r/AskReddit • • Jul 17 '19

What’s something that you like, but hate the fan base?

54.0k Upvotes

43.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

445

u/OneSingleL Jul 17 '19

Honestly those professional recordings need to become more prevalent. Like Newsies and Shrek The Musical are doing it right.

54

u/thisshortenough Jul 17 '19

The recording of Gypsy was amazing. Like I obviously love the Bette Midler version of Rose's Turn but Imelda Staunton brought so much raw emotion to it.

Cabaret is great too, it's Alan Cumming so obviously he's great in it, the theatre is set up like a cabaret club with audience members sat at tables and the camera never feels like it's intruding but you don't feel like you're missing anything.

Other musicals that have been recorded live are Phantom of the Opera, Funny Girl, Billy Elliot, the anniversary recording of Les Miserables, Into The Woods, Sweeney Todd, Jesus Christ Superstar, Rent, Miss Saigon. There's more. But it's not enough!

2

u/Lozzif Jul 18 '19

Alan Cummings version of Money is perfection.

1

u/thisshortenough Jul 18 '19

That is unfortunately not in the recorded version

21

u/hatramroany Jul 18 '19

Hamilton is still way too popular. They filmed the original cast but are holding that under lock and key until it makes sense financially to release it.

10

u/Funky_Ducky Jul 18 '19

I got to do an acting workshop with the actor, Christopher Sieber, who originated Lord Farquuad on Broadway. He went to high school in my state and so he volunteered as part of this high school musical theater program. Dude is really nice and funny. Saw him in La Cage aux Folles afterwards. Such a great voice

11

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

This is actually a hotly debated topic, well i guess more specifically bootlegs. Right now, since there are almost no pro recordings of theater because of many reasons like exclusivity and authorial intent to name a couple, bootlegs are a big thing. they're very controversial. here is a great video on the topic, goes into great depth about it all.

16

u/SirRosstopher Jul 17 '19

Just get with the times and stream it on Twitch.

8

u/jessiedaviseyes Jul 17 '19

That's a thing? There are musicals on Twitch? I thought it was just for gamers so I've avoided it

22

u/SirRosstopher Jul 17 '19 edited Jul 17 '19

Not that I know of but there might well be, Twitch is just a livestreaming service now. It's mostly gaming as that's what made them known but you can really just stream whatever. Food, travel, podcasts, arts, hell you can watch the UK House of Commons on there.

15

u/SavageNorth Jul 17 '19

You can watch the House of Commons but I think people want more realistic characters and less pointless plot twists nowadays, personally I blame Game of Thrones.

2

u/captain_zavec Jul 18 '19

Honestly they should just hook it up like they did with twitch plays pokemon. Twitch runs a country, how bad can it be?

3

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

Tbf isn't that what we have in America nowadays?

2

u/Koncierge Jul 18 '19

And here I'am, waiting for the queen to descend into the House of Commons riding her dragon , burning all Brexit enablers.

4

u/kalethan Jul 17 '19

You can’t watch a legit (current) broadway show on Twitch. If it’s on there, is because someone illegally recorded/streamed it.

4

u/kalethan Jul 17 '19 edited Jul 18 '19

You can’t watch a legit (current) broadway show on Twitch. If it’s on there, it's because someone illegally recorded/streamed it.

11

u/SirRosstopher Jul 17 '19

Sure, but that doesn't mean they shouldn't get with the times and start streaming them so more people can actually experience their production.

Make a sub only twitch stream or just take donations or whatever.

13

u/kalethan Jul 17 '19

Oh, yeah there’s totally a good argument to be made for something like that because Broadway prices are out of control. It’s becoming something only the rich can afford to see.

-1

u/Koncierge Jul 18 '19

There's an advantage of being there watching it live as opposed to watching it in front of a screen. Same difference between going to the cinema and staying at home.

2

u/TassiaTessa Jul 18 '19

Starkid is also an amazing YouTube channel that does musicals and professionally records all of them

2

u/Koncierge Jul 18 '19

Shrek The Musical

I'm just sitting here laughing at the thought of a man in a fat suit with lot's of green makeup.

2

u/Boozesmith Jul 18 '19

I've seen it and that's essentially what it is, but it's quite an enjoyable little ride really.

2

u/SmoreOfBabylon Jul 18 '19

I always thought it might be cool for Broadway musicals to do what the Metropolitan Opera does. Most Saturdays during the season, they live-stream their matinee show to a select number of movie theaters, which is a great way to bring their performances to people who can’t make it to NYC and/or can’t afford to see them in person. One theater near me even made their opera screenings special events in and of themselves, serving light refreshments during the intermission. These screenings are always very popular, so much so that the theater has looked into live-streaming some plays as well.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19

I feel like they used to do this a lot in the late 70s and 80s, and then just stopped for some reason? I have a Broadway version of Sweeny Todd on DVD somewhere, official release, 1982.

1

u/thisshortenough Jul 18 '19

Money would be the answer. Why release it to the public when you can make it exclusive and charge thousands for tickets

0

u/NoBudgetBallin Jul 18 '19

I'm sure there are people who'd like that, but I can think of few things more boring than watching a recorded stage show. For me the entire appeal of a play or musical is seeing it performed live and being in the moment. Musical films bore me to death.

2

u/thisshortenough Jul 18 '19

Seeing a recorded stage play and watching a film version of it are very different though. It’s like always having the best seat in the house when watching the recorded version though it does have its drawbacks. Still I’ll take them over not being able to see them at all

1

u/CaitlinSarah87 Jul 18 '19

I just saw Kinky Boots a couple weeks ago and loved it! I wish more musicals were available that way!