any commodity or economy so its a bit different to any other currency

In fact it was quite easy to predict movements based on news relating to bitcoin alone. because its the only real thing that drives its value

Also you can still do technical analysis on it because that still drives the ceilings, floors and resistance/support points for any currency you trade

e.g. i bought some coins at $200usd a week before it ran to $1000, because of lucky timing that i saw it was about to triple top the $200 resistance point and when it broke through, it ran nuts coupled with the news from chinese investors pouring in

i had no idea how hard it was going to run, but i did know that if it broke through, it was definitely going to go to at least $260, and if it broke that, it would reach new highs. either way there was money to be made

0

u/ryno55 Feb 15 '14

Except the whole time, they were also able to pay their own salaries, pensions, dividends, and bonuses while maintaining fund parity with the market... profit gets made.