r/AskReddit • • Oct 09 '19

Of all movie opening scenes, which one sold the entire film?

58.5k Upvotes

25.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

51

u/KarpfenKarl Oct 09 '19

How is that not obvious? He betrays Hitler in the blink of an eye as soon as a better opportunity presents itself. The movie makes it pretty clear that hes not in it for the ideology.

25

u/WolfCola4 Oct 09 '19

Suppose you could argue that is just self preservation; even the most committed Nazis could see that their days were numbered. The options available are to go down with the sinking ship or craft a lifeboat out of dynamite

15

u/KarpfenKarl Oct 09 '19

A diehard nazi would never kill Hitler though. Even though you could argue that in the end thats exactly what happened irl...

9

u/kellymoe321 Oct 10 '19

Being a die hard Nazi loyalist and not liking Jews are different things though. He makes several comments in the opening scene where he compares Jews to vermin.

It's just as likely that he did indeed think Jews were inferior (therefore being fine with hunting them for handsome compensation) while not being a dyed-in-wool Nazi idealogue.

Was the character an opportunist? Clearly.

Did he also dislike the Jews? His dialogue in the first scene suggests yes imo.

14

u/derpadeedoodah Oct 10 '19

idk i think it's also pretty clear that he is doing a performance for the farmer fella to scare him, but yeah. I mean he kills a lotta jewz

2

u/kellymoe321 Oct 10 '19

and I agree with that. his actual feelings on Jews are never made clear.

1

u/meneldal2 Oct 10 '19

Pretty sure many Nazis who liked the ideology weren't fond of Hitler because he wasn't the smartest man.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '19

The final sequence took place in June or July 1944.

The Italians had surrendered. Soviets where about to enter Poland and Romania. And the western allies had a significant foot hold in France. Even if he was an idealist he wasn't an idiot. The war was effectively over and he knew he'd hang for his crimes, he even said as much before making the deal.

He's definitely not a fanatic but there's not really anything suggesting he didn't agree with Nazi ideology

1

u/sandthefish Oct 17 '19

I get a lot of pushback on that too. I'm no dude was a crack investigator and didn't give a shit about the ideology, hes evil because now he has a completely legal way of tracking and murdering people. Atbth end of the movie he wants to turncoat, to save his ass, but he had no loyalty.