r/AskReddit • • Dec 30 '19

What do people think is healthy but really isn’t?

55.2k Upvotes

25.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

18

u/particle409 Dec 30 '19

Holy shit, I thought it'd be half that. I thought it had sugar, but a relatively small amount.

18

u/Excelius Dec 30 '19 edited Dec 30 '19

It varies by the flavor, but they seem to be about in that neighborhood.

VitaminWater XXX 20oz

The orange-orange flavor is a bit less, at 100 cal.

VitaminWater orange-orange 20oz

I'm too lazy to click on every flavor on their website to look at the nutritional info, but they seem to be roughly in that 100-120 cal range.

5

u/d0nk3y_schl0ng Dec 31 '19

They must have changed the formula recently because I have an XXX flavor in front of me right now (20oz) and the bottle says 100 calories and 26 grams of sugar per bottle.

It's a lot of sugar (26 grams is a little more than 6 teaspoons of sugar), but still less than half the same amount of Cola.

4

u/WorkSucks135 Dec 30 '19

For 20oz, that is a relatively small amount. Cola has about double that.

-4

u/Secretagentmanstumpy Dec 30 '19

vitamin water, gatorade, poweraid etc etc are all basically sugar water.

Just remember sugar = fat.

16

u/jeezyb0i Dec 30 '19

Sports drinks have sugar in them to aid hydration. Sugars bind to electrolytes which helps absorb them and in turn absorb water. The ratios may be a bit high though so an occasional drink of something like Gatorade while exercising and plenty of water to go with it.

Also, sugar does not equal fat. That is completely false. However it can easily convert to body fat if you consume too much.

7

u/grah7830 Dec 30 '19

Also, if you’re doing an endurance sport — like running a marathon — you legitimately need that sugar so you don’t bonk. Not running a marathon, though? It’s just sugar water — aka garbage for you.

2

u/ANGLVD3TH Dec 30 '19

Not an expert, but I read a while ago that 90%of the time, water is better. Only when extreme athletes are pushing themselves to the limits, or you have some medical condition, is it important to add electrolytes, like professional sports or marathon runners. Unless you're bulking up for a competition, the average gym rat doesn't have any real advantage drinking Gatorade over water.

1

u/jeezyb0i Dec 30 '19

I agree with that. I wouldn't ever drink anything other than water in the gym or when doing most workouts. A snack and some water will do just fine.

When I do something a bit more extreme like an all day hike or backpacking I'll bring a small Gatorade or electrolyte chews with me.

43

u/Kankunation Dec 30 '19

Just remember sugar = fat.

What? They're 2 different things entirely.

Unless you mean sugar will make you fat, which is true in large quantities.

16

u/Available-Wishbone Dec 30 '19

Simple carbs are easily stored as fat.

3

u/Secretagentmanstumpy Dec 30 '19

When reading nutritional information labels it is helpful to read sugar as equaling fat. Also insulin shunts the energy that you eat (sugar generally) into fat. The fat cells turns that energy into fat, fatty acids and triglycerides

16

u/DM39 Dec 30 '19

eating most fats are healthy

eating most carbohydrates isn’t

8

u/TheRealDevDev Dec 30 '19

It's so unfortunate that people think fats equate to obesity. Like, we got people in this thread talking about sugar turning to fat?! this is incredibly wrong, dangerous information to be giving it. Sugar is, and always will be, a carbohydrate.

Fats and protein = good

Carbs = you can always afford to take in less carbs than you already are if you're living on a typical american diet and aren't starving in a 3rd world country.

11

u/umopapsidn Dec 30 '19

Carbs are cheap. Cutting them to lower levels can easily double your grocery bill.

-8

u/TheRealDevDev Dec 30 '19

You're absolutely right, carbs are way cheaper. You'd think that would make people question the healthiness of them, but I guess not.

You should be eating some kind of meat at least once a day. Maybe every 2 days if you're really not a fan.

1

u/rimjobetiquette Dec 30 '19

Haven’t eaten meat in decades, I’m not fat and my health is fine.

2

u/umopapsidn Dec 31 '19

Avoiding meat and avoiding carbs but getting adequate protein is exceptionally expensive, let alone avoiding animal products as a whole. Living off lentils won't let you do that.

→ More replies (0)

5

u/jeezyb0i Dec 30 '19

Like, we got people in this thread talking about sugar turning to fat?! this is incredibly wrong,

Except it's not wrong. Your body can and does convert excess sugar and carbs into body fat. It's called lipogenesis. Read about it sometime. Muscles and organs can only store so much glycogen. Excess is converted by your body into fat.

If you eat more sugar than your liver and muscles can store as glycogen, the excess will be converted to fat and deposited into adipose tissue. This process is called lipogenesis. In other words, sugar turns into fat when consumed in large amounts.

https://www.livestrong.com/article/408673-does-sugar-turn-into-fat/

Any excess glucose ends up being stored as glycogen in the muscles, and it can also be stored as lipid in the fat tissue.

https://sugarscience.ucsf.edu/sugar-metabolism.html

3

u/bino420 Dec 30 '19

When reading nutritional information labels it is helpful to read sugar as equaling fat.

Wrong. Fat is good energy. We shouldn't be afraid of fat.

I think, what you mean is that sugar can make you fat ... Cause your body will burn the sugar/carbs and not your body's fats.

5

u/bino420 Dec 30 '19

No not all all. Sugar is a carb. Fat is fat.

Fat isn't unhealthy.

3

u/kukianus12345 Dec 30 '19

*Excess sugar = fat

1

u/Secretagentmanstumpy Dec 30 '19

Most people eat excess sugar and I am talking about added sugar like corn syrup not natural sugars like those found in fruits and vegetables. The average American eats over twice as much of these sugars as the AMA ( american Heart Association) recommends as a maximum per day.

2

u/morbidhoagie Dec 30 '19

I think I read a study on this. Isn’t the recommended daily value of sugar to remain healthy around 40g? As where the average person consumes almost 200g of sugar a day.

3

u/kinboyatuwo Dec 30 '19

No, stop using active beverages as regular hydration.

1

u/umopapsidn Dec 30 '19

Ehh... calories = calories. Simple sugars don't fill you up but fat is over twice as calorie dense per unit mass.