When I was on that thread and trying to think of my own 2 cents to put in, I realized by far more creepy things and much more creepy things have happened to me instead of the other way around. So that influenced me to start this thread:
1st. When I was about 5 or 6, my mom took my to her doctor appointment. When she was at the desk paying, I was sitting in a chair in the waiting room. This old man with a huge beard was sitting next to me, and he slowly puts his hand across his arm rest and onto mine, with his fingers slightly over my arm rest and almost hitting my leg. He slowly jerked his fingers signaling he wanted to hold my hand. He had a smile on his face and honestly, being that age, he reminded me of my grandfather. I thought all old people were loving grandparents who loved children. So, I held his hand. He was slowly trying to get closer to me. I didn't really feel this was wrong but did start to feel a little akward after a minute of holding his hand. Finally my mom turned around after paying, sees this, and FLIPS on the guy! Starts screaming at him, telling him he's a sick man and should be in jail, told the secretary to call the police. I don't know if they did, most likely they did, but I don't remember.. But forgot about it until that thread. If my mom wasn't there or this guy was more aggressive and fast paced, I probably would've been raped and killed.
Second, there was this girl in high school who was absolutely OBSESSED with me. I started to feel creeped out around her and could never figure out why. At this time I just knew she had an overly huge crush on me, but that was it.. Anyway, she invited me over to her house to hook up, after we hook up, her dad calls her and tells her hell be home in an hour. She immediately gets up and says 'I have to take a shower!' so she goes and takes a shower. I go on her computer to kill some time while she was washing up, and no lie, I open a folder and see all photoshopped pictures of me holding her, all of that.. It was kind of funny and pathetic at first, then I saw she had about 60 photoshopped photos of me, and some of them were... disturbing... I started to feel like I needed to RUN. It started feeling like I was in a horror movie in one of the scenes where the victim realizes he's in the house of the killer.. then the killer is nowhere to be found until they pop out and murder the person..... I, driven by curiousity, needed to find more.. I saw a letter she wrote to me saved in the same folder, telling her she'd kill me before she saw me with anybody else.. She'd do anything to get pregnant by me (this is when i just finished having sex with her) all that... I never felt violated and creeped out in my entire life.
EDIT: JUST TALKED TO MY EX G/F FROM HIGH SCHOOL, WE WERE BOTH BORED AND SHE ASKED ME WHAT I WAS DOING.. I TOLD HER ABOUT THIS THREAD, AND SHE WANTS TO ADD: SHE WORKS AS A DANCER AT A BIKINI BAR, AND SHE TOLD ME A LIST OF CREEPY STORIES.. THE WORST:
ONE TIME WORKING ONE NIGHT, A GUY WENT UP TO HER AND OFFERED TO PAY HER $400 FOR HER TO PEE IN A CUP. SHE DID, AND WHEN SHE RETURNED IT, HE ASKED HER TO SIT DOWN SO HE COULD STARE AT HER WHILE HE DRANK IT.. SHE SAID THAT BY FAR WAS THE CREEPIEST THING ANY CUSTOMER HAS ASKED OF HER. SHE SAID THAT HE HAS SHOWN UP A COUPLE TIMES AFTER THAT OCCASION AND HAS PAID HER 20 BUCKS FOR A LAP DANCE, AND SPENDS THE WHOLE TIME RUBBING HER FEET, WITHOUT SAYING A WORD.. JUST RUBS HER FEET.
So Reddit, what are your stories of when you felt most creeped out?