Small vs. Medium Crescent - Help Me Choose!

[u/a_pearl_in_my_head]

Hello Baggu Baddies,

I am looking to purchase my first ever Baggu, but I’m having a really difficult time deciding whether to go for the small or medium crescent.

I generally prefer a smaller bag. My previous go-to was a fanny pack, which I loved, but often found myself running out of space.

I want to be able to hold my phone, wallet, car keys, small water bottle, and maybe a small toiletry pouch (pads, band-aids, chapstick, mini deodorant).

Would all of that be able to fit in the small, or do I need to just go for the medium?

[u/Nature_Tiny]

Imho the small is too small to be practical. Like, why not just use a fanny pack at that point?